The Communist Party and the rank and file
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 47 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 47
In a limited way, the British shop stewards had developed one essential of a socialist approach, the idea of workers councils. What they lacked was an understanding of the need for a political party which could mesh with and develop further the rank and file movement and prepare the way for the conquest of power.
Many of the leading shop stewards were now to take that struggle further by joining the new Communist Party.
At the workplace level itself, the wartime experience represented a development. As Cole points out: "While the number of stewards was thus rapidly increasing throughout practically the whole range of the munitions industries, their positions and duties were also rapidly transformed. The wartime steward became, to a large extent, a negotiator on workshop grievance, a representative of the workers by whom he was appointed in dealing with the foreman and with management over all manner of workshop problems...
"More and more the stewards undertook these daily problems of workshop administration, calling in the union official only when they were unable to bring about a direct settlement by formal or informal negotiation...It became more and more necessary for all the stewards to act in regular cooperation and to devise a common organisation within each department and for each establishment as a whole.
«Consequently, shop stewards committees, workshop committees and works committees, all alike, based on the shop steward system, began to develop on a considerable scale...
"Usually the stewards in a particular shop appointed from their number a secretary or convenor who had power to call meetings of all the stewards...In the large establishment, consisting of a number of considerable shops or departments, an inclusive body was often constituted to represent the trade unionists in the works as a whole. Sometimes the convenors from each of the shops were appointed, usually by a meeting of all the stewards in the establishment to form a works committee."
Workshop Organisation)
In 1920 an agreement with the Engineering Employers Federation gave shop stewards formal recognition and a place in procedure. But this system, with its close parallels in present steward organisation, was short-lived as unemployment soared.
As the Sheffield stewards leader, JT Murphy, said in 1922: 'In England we have had a powerful shop stewards movement. But it can and only does exist in given objective conditions. These necessary conditions at the moment in England do not exist. How can you build factory organisations in empty and depleted workshops while you have a great reservoir of unemployed workers?"
"From the beginning Minority Movement we learn that it is possible organise the hardest militants together even when the economic tide firmly antagonistic"
Unemployment was 27% in engineering in 1921. After the employers' victorious lock-out in 1922 the AEU, as it now was, had lost a quarter of its 1920 membership.
In industry generally the erosion of shop floor strength led to dependence on national collective bargaining and the official union leaders were back in the saddie.
The shop stewards leaders were ruthlessly victimised. As early as 1920 Arthur Gleason wrote: 'The unofficial shop stewards movement is at ebb tide because of the percentage of the unemployed in the metal trades. The man at the gate determines the status of the man at the bench."
It was precisely during this down-turn that Communist Party militants were able to take up and transform the earlier traditions of rank and fileism. They provided, in the Minority Movement, which they sponsored, the clearest programme yet developed for an organisation within the unions which can act as a bridge from the trade union organisation of today to the working class organisation of tomorrow.
Founded in August 1924, the programme of the movement began with demands for improvements in hours and wages, the spread of trade unionism, the democratisation of the union and the building of factory committees. It then went on to place demands which would stem from struggle over these issues on the future Labour Government. It stated clearly the necessity for the removal of the capitalist system, constantly warning that the question of government was vital (a warning that might be observed by today's neo-syndicalists such as the SWP).
"This is not a question outside trade unionism but the central question for trade unionism. On every side it is realised that trade unionism is not enough and that only a workers' government can solve these problems." (Report of the First Minority Movement Conference)
The story of the Minority Movement is a big subject and deserves to be told in detail elsewhere. At its foundation it grouped together representatives of 200,000 workers. Nor did the Minority Movement concentrate purely on the 'little things' , on factory issues alone, but on issues such as the democratisation of the unions and the TUC, and the forging of links with workers in other countries.
But the Minority Movement was soon derailed by the defeat in the General Strike and the degeneration of the Communist Party. For reasons of Russian foreign policy, the CP in the mid-'20s got too close to those who sold out the General Strike then, from 1928 to 1934 it tried to build its own sectarian trade unions, ducking out of the mass movement.
From the beginning of the Minority Movement we can learn that it is possible to organise the hardest militants together even when the economic tae is firmiy antagonistic. That it is essential to do this on a firm political basis and that it is essential to give such a grouping a trade unionwide, class-wide and international perspectives.
Scan page 48
The Aircraft Shop Stewards National Council now attempted to embrace all