Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Engineering was the first heartland

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 46–47 · about 1,824 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 46 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 46

Engineering was always the heartland of strong workplace • organisation. The formal system in the Amalgamated Society of Engineers was for the union outside the workplace to lay down rules and customs.

If employers did not accept the conditions the union laid down, society men shouldn't work there. But this system was always supplemented by informal bargaining within the shop. Given the control the craftsmen had over their job a whole range of custom and practice flourished and district committees began to appoint delegates within the workplace.

From the 1880s the development of new technology - the introduction of capstan and turret lathes, machine grinders, the radial arm drill, all capable of being operated by the semi-skilled - undermined the position of the time-served craft With increasing international competition from Germany and the USA in the period to 1914 the employers pressed for drastic changes in the organisation of work. They attempted to weaken the unions, the barrier to putting less skilled workers on the machines at lower rates and to introducing piecework.

Disputes over these issues gave stewards a greater bargaining role. Stewards received a further fillip from the 1897 agreement which broke the closed shop, lifted restrictions on overtime and the number of apprentices and brought in payment by results with job prices to be fixed in the shop. That was where the locus of activity shifted. The district committee could no longer uphold the craft rules. In strong workplaces the stewards could.

The introduction of new tools and the growth of management techniques led to numerous disputes over discipline. The piecework system provided a negotiating role over money for stewards. So in the years to 1914 the shop stewards system developed as a means of workplace negotiation and as the guardian of job controls.

These developments were not limited to the ASE. Tom Bell of the Scottish Ironmoulders recalled that in the West of Scotland in the early years of the century, "Every foundry had a shop steward. Within three hours of starting a job your card was collected."

Nor were stewards limited to the skilled unions. As early as 1872 the functions of stewards in the Tyneside and National Labourers Union were extended from recruitment and collection to negotiation. In the upsurge of the new unionism after 1889 the rules of the Gasworkers, the National Amalgamated Union of Labour specifically provided for stewards.

Tom Bell's judgement was true of many unions: 'The shop steward was an integral part of the trade union machinery, especially to the engineers prior to the war. Most unions had their delegates on the job or in the shop for the collection of contributions checking up on defaulting members for reporting changes in the condition of work and as a link between the union branch and the work."

In engineering, stewards had a greater negotiating role. Committees were Page 44 New problems, New struggles established. GDH Cole describes stewards — all those years ago — being given an office, access to all departments and full facilities for negotiation with the rate fixers.

Not only was workers' organisation at the point of production a tremendous gain. It was soon asserting its independence from the bureaucratised fulltime officials.

The years before 1914 saw a tremendous struggle in the ASE between a leadership attempting to impose central negotiating and the districts attempting to maintain local autonomy. This led in 1912 to a Delegate Conference which insisted on the resignation of the Executive. When they refused to go, the delegates tunnelled their way into the union headquarters and physically turned them out.

The militancy of the 'Great Unrest' saw the establishment of rank and file vigilance committees in many unions. Many of the emerging shop stewards were "Despite the socialism of the leadership they failed to put forward a class policy which could unite skilled and unskilled workers and point a way forward by arguing that the upgrading of the unskilled shoul be under the control of workplace committees and that all workers should receive the skilled rate" attracted to the socialist organisations, the British Socialist Party and the Socialist The outbreak of war in 1914 intensified many of these tendencies. A conference of trade union executives agreed with the government that "there shall in no case be a stoppage of work upon munition and other work required for a satisfactory completion of the war". This Treasury agreement was given legal force by the passing of the Munitions Act which also provided for prosecution of workers.

With the union leaders now a part of the machinery of state, the rank and file filled the gap. With more timé and full employment they possessed the capability to defend themselves independently of their leaders. New issues in the workshops - crucially the dilution of skilled trades by employment of less skilled workers -gave a further boost to the development of stewards on a basis which spread beyond the workshop.

The Clyde Workers Committee gave the first formal declaration of independence of the rank and file which was to be the first plank of the movement. «We will support the officials just as long as they rightly represent the workers. But we will act independently immediately they misrepresent them. Being composed of delegates from every shop and untrammelled by obsolete rule or law we claim to represent the true feeling of the workers. We can act immediately according to the rank and the case and the desire of the outlined its aims as:

"(a) To obtain increasing control over workshop conditions;

(b) To regulate the terms upon which the workers shall be employed;

(c) To organise the workers upon a class basis and to maintain the class struggle until the overthrow of the wages system and the establishment of industrial democracy has been obtained."

250-300 delegates met each weekend. There were delegates from engineering, shipbuilding, the miners, railways and shops. many represented militant minorities rather than fully fledged workplace organisation. The crunch came over the key issue of dilution. Despite the socialism of the leadership they failed to put forward a class policy which could unite skilled and unskilled workers and point a way forward by arguing that the upgrading of the unskilled should be under the control of workplace committees and that all workers should receive the skilled rate. Instead, they argued that they would only accept dilution if all industries and national resources were taken over by the government under a system of joint management with the unions. This was a pie in the sky "socialism now" approach.

The government realised the need to remove the committee and adopted a stick-and-carrot approach. Half a dozen plants were selected and dilution implemented in each. When the government could point out that it was in and working smoothly they moved to crack the tougher nuts.

Kirkwood, convenor of the Parkhead Forge, was forbidden to move to other sections in the workplace. The members struck. But they had been isolated. Kirkwood and eight other CWC leaders were arrested and deported from Clydeside, and opposition to dilution collapsed.

The Clydeside Committee had failed build bridges to the rest of the industry and to the unskilled.

The centre of the struggle shifted to Sheffield. Here the principle of dilution had been accepted, but negotiation over its implementation had stimulated workplace organisation. In Sheffield the majority of district committee members were stewards, there was greater coordination between craft organisations than on the Clyde and closer links with the unskilled.

In October 1916 Hargreaves — a local fitter, supposedly exempt — was conscripted. A mass meeting launched the Sheffield Workers Committee which gave seven days notice of strike action if Hargreaves was not released. 12,000 workers struck. A few hours later, Hargreaves was released. But the workers refused to return until he was presented to a mass meeting two days later. This success spurred further action.

The number of stewards in the Sheffield district rose from 60 to 300. The committee was expanded to include the unskilled. The idea was that the District Stewards Committee should stimulate workshop committees covering all grades, and a national committee.

A national stewards meeting was to be held at Easter 1917, but in March a strike broke out when a Rochdale firm sacked 500 engineers for refusing to train women transferred from shell production to commercial work. 200,000 workers struck in Lancashire, Sheffield and Coventry.

Scan page 47

The government tried to crush the movement as it had on the Clyde by arresting eight of its leaders. In response, one hundred delegates from 34 different districts met for three days and set up a national shop stewards leadership. After negotiations the arrested men were freed pending trial and the strikes petered out.

Now the impact of the Russian Revolution, war-weariness, peace propaganda and severe food shortages all led to a growing working class opposition questioning the continuance of the war itself. This mood found a focus when, at the start of 1918, the government introduced the Military Service Bill to take men from the munitions factories to the trenches. The National Conference of the shop stewards movement, meeting on 5 and 6 Januâry 1918, decided to sound out the feeling in the districts. The conference recommended strike action against the Bill and called on the government to consider peace terms.

Clyde, Barrow, Coventry and London supported the call, but crucial districts such as Sheffield and Manchester, who had tested workshop opinion, said: "They were opposed to strike action against the war." The movement drew back from a confrontation with thé state into a sectional demand for exemption for the skilled.

Despite its involvement in the 40-hours strike on Clyde in 1919, the stewards movement never recovered the initiative and disintegrated with the collapse of war production and full employment.

The shop stewards movement contained two elements: a militancy by privileged workers to defend their threatened position and, within that, strains of opposition to the trade union tops, the war and the state. In the end, the former tendency won out.

Nonetheless, the movement was important in popularising and illustrating key ideas which were to remain vital as a bequest to future generations; the idea of a movement, of powerful organisation at the point of production where the workers are strongest; and, going beyond this, an organisation to link workplaces at local and national level and establish an independent bulwark directly answerable to the workers against the official union leaders who tended to be incorporated by the employers and the state.

Where they were weakest was in sometimes believing that a small but key section of workers could take successful action by themselves; in their neglect of work within the wider union; and in their lack of examination of wider political problems. They never solved the key problem of how socialists could establish a bridge, both organisationally and ideologically, between day-to-day militant trade unionism and the problem of removing the exploiting class from power

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →