Trotsky on boom slump and revolution
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 42 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 42
Why did working class militancy collapse just when it was needed stand up against the most savage ruling class onslaught for 40 years? This is one of the most important questions facing those whose hopes and struggle for socialism centre on the working class.
There had been no crushing demoralising defeat before the return of the Tory government in May 1979. Quite the opposite in fact - the movement had shown its mettle, and plenty of muscle, in the 'Winter of Discontent' in 1978-9.
The explanation is to be sought the complex interaction between effects of the Tory victory, the deepening slump bringing mass unemployment and the economic devastation of whole areas, the bureaucratisation of the top layers the shop stewards' movement, anc the collaboration with the government of the national union leaders.
It is all the more difficult for the would-be Marxist left to come to terms with what has happened because 'primitive slumpism' - the belief and expectation that the inevitable economic crisis, when it came, would radicalise the working class — had been a very popular response during the boom years to the capitalist argument that prosperity had bourgeoisified the working class.
Having had one dogma exploded, some pundits are now putting forwa another, pretending that a new economic upswing will inevitably, and of itself, produce a new resurgence of industrial militancy.
In the following address to the Communist International, from 1921 - directed against those who refusec to see that European capitalism had temporarily re-stabilised itself following the crisis that shook the world after the Russian revolution -Leon Trotsky shows that there is no mechanical or direct relationship between slump and working class radicalisation.
The reciprocal relation between boom and crisis in economy and the development of revolution is of great interest to us not only from the point of theory but above all practically.
Many of you will recall that Marx and Engels wrote in 1851 - when the boom was at its peak — that it was necessary at that time to recognise that the Revolution of 1848 had terminated or, at any rate, had been interrupted until the next crisis.
Engels wrote that while the crisis of 1847 was the mother of revolution, the boom of 1849-51 was the mother of trumphant counter-revolution. It would, however, be very one-sided and utterly false to interpret these judgements in the sense that a crisis invariably engenders revolutionary action while a boom, on the contrary, pacifies the working class.
The Revolution of 1848 was not born out of the crisis. The latter merely provided the last impetus. Essentially the revolution grew out of the contradictions betproblems, ween the needs of capitalist development and the fetters of the semi-feudal social and state system. The irresolute and halfway Revolution of 1848 did, however, sweep away the remnants of the regime of guilds and serfdom and thereby extended the framework of capitalist development. Under these conditions and these conditions alone, the boom of 1851 marked the beginning of an entire epoch of capitalist prosperity which lasted till 1873.
In citing Engels it is very dangerous to overlook these basic facts. For it was precisely after 1850, when Marx and Engels made their observations, that there set in not a normal or regular situation, but an era of capitalist Sturm und Drang (storm and stress) for which the soil had been cleared by the Revolution of 1848. This is of decisive importance here. This storm-and-stress era, during which prosperity and the favourable conjuncture were very strong, while the crisis was merely superficial and short-lived - it was precisely this period that ended with revolution. At issue here is not whether and improvement in the conjuncture is possible, but whether the fluctuation of the conjuncture are proceeding along an ascending or descending curve. This is the most important aspect of the whole question.
Can we expect the same effects to follow the economic upswing of 1919-20? Under no circumstances. The extension of the framework of capitalist development was not even involved here. Does this mean that a new commercial-industrial upswing is excluded in the future, and even in the more or less near future? Not at all! I have already said that so long as capitalism remains alive it continues to inhale and exhale. But in the epoch which we have entered — the epoch of retribution for the drain and destruction of wartime, the epoch of levelling out in reverse - upswings can be only of a superficial and primarily speculatory character, while the crises become more and more prolongand deeper-going.
Historical development has not led to the victorious proletarian dictatorship in Central and Western Europe. But it is the most brazen and at the same time the most stupid lie to attempt to conclude from this, as do the reformists, that the economic equilibrium of the capitalist world has been surreptitiously restored. This is not claimed even by the crassest reactionaries, who are really capable of thinking, for example, Professor Hoetzch. In his review of the year this professor says in effect that the year 1920 did not bring victory to the revolution, but neither did it restore capitalist world economy...the curtailment of production continues...profound economic depression.
On the basis of this economic depression the bourgeoisie will be compelled to exert stronger and stronger pressure upon the working class. This is already to be seen in the cutting of wages which has started in the full-blooded capitalist countries: in America and in England, and then throughout all of Europe. This leads to great struggles over wages. Our task is to extend these struggles, by basing ourselves on a clear understanding of the economic situation. This is quite obvious.
It might be asked whether the great struggles over wages, a classic example of which is the miners' strike in England, will lead automatically to the word revolution, to the final civil war and the struggle for the conquest of political power. However, it is not Marxist to pose the question in such a way. We have no automatic guarantees of development. But when the crisis is replaced by a transitory favourable conjuncture, what will this signify for our development? Many comrades say that if an improvement takes place in this epoch it would be fatal for our revolution. No, under no circumstances. In general, there is no automatic dependence of the proletarian revolutionary movement upon a crisis. There is only a dialectical interaction. It is essential to understand this.
Let us look at the relations in Russia. The 1905 revolution was defeated. The workers bore great sacrifices. In 1906 and 1907 the last revolutionary flare-ups occurred and by the autumn of 1907 a great world crisis broke out. The signal for it was given by Wall Street's Black Friday. Throughout 1907 and 1908 and 1909 the most terrible crisis reigned in Russia too. It killed the movement completely, because the workers had suffered so greatly during the struggle that this depression could only act to dishearten them. There were many disputes among us over what would lead to the revolution: a crisis or a favourable conjuncture?
At that time many of us defended the viewpoint that the Russian revolutionary movement could be regenerated only by a favourable economic conjuncture. And that is what took place. In 1910, 1911 and 1912, there was an improvement in our economic situation and a favourable conjuncture which acted to reassemble the demoralised and devitalised workers who had lost their courage. They realised again
Scan page 43
how important they were in production: and they passed over to an offensive, first in the economic field and later in the political field as well. On the eve of the war the working class had become so consolidated, thanks to this period of prosperity, that it was able to pass to a direct assault.
And should we today, in the period of the greatest exhaustion of the working class resulting from the crisis and the continual struggle, fail to gain victory, which is possible, then a change in the conjuncture and a rise in living standards would not have a harmful effect upon the revolution, but would be on the contrary highly propitious. Such a change could prove harmful only in the event that the favourable conjuncture marked the beginning of a long epoch of prosperity. But a long period of prosperity would signify than an expansion of the market had been attained, which is absolutely excluded. For after all, capitalist economy already embraces the terrestrial globe. Europe's impoverishment and America's sumptuous renascence on the huge war market corroborate the conclusion that this prosperity cannot be restored through the capitalist development of China, Siberia, South America and other countries, where American capitalism is of course seeking and creating outlet markets but on a scale in no way commensurate to Europe. It follows that we are on the eve of a period of depression; and this is incontestable.
With such a perspective, a mitigation of the risis would not signify a mortal blow to the evolution but would only enable the working lass to gain a breathing spell during which it ould undertake to reorganise its ranks in order ubsequently to pass over to attack on a firmer asis. This is one of the possibilities. The conent of the other possibility is this: that the risis may turn from acute into chronic, ecome intensified and endure for many years. ll this is not excluded. The possibility remains pen in such a situation that the working class vould gather its last forces and, having learned rom experience, conquer state power in the rost important capitalist countries. The only hing excluded is the automatic restoration of apitalist equilibrium on a new foundation and « capitalist upswing in the next few years. This is absolutely impossible under the conditions of modern economic stagnation.
Here we approach the question of social equilibrium. After all, it is frequently said -and this is the guiding thought not only of a Cunow but also of Hilferding - that capitalism is being automatically restored on a new foundation. Faith in automatic evolution is the most important and most characteristic trait of opportunism.
If we grant — and let us grant it for the moment — that the working class fails to rise in revolutionary struggle, but allows the bourgeoisie the opportunity to rule the world's destiny for a long number of years, says, two or three decades, then assuredly some sort of new equilibrium will be established. Europe will be thrown violently into reverse gear. Millions of European wokers will die from unemployment and malnutrition. The United States will be compelled to reorient itself on the world market, reconvert its industry, and suffer curtailment for a considerable period. Afterwards, after a new world division of labour is thus established in agony for 15 or 20 or 25 years, a new epoch of capitalist upswing might perhaps ensure...
In short, speaking theoretically and abstractly, the restoration of capitalist equilibrium is possible. But it does not take place in a social and political vacuum — it can take place only through the classes. Every step, no matter how iny, toward the restoration of equilibrium ir economic life is a blow to the unstable social equilibrium upon which the Messrs. Capitalists still continue to maintain themselves. And this is the most important thing. Union officials and Committees: All officials should be elected for definite terms (no more than two years) and subject to recall at any time. Full-time officials should be paid the average wage in their industry.
Union policy-making bodies should be made up of elected lay members only. The same should go for Standing Orders Committees and Appeals Committees.
Full minutes and voting records of policy. making bodies should be circulated. .
National delegate conferences should have supreme policy-making power.
Elections: Voting should be at workplace meetings or by workplace ballot. It should not be by postal ballot. We want informed, collective working class decision-making, not ballots manipulated by Fleet Street liemachines: Election addresses must be circulated unaltered, and candidates and their supporters must have unrestricted rights to circulate literature.
Strikes: Strikes should be automatically official until declared unofficial. All strikes for trade union principles, work conditions or wages should be made official. Strike committees must be elected from (and subject to recall by) mass meetings. Through mass meetings and strike bulletins, they must keep the membership fully informed throughout the strike.
There should be no secret negotiations. Every stage of negotiations should be subject to rank and file ratification at mass meetings. Mass meetings should never be presented with package deals unless each part of the deal has been voted on separately by the meeting beforehand. Workplace Organisation: Shop stewards must be elected at mass meetings held in the workplace, in company time if possible. They should hold regular report-back meetings, also if possible in company time. Joint Shop Stewards' Committees should be set up on a plant, combine and international basis. Technical and clerical workers should also be represented on these com. mittees.
Despite the general need for unity, there will be cases where shop stewards disagree strongly with the majority of the stewards' committee and want to put their minority views to the membership. They should have the right to do so, after notifying the committee of their intention, so long as they also make it clear to the membership what the stewards' majority view is.
Union branches should have the right to meet at the workplace and in work time if possible. If not, crech facilities must be provided to ensure women workers can at. tend. Labour Party workplace branches should be set up with all the rights of ordinary ward branches.
Closed Shop: We must campaign for 100% trade unionism; for the right of trade unionists to enforce closed shops; for the right of trade unionists to discipline fellow workers who scab or flout democratic deci sions; against the check-off system; and against employer-policed 'agency shops'. Women's Rights: Implement the TUC Charter for Women Within Trade Unions.
Proportional representation for women on national executives, conference delegations (including TUC and Labour Party conferences, regional, district and divisional, sectional or rules revision conferences) and, where applicable, local branch committees.
The right of all women's committees, caucuses and conferences to bring resoli tions to the policy-making bodies of the union at that level.
Recognition that sexual harassment is trade union issue and that an offence against women is an offence against trade Support for positive discrimination as a way of compensating for the extra barrier: women face at work, in the trade unions and in politics. Broad Lefts should lead the way by practising it in their own structures.
Black and Immigrant Workers: No discrimination against black or immigrant workers in the unions (including in social clubs). Positive discrimination to ensure real equality. Support for the right to form black caucuses.
Campaigns to recruit immigrant workers to trade unions (using leaflets in the immigrants' own language).
A purge of open racists from all positions in the labour movement. Expulsion of fascist activists from the unions.
A vigorous and sustained trade union fight against racist and sexist job discrimination. Automatic endorsement all strikes against discrimination.
Youth: Full trade union rights for young workers, including the right to strike. Fr mation of youth committees.
The Unemployed: Unionisation of the unemployed, with full rights within unions.
Individual Rights: Right of members to criticise union policy; to meet unofficiall!! and visit other branches; to write, circula and/or sell political literature. Right of ap peal direct to union Appeals Court.
All education or other special qualifications for union office to be abolished. No member to be disqualified from holding union office on political grounds, other than fascist or racist acvitity.
Rights of Branches and District Committees: Defend the rights of trade union branches and district committees against the central union bureaucracy. For the right of branches to take or approve industrial action. Developing Solidarity: Develop links between unions. Expand trades councils to include refiassitation from the unemployed, tenants and students, and, most important direct representation from factory committees and other shop floor organisations Affiliate trade unions to the Labour Party and local union branches to the local CLPs. TUC and Labour Party conference delegations should be bound to follow union policy where it exists. There should be democratic control of the block vote cast at Labour Party conference: delegations should be elected and consist of lay members. Members of all working class parties and tendencies should be eligible for inclusion in the delegation.
Trade union branch delegates to Trades Councils and Labour Parties must report back regularly.
Breaking Collaboration: Trade unions should fight for full independence from the state. Total non co-operation with the Tebbit Law and the Employment Act: state money for postal ballots should be rejected.
The National Economic Development Council and all the other governmental and industrial 'participation' bodies should be opposed and boycotted. Trade unionist must be answerable to the membership, not to joint committees with the bosses.
No interference by the bosses' courts in the internal affairs of the labour movement. Even when an appeal to the courts is motivated by a desire to thwart the right wing bureaucrats, it runs counter to the principles of working class democracy.
New problems, New struggles Page
Scan page 44
The source of rank and file movements is the conflict between the struggle of the working class for better conditions and a new social order, and the increasing reconciliation between the leaders of the trade unions and the capitalist class, their growing integration into the upper reaches of bourgeois society.
In Great Britain we find the first appearance of such movements in the years shortly before the first world war, and it is significant that this phenomenon was preceded and accompanied by a good deal of comment on the declassing of trade union officials.
In 1892 the 'civil service' of British trade unionism numbered between 600 and 700. After the Reform Act of 1867 and the Ballot Act of 1872 had created an important working class electorate largely immune to older forms of pressure, the ruling class began to pay special attention to trade union leaders.
Engels observed in 1874 that 'the chairmen and secretaries of trade unions ...had overnight become important people. They were visited by MPs, by lords pathetic in ill was suadenly made in.
the wishes and needs of the working class." On the advice of the Liberal politician Mundella, the Trades Union Congress held at Nottingham in 1872 was officially welcomed by the city corporation, the delegates were banqueted and invited to the homes of leading citizens, and so forth - the first time such things had happened.
Trade union leaders were pressed to accept seats on Royal Commissions, and in 1886 the general secretary of one of the most important unions stepped into a job in the Labour Bureau formed by Mundella as President of the Board of Trade, an organisation from which the Ministry of Labour later developed. During the 1880s outstanding trade union leaders were more than once entertained by the Prince of Wales (later Edward VII) at Sandringham. In 1890 Broadhurst, secretary to the Trades Union Congress, was exposed as having accepted a gift of shares from Brunner, the chemicals industrialist, in return for political support al an election.
The years of comparative industrial peace, between the 18sus and 188Us, had seen "a shifting of leadership in the trade union world," as the Webbs put it, 'from the casual enthusiast and irresponsible agitator to a class of permanent salarjed officials expressly chosen from out of the rank and file of trade unionists for their superior business capacity."
To the epoch of "defence, not defiance", » corresponded the emergence of a generation of trade union leaders of a difTerent type from those who had laid the foundations in the bitter days of the ComPage 42 Now problems, New struggles bination Acts and Tolpuddle. It was between these "sober, business-like" men and sections of the capitalist class 'that the political alliance was forged which, in different forms and phases, has been with us ever since — 'the bourgeoisie cannot rule alone'. The system which JH Thomas admired for 'making me what I am' was fairly launched."
These trade union leaders saw their task as essentially one of peaceful negotiation with the employers, and this gave rise to a whole network of social relations separating them off from their original class. Assured of a permanent position with a secure income, the trade union officials — "a closely combined and practically irresistible bureaucracy", as the Webbs called them in their book Industrial Democracy which Lenin translated while in exile in Siberia — soon found their different life-experience reflected in a different outlook on the class struggle. In the Webbs' History of Trade Unionism the account of the career of a typical official •Parallel with the rise of the coups of permanent officials was the weakening... in trade union democracy'.
given to the authors in 1893 by a member of one of the great craft unions is quoted:
"Whilst the points at issue no longer affect his own earnings or conditions of employment, any disputes between his members and their employers increase his work and add to his worry. The former vivid sense of the privations and subjection of the artisan's life gradually fades from his mind; and he begins more and more to regard all complaints as perverse and unreasonable. With this intellectual change may come a more invidious transformation. Nowadays the salaried officer of a great union is courted and flattered by the middle class lie. in the language of those days, the capitalists]. He is asked to dine with them, and will admire their well-appointed houses, their fine carpets, the ease and luxury of their "He goes to live in a little villa in a lower middle-class suburb. The move leads to dropping his workmen friends; and his wife changes her acquaintances. With the habits of his new neighbours he insensibly adopts more and more their ideas...His manners to his members ...undergoes a change...A great strike threatens to involve the Society in desperate war. Unconsciously biased by distaste for the hard and unthankful work which a strike entails, he finds himself in small sympathy with the men's demands and eventually arranges a compromise on terms distasteful to a large section of his members."
Brought constantly into friendly intercourse with well-to-do businessmen, civil servants and capitalist politicians, trade union leaders, the Webbs observed, were tempted to bring their spending power up to the same level as that of their associates by making "unduly liberal charges" for their travelling expenses, and even "to accept from employers or from the government those hidden bribes that are decorously veiled as allowances for expenses or temporary salaries for special posts."
This situation, thus already recognisable in the 1890s, is still with us Parallel with the rise of the corps of permanent officials was the weakening, during the years of 'the servile generation" , in trade union democracy. Such institutions as the referendum and the initiative "withered away". The shifting of the basis of the branch in many unions from the place of work to the place of residence helped to atomise the membership and increase their dependence on the officials. The Trades Union Congress of 1895 saw a conscious and open move by the officials to cut away a possible line of rank and file control over their doings, by excluding the representatives of the trades councils, the very bodies which, less than thirty years earlier, had summoned the TUC into existence.
"The trades councils were in fact shut out partly in order to exclude 'agitators' whom the trade union leaders regarded as irresponsible busybodies, and partly in pursuance of a definite policy of centralising industrial control in the hands of the national trade union executives. Obviously a Congress in which two or three million votes might have been cast by the delegates of local bodies would have been a great deal more difficult for the platform to manage than a Congress in which a very small number of national trade unions would cast, under a system of block voting, a majority of total votes. The TUC might have been a very different body if the trades councils had retained their original place in it. That, of course, is precisely why they were not allowed to retain it.
Just as the emergence of a caste of privileged officials, cosily coexisting with capitalism, was reaching completion, a new phase of history opened, that of imperialism, passing into that of the general crisis of capitalism. The conditions characteristic of the second and third quarters of the nineteenth century were swept away for ever, and the workers found themselves under steady and intense attack, at first especially by means of rising prices. Round about 1909, when EJB Allen published his pamphlet Revolutionary Unionism, wide sections of the workers became aware that the militant policy their new circumstances urgently demanded was being sabotaged by their officials. Allen listed a number of examples of what he called the "treachery of officials" in preventing necessary strikes on various pretexts. He wrote:
«This kind of business is notably on the increase, particularly since the workers have been fools enough to pay this kind of official £200 and more per year [1909 money!] to do nothing in Parliament except betray their interests and run around after different capitalist politicians...in order to be remembered when there are some government jobs going."
Fred Knee, of the London Society of Compositors, remarked bitterly in 1910 that, "there are some trade union leaders who are so prosperous that they at any rate have in their own persons achieved the harmony of the classes."
From 'Some past rank and file