Merger mania
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 41 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 41
Union leaders could threaten militants who wouldn't toe the line. with the sack.
For example, the entire committee of the Manchester TGWU Docks branch were summoned to London to meet general secretary Arthur Deakin and he said: 'Watch yourselves boys. If you don't toe the line I'll have you sacked"
In 1954-55, some 16,000 dockers -beginning in Hull, then Liverpool, then Manchester - broke out of the T&G.
There had already been a breakaway in the '20s which had a base in London and was recognised by the employers there for negotiations, they Stevedores Union (NASD). The TGWU was known as the white union and the Stevedores as the blue union because of the colour of their cards.
The 16,000 dockers attempted to join the 'blue union'. They described this as "The biggest prison break in history'. But they failed. They struck for recognition for six weeks.
On the docks you had to negotiate pay according to the condition of each job, from day to day. Recognition was crucial to the whole business. You couldn't have a union that wasn't recognised.
The Dock Labour Board stuck to its mates, the T&G, fought a bitter struggle against the breakaway and refused to recognise it.
The Communist Party after its turn away from being ultra-left in the '20s and '30s had begun to burrow into the union bureaucracy. The T&G in the late '40s had imposed a • ban on the CP members holding positions, a ban which held in place until 1970. But in London the CP had the leadership of the dockers. Their policy was to work their way into the bureacracy and win favour by being good supporters of the bureaucracy. So they scabbed on the recognition strike.
London didn't come out. The strike for recognition was defeated. The Blue Union then tried to expel the dockers who had joined it in the Northern ports. The dockers tried to stay in by taking the union to court. The blue union was ultimately expelled by the TUC in 1958.
Was the breakaway right or wrong? In retrospect it was a fiasco. It led to a split in the docks and even to a certain amount of non-unionism, though not enough to undermine militancy. Many Trotskyist
rge
These days the trade union movement almost outdoes the City in its enthusiasm for mergers.
NUPE, NALGO and CoHSE are talking about coming together to form a giant public-service union. The General and Municipal Workers have absorbed the Boilermakers and the APEX white-collar union.
SOGAT, having absorbed NATSOPA, and the NGA, having absorbed SLADE, al now talking about a fusion into a bigger print union. The NUJ had been talking about a merger with the NGA.
NUCPS has absorbed the Civil Service Union and is talking about merger with the clerical prades union CPSA. The TGWU, having absorbed the Vehicle Builders, Agricultural Workers, Dyers and Bleachers, and others, has been talking with the National Union of Mineworkers, though these talks seem to be in difficulties.
The National Union of Seamen is discussing merger with the National Union of Railwaymen. The building workers' union UCATT, itself a merger of a number of older building unions in 1970-1, is looking for a larger union to amalgamate with.
The EETPU has failed to puli off its merger with the ABU, but is energetically building links with smaller right-wing organisations. MSF is a merger of groups ranging from draughtsmen through scientists to sheet metal workers and tobacco workers.
This wave of mergers is different from the previous one, around the First World War, which established the T&GWU, the G&M and the AEU, and set the shape of British trade unionism for most of this century.
Then the mergers were driven by an attempt to build strong and effective uniti out of increasing trade union recruitment. Now many mergers are attempts to survive when membership is falling.
No-one can deny the good sense of pooling overhead costs. And socialists generally prefer big unions, uniting greate numbers of workers, to small ones.
But there are problems. Some of the mergers bring together workers in an industry by eliminating trade-union divisions which have hindered united action. Such industrial unionism is a step forward.
But other mergers link together scattered groups of workers across a of industries, with no common factor except that they are all sources of dues income for the trade union officials constructing the merger. The MSF merg is the most extreme example so far, but the GMBU and the EETPU would like to do the same if they could.
Such mergers rarely promote workers' unity in struggle or even in negotiations. And they often lead to very bureaucratic structures.
The members, scattered across differen trade and industrial groups, find it difficul to combine at rank and file level. Any particular industrial group of members in dispute finds itself a small minority in the union. The majority of the union's members have no close interest in the dispute and it's hard to mobilise them against the union leaders if those leaders are selling out the dispute.
Even mergers with a good industrial logie sometimes need to be viewed with caution. West Germany's unions are organised on an industrial basis, with a neatness and rationality that cannot be faulted. Yet they are very bureaucratic unresponsive.
A democratic union with a untidy industrial structure is better than a bureaucratic but industrially tidy one. Where the rank and file is militant and strong, competition of two or more union in the same industry can limit the control of the union bureaucrats, and give more leverage to the rank and file.
Another problem with union mergers is only beginning to emerge. The merger activity of Ken Gill (MSF) on the one hand and of the GMB and EETPU on the other. have tried to bring together unions linked not so much by industrial logic as by political sympathy — creating a Stalinist bloc round the MSF and right-wing blocs round the GMB and EETPU.
This activity still has a long way to go before it brings the British trade union movement near the conditions of France, Italy, or Spain, where union groups of different political colours (Communist, Socialist, Christian) compete in each industry. But that is the direction in whic it is going. It is a harmful direction, which should be resisted.
Socialists in the trade unions should generally support mergers, but raise questions about which mergers, under what conditions. We want mergers with an industrial logic, on the basis of democratic union constitutions.