Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Breakaway unions: right or wrong?

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 40–41 · about 1,689 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 40 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 40

Socialist Organiser has opposed the creation of EPIU a small left-wing electricians' union formed by a breakaway from the right-wing EEPTU. We hal argued that this breakawa takes militants away from fight among rank-and-file electricians which is still possible and still necessary But should socialists always oppose breakaway unions? John O'Mahony looks at the history.

Are we for or agains breakaway unions? In general, we're against: but the issue can't be dealt with abstractly.

Trade unionism is about unity. We are in favour of the maximum unity. We want to overcome sectionalism and parochialism, to unify the workers for a serious fight to defend themselves.

That's why we're against breakaways. But it is only one side of the question.

In reality trade unions don't unite all workers not even in a country like Britain. And the modern unions are not just straight workers' organisations. They are bureaucratised.

A layer of people — officials of the union - become abstracted from the workplace struggles of workers. They become specialists in bargaining. Their conditions of life are separated from the workers they represent. Their wages and conditions are not at all linked to their success or failure as representatives of the workers' interest. Over a period of time they develop all kinds of links with the bourgeoisie and the bourgeois state.

There are many different sorts of trade unions and trade union bureaucracies — straightforward business unionism, European Catholic unionism, and many others.

The unions are thus not mere reflections of the needs of the workers. Very often they act as an agency controlling the workers or as a conduit for bourgeois ideas. The union bureaucracy acts as a highly developed ideological agency for the bourgeoisie and for Stalinists, or sometimes by way of the Stalinists for the bourgeoisie.

We have workers' organisations that stifle their members to one degree, or another.

That's why we can't simply say that trade unionism is about uniting workers, that getting the maximum number of trade unionists in a union is what we go for and that nothing else matters.

Lots of other things matter. Trade union unity can sometimes be a fetter on the workers.

problems, Let's take the clearest USA in the 1930s.

The workers had been organised in a broad trade union - the Knights of Labour — in the latter half of the 19th century, but that had been smashed and destroyed. It was replaced by the American Federation of Labour, a business-type trade union movement. The AFL was very conservative, concerned with craft unionism, very racist and very sexist.

In the 1930s there was a great wave of militancy with sit-down strikes. The workers wanted to organise.

They were stopped by the AFL. It was a block in their way. Sections of the AFL in the first place the miners' union began to reflect the drive of the workers. They wanted to organise industrial unions. So there was a split in the AFL.

The miners' leader John L Lewis -who was a gangster, scoundrel and dirty bureaucrat — walked up to a prominent representative of the craft unionists and hit him on the jaw. It was the signal for a break in the AFL.

"Unity is a good thing - but It was a constructive break. It allowed the workers to create the Congress of Industrial Organisations, CIO, which became the most powerful section of the US labour movement. The split lasted to 1955.

For a long time many militants believed that 'one big union' was an answer to all the problems. That was the basic idea of the syndicalists in the years around the First World War. They helped to create big unions like the TGWU and Connolly's and Larkin's Irish TGWU. But nevertheless the reality of bureaucratisation overtook these unions as well. The TGWU became a great block on workers' militancy.

In the Transitional Programme of 1938. Trotsky argued that we should be against breakaway unions of a sectarian type that pull away from the broad mass of workers in a particular industry. On the other hand, we are against capitulation to the trade union bureaucracy.

In a highly bureaucratised trade union the logic of development of a powerful rank and file movement may lead to a complete clash with the bureaucracy. It may lead to a situation where the rank and file movement is faced with an ultimatum from the bureaucrats to surrender or to break away. In that situation it would be to create a fetish to say that industrial unionism and unity is the main thing. Such an approach would leave the workers no option but to bow down before the incumbent bureaucrats - and the bourgeoisie.

So we are against sectarian - and we are also of unity.

In 1928, Stalin declared that the so-called Third Period of capitalism had started — the system was collapsing everywhere, and revolution was round the corner. Stalin's sidekicks worked out all sorts of daft theories. The main enemies were not fascists, or capitalist, or monarchists but the social democrats.

In Germany the Communist Party united with anyone against the Social Democracy, even sometimes with the Nazis.

The Stalinists also tried to organise their own trade unions. In some countries, like France, that didn't matter a great deal. The unions had already been split by the reformists after World War 1. Elsewhere there was a tradition of political parties having their own unions. But in countries like Germany and Britain it was disastrous.

In Britain in the '20s the CP led a powerful rank and file movement - the Minority Movement - with a paper membership of about one million, in a trade union movement of about four million members.

The CP tried to form breakaway unions out of the Minority Movement. This utterly smashed the Minority Movement.

They created a small miners' breakaway in Fife and a clothing workers' union in East London and Leeds - mainly of Jewish workers — but that was the extent of hsir ability to create independent That sort of politics is utterly and absolutely destructive It very quickly gave way a few years later (1934-6) to the CP forgetting all about fighting the bureaucrats and adopting a policy -which they still maintain — of burrowing within the bureaucracy.

That is one type of experience. But there are many other examples of the opposite happening - of people being frightened to break with the existing machinery of the union and then blocking the class struggle.

The best illustration is the British docks 'in the '50s.

The TGWU was the great hope of the amalgamaters — those who wanted to build one big union in and around the time of the First World War. It became highly bureaucratised very early. It became involved in deals with the capitalists in the mid to late '20s.

It was involved in full scale collaboration with the government and with the state in World War 2.

In 1947 the National Dock Labour Board was set-up. It was an agency to employ dockers. Dockers were employed directly by the Board which then hired them out on a half day basis to the employers who would put them to work. If there were no employer the Board would be responsible for paying a minimum wage to the docker provided he turned up and got his book stamped.

The Dock Labour Board was 50% employers, 50% union representatives.

The TGWU had a closed shop and it was a half-share employer of the workers it was supposed to be representing. Highly bureaucratised, it took on the job of policing the dockers.

It did the sort of job that maybe the Histadrut does in Israel, or the Stalinist bureaucrats who took over Eastern Europe after the war (except the TGWU didn't have a police state)!

There were never official

Scan page 41

Deakin officials would organise to break strikes. groups opposed the breakaway. The Grantites (now Militant) condemned it, the Cliffites (now the SWP) condemned it. The Healyites (later SLL-WRP) were central to the whole, development. They acted as the link between various ports. They had some dockers in Liverpool who played a leading role in the breakaway. Bob Pennington, a Healyite, became a full-timer of the blue union in Liverpool I think the Healyites were right. That sort of prison break - a movement of militant workers which challenges the bureaucracy — is a good thing.

The movement was defeated. After a defeat it is easy to say that you shouldn't have fought. But then when would you ever fight? You never have a guarantee of victory - the dockers could not have known in advance that they would be defeated.

In any case it was not a full scale defeat. It liberated the militants and it helped change the TGWU. Arthur Deakin, the T&G autocratic right-wing General Secretary died in 1954. His right-wing successor, Tiffin, soon died too, and a leftwing Frank Cousins, became general secretary.

Frank Cousins was shaped not just by the bureaucracy but also by the breakaway and by a big bus strike in the late '5Os.

Unity is a good thing — but not the unity of the graveyard and of the apparatchicks. We have to analyse each situation concretely.

In any big struggle against the trade union bureaucracy there is a logic of split — just as in a big fight in the Labour Party. There is nothing that tells you that the anti-bureaucrats are going to get a majority, or that the union bureaucracy will be easily ousted. Faced with being defeated it can split the union. If that threat always makes us climb down and retreat, then we're paralysed.

As Rosa Luxemburg put it, the union doesn't create militancy, militancy creates the union. The union exists for the working class or it exists for nothing at all. We go by the interests of the working class, not by the interests of the union officials' shopkeeping.

From a speech at a recent Organiser industria school.

----- pull-quotes -----

not the unity of the graveyard and of the apparatchik. We have to analyse each situation concretely"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →