Business unionism goes bust
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 39 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 39
The terrible decline of tr ade unionism in the USA since the 1940s and especially since the 1980s has some sobering lessons for British trade unionists.
One thing we can certainly learn from Kim Moody's book* on that decline is that British trade union leaders who look to American 'business unionism' as the answer to their problems are heading for disaster.
Between 1953 and 1985, unionisation in the US in manufacturing fell from 42 per cent to 25 percent; in transport, from 80 per cent to 37 per cent; in construction, from 84 per cent to 22 per cent; and in mining, from 65 per cent to 15 per cent.
The shift in employment from manutacturing to services does not explain the decline; unionisation has weakened in almost every sector, with government service workers being an area of relative success.
Real wages have been declining in the US since the early '70s, and differentials between unionised and non-union workers has been declining too. Poverty and insecurity have increased, and the trade unions have done nothing effective to resist.
Kim Moody argues that the unions' ineffectiveness results from the basic philosophy of their leaders. He quotes Lane Kirkland, leader of the American equivalent of the TUC, to illustrate the utter lack of working class consciousness among American trade union leaders. A class restrade middle a ass erase unions" , he declares, "are nothing more and nothing less - than the American middle class and those who aspire to it' In the 1930s and '40s, Chapple unionism first emerged in the USA, the trade unions were not socialist, nor did they form their own political party, though the idea was much discussed.
Yet the main trade union leaders did have some concept of 'social unionism' which enabled them to respond militantly, creatively and as a movement.
In the early '50s the frail philosophy of "social unionism' was swept away by the Cold War witch-hunt and the boom which started with the Korean War. The union leaders switched to running the union strictly as businesses. Their job was not to change society or even to advance the immediate interests of workers as a class, but to get enough dues income to sustain the union machine and negotiate enough gains for the members to get that dues income.
The 'pattern bargaining' which had been one of the main gains of the great struggles of the 1940s, negotlating common wages and conditions for workers across whole industries, was allowed to decay through short-sightedness. When American capitalism lost its position of world domination and ran into hard times in the 1970s, the union leaders had no answers.
They ran increasingly desperately after Democratic Party politicians, hoping for some crumbs from the government's tables. They tried to negotiate 'realistically' when businesses threatened to shut down or sack workers. Increasingly that meant negotiating 'give-backs' cuts in wages and loss of conditions and benefits. What was left of pattern bargaining disintegrated and was replaced by whipsaw patterns, where give-backs in one company would become the basis for other companies to demand similar concessions.
The union leaders tried to preserve their position, not by any effective campaign to organise and mobilise more workers, bui mainly by merging with smaller unions and trying to pick up easily organised groups of new workers, especially public service workers. What were relatively coherent industrial unions are increasingly becoming ragbag general unions.
"The more disparate and dispersed the separate pieces, the more uncontrollable becomes the full-time officialdom ana Its full-time staff, which remains the only coherent centralising force in a sprawling institution... Random organising promises to improve the workers' situation for the moment, but offers no guidance for achieving further advances or even for holding on to past gains...It is a nickeland-dime business unionism which sees unions as service organisations and bargaining 'strength' as a question of internal organisation resources"
But there is more to the US unions than their leaders. Moody also describes the rank-and-file struggles in the 1980s which have begun to point the way for a new revival of trade unionism.
* Kim Moody, An Injury to All: the Decline of American Unionism, Verso 1988. Eric Hammond n trade union politics the EETPU is a right-wing bastion, and it has been ever since Cannon, Byrne and Chapple took control in 1961 as the union's top three Executive Committee men.
Significantly, not one EETPU member voted for this triad because no election actually took place. They were simply installed by the High Court, at the end of an unprecedented media campaign that purged the old ballot-rigging Communist Party leadership of the union without a single vote being cast.
For two decades Frank Chapple, a former Communist and electrician shop steward, was the key functionary in a complex umbrella that organised workers energy supply, contracting, shipbuilding, telecommunications and electronics.
The union's elected lay Executive Committee was abolished and replaced by a full-time body which almost immediately suppressed all membership elections for national and local officers, opting instead for appointing loyal EC careerists. The elected rank and file Appeal Committee was abolished too.
Three years ago the EETPU spent £4.6 million (49% of its total income) on its salaried staff of 15 EC members and 151 national and local oficers. That's an average of £28,000 each. A further 25 researchers and general administration cost another £1.7 million.
Not one of these officers is elected by members. All of them are appointed by a shadowy sub-committee of the EC, yet union policy-making committees are dominated by this EC network of selected functionaries.
Left-wing branches and activists are routinely suspended. Cardiff, Birmingham, Glasgow and London Central branches have been closed and reorganised because of rank and file opposition to the EC. Many militants blacklisted by employers also claim the EC is keeping dossiers on them.
Scan page 40
against making a fetish
----- pull-quotes -----
How Hammond keeps contro