Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

RANK FIL The EETPU's strategy

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan p. 38 · Alan Fraser · about 729 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 38 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 38

and how to fight it The EETPU is a pioneer of business unionism. In industrial relations courses at its two training centres it tries, with some degree of success, to indoctrinate convenors and shop stewards away from militancy and towards collaboration with the employers and particularly Japanese hi-tech multinationals.

The EETPU's new electronics training college was opened by Norman Tebbit and was funded with bosses' money and public grants from the Tory government.

The EETPU leaders have a distinct philosophy. They believe that thriving capitalism - high profits - equals high wages.

Their strategy is based on offering employers something new in return for job security, improved conditions, good wages and fringe benefits for their members. And what could be better than a no-strike agreement, pendulum arbitration, greater use of part-time workers, variations of hours, mobility of labour, demarcation lines removed — and "no problems" in collective bargaining.

Eric Hammond puts it like this: "Of course there are people, sects and nuts, who actually believe that in being involved in strikes workers find out how to struggle electronic giants like Toshiba, Hitachi and Sanyo not only outlaw strike action but place unique emphasis on the idea of a common interest between labour and management, between the exploiters and those they exploit.

The most typical example of such ideological mobilisation is the "three P" system - productivity, participation, prosperity. The central feature is the setting up of joint union-management quality control committees. At Toshiba these meetings are held at four levels:

1. A twice-yearly central liaison meeting to discuss long-term company plans.

2. A plant meeting, also twice a year, between company executives, EETPU national officials, and plant convenors on issues related to efficient operation of the company.

3. A plant liaison meeting held once a month between management, local officials and convenors to decide production schedules for the month.' 4. A further monthly plant-wide briefing on how best to attain production schedules.

It is significant that decision on matters such as size of workforce, labour efficiency and pay and job conditions are made behind closed doors in secret negotiations between top union officers and management. At no stage are such negotiations subject to rank and file ratification at focus for opposition to what is decided at the top. This system operates to make it difficult to organise unofficial strikes for trade union principles, work conditions or wages.

It is estimated that no more than 10,000 to 20,000 workers are covered by these agreements. However the signs are ominous. Many cowed union leaders, desparate to replace lost membership and lost funds may very well seek to sign such deals.

Where the EETPU and AEU have broken ranks with the rest of the TUC 'new realists' is in explicitly renouncing the strike weapon and substituting binding 'pendulum' arbitration in their agreements. This means that production must continue through all stages of the disputes procedure, and if no settlement can be reached 'in company', leads to binding arbitration as the final stage.

At this last stage of the procedure, an 'independent' arbitrator (usually from ACAS) is brought in to choose between the final positions of the employer and the union. The arbitrator must opt 100% for the union's position or 100% for the boss's, not for anything in between -hence the "pendulum' tag.

So the fight against the new business unionism will be hard and long, and not just a matter of dealing with Eric Hammond and his cronies.

The fact is, though, that Hammond's ideology just does not square with reality. In January 1986, the workers at Bowman Webber, a firm making mirrors in Harlow, struck for two weeks over the sacking of three workers, one of whom had been elected an EETPU shop steward the night before.

What was unusual about this action was that it took place in a company that was covered by a no-strike deal with the BETPU. The sacked workers were reinstated, but the story has an interesting postscript: shortly after the strike, pendulum arbitration (the EETPU's favoured form of annier dispute or pay or double-sive 'strike substitute') was used to resolve working, and it came down in favour of the workforce for once.

Even the Guardian commented that, "whatever deals are made between unions and management, workers are still going to find that collectively withdrawing their labour will from time to time be necessary."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →