Organising women workers
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 36 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 36
Whenever there is a shortage in labour, for instance during war, women become the pool of unused labour from which the capitalists draw their reserves.
Suddenly women become the driving force behind a war economy. They work long hours in munitions factories, in heavy industry and in agriculture. Women weld warships and rivet essential machinery. In other words, women become a part of what has traditionally been the male labour force.
On the business pages of the press today we read more and more about "the demographic time bomb", 'the expected decrease in the youth labour market" and, as a result of this, "the possibility of workplace nurseries. The financial experts are pondering over the problem presented to industry by the fall in the birthrate in the 1970s, and fewer and fewer school leavers entering the workforce as the years roll by.
The shift is not as drastic as those brought on by war, but nevertheless, the fact that women are a growing part of the labour market and of the shopfloor is undeniable. Nine million women in Britain are now in some form of paid employment. Women are 45% of the workforce, and the fastest growing area of employment is women's part-time work.
These trends are likely to increase. They mark a change in the make-up of the working class and a corresponding need of the labour movement to begin the organisation of women workers as a priority in order to ensure its own survival.
Although women are now more likely to be in waged work, they continue to bear the burden of family life. A great deal of women's work is part-time precisely because the responsibility of childcare still falls on them.
The Tory attacks on public spending and the welfare state have compounded the situation by cutting state provision for care for the elderly or young children. Thatcher's government has accelerated the trend of women into paid work, but forced women to combine childcare and housework with waged work.
A recent report by the Equal Opportunities Commission has pointed to this double burden with evidence that the majority of childcare undertaken for women in work is done by their own mothers. Women's role in the domestic sphere is still very much as carers and nurturers.
The Tories have also tried to use women workers as a tool towards the goal of the free market economy. Women workers are looked upon as a flexible, unorganised army of cheap labour. Women workers have been at the sharp end of attacks on wages councils, work conditions and health and safety regulators.
Many of these attacks have occurred because of the inability of the trade union movement to organise the • female workshop. The sexism of individual male trade unionists is a big enough barrier to the involvement of women, and in addition there is the very real problem of rightproblems, wing, bureaucratic union structures which reproduce the problem of the male-dominated branch meeting. The lack of thought about childcare provision, the glaring lack of demands for creches, for a minimum wage and equal pay. In its drive to recruit more women members the trade union movement has got to look at its own structures, promote women positively into its ranks and fight for demands relevant to women.
Many trade unions have begun tackling by the problem of the dedine in membership workers as well as looking at the problems of unionising youth on schemes and the part-time flexible workforce. Initiatives such as the TGWU's 'Link Up' campaign, which aim to reach out to such workers, must be welcomed. However, the reality is that these campaigns are inadequate to deal with the tough reality of ensuring militant campaigi committed to a working women charter would provide a tramew frame for un ion women are protected in the workplace.
A rigorous and militant campaign, committed to some sort of women workers' charter, would provide a framework for unionising women. Such a charter would include demands for fulltime rights for part-time workers (such as maternity leave, sick and holiday pay, workplace nurseries, procedures to deal with sexual harassment, positive discrimination to ensure women's involvement at all levels of the union, childcare provision at union meetings, health care that is relevant to women's needs, a commitment to equal pay and a minimum wage.
The problem of the inertia of some trade unions in organising women is a problem of right-wing domination of the union movement. However, some feminists argue that it is a problem of gender polarisation in the workforce. Male workers are supposed to greedily defend the status quo because low paid women secure their own highly paid jobs.
Marxism Today and some in the Labour Party have talked of the need for a "feminist incomes policy".
The real aim behind such proposals is an attack on the income of male wage earners and on the better organised sections of the labour movement. It would be suicidal and divisive to accept policies designed to redistribute wealth within the working class rather than between classes.
The notion of a 'female' approach rather than a specifically working-class approach to union organisation has other reactionary implications. Bea Campbell of Marxism Today denounces the most militant methods of class struggle as macho and essentially anti-women. Picket lines, spontaneous rank and file movements and organised defence are all lumped together as male methods of struggle.
This flies in the face of the experience of many women workers who have, over the years, been involved in some of the bloodiest battles of the labour movement. Most recently women in the Health Service have organised rank and file action, pickets and mass meetings. Bea Campbell's argument can only place these struggles firmly outside the feminist or, as she sees it, the socialist project.
Unfortunately ideas like these are commonplace and fuelled by a new 'radical' politics which was firmly placed on the British political agenda by the Greater London Council. The GLC, after retreating from a fight with central government over implementing cuts and raising rates, turned instead to 'empowering' disadvantaged groups. Much of what the GLC did was positive, but as the cuts began to bite a version of feminism was used to cloak the anti-working class nature of the council's politics. Increasingly the GLC maintained funding select women's groups while doing nothing to back the struggles of ordinary women workers.
At the same time as these terrible hypocritical policies took their toll, women workers in the GLC typing pool still had to raise their hand to ask permission to go to the toilet!
Some councils following the GLC's example have carried through redundancies by dividing the council workers into layers of specially oppressed groups: white heterosexual men were the first to go, black workers could keep their jobs. A racist backlash was inevitable, but any attempt to fight the redundancies could also be labelled as sexist, racist or homophobic.
The problem of the whole 'Local Government Left' experiment was the way in which it broke down the working class into specially oppressed groups, an idea belonging less to socialists than to radical liberals in America. The notion of the working class as the liberators of the whole of society is submerged into the idea of a coalition, a 'rainbow alliance' of specially oppressed groups, in which the working class is seen as a small, fragmented part. Each group fights for what it sees as its own particular interests, rather than seeing itself as part of the generalised whole, as part of a united working class movement. The problems of the oppressed are seen as the fault of 'bad' ideas rather than the economic entrenchment of oppression. The enlightened local authority sits above the fragments, correcting 'bad' ideas, distributing bits of 'empowering' (or money) to the various oppressed groups, and supposedly linking all the fragments into a coherent battle for liberation.
In terms of the real effect made upon women's lives, the attempt made by the GLC to 'empower' women pales into insignificance compared to the organised strength of a working class women's movement such as Women Against Pit Closures. In 1920 Alexandra Kollontai
Scan page 37
Photo: john Harris wrote that "participation in the workers' police on picket lines. movement brings the woman worker The experience of Women Against Pit towards her liberation, not only as a seller Closures and the prospect of millions of of labour power but also as a woman, a women becoming part of the organised wife, a mother, a housekeeper. labour movement provides socialists with Her point was illustrated in the miners' the hope of a mass working women's strike of 1984-5. spontaneous movement coming into existence. organisation of women in mining com- But it is not inevitable. The organisamunities into an autonomous movement tion of women workers depends on the which combined working class militancy structures and the politics of the trade with demands for women's liberation and union movement. Making the union organisation which socialised cooking and movement respond to women's needs and great deal of childcare. Women emerge demands will take a long and bitter fight, from the narrow, isolated domestic work but fight we must if we are not to waste to address political meetings, money and food distribution and riga the opportunity of unionising a whole layer of unorganised labour About 45 per cent of wage-workers in thi UK today are women. In 195l it was only 31 per cent. The proportion continues to increase, with part-time women workers by far the fastest-growing section of the workforce.
Half of all women wage-workers are part-timers. It is becoming more and moi common for women who look after children also to have jobs. In 1911, only one in ten married women had a job; in 1985, 55 per cent.
Nevertheless, local authorities provide nursery places for only one per cent of under-fives. The total number of places with nurseries and child-minders covers eight per cent of under-fives. Most women workers with small children rely on their mothers or other female members of their families to help out.
The Sex Discrimination Act 1976 should ensure equal opportunities. It brought some improvement for a small minority of better-off women. Between 1971 and 1981 women increased their share of judges' and barristers' jobs from 4% to 15%, of accountants' and valuers' jobs from 4% to 10%, and of managers' jobs from 18% to 25%.
But most women are still concentrated in 'women's jobs'. Discrimination continues in the form of worse pay and conditions for those jobs and for part-time workers.
When the Equal Pay Act 1975 came into force, women's average hourly earnings were 72% of men's. By 1986 they were...74 per cent.
Since 1984 changes in the law have made it possible to insist on equal pay not just for the same work but for 'work of equal value. This has produced some, but very slow, progress.
Up to June 1989, unions had made 128 applications for 'equal pay for work of equal value'. 20 had been upheld by tribunals and 24 rejected. 43 had been withdrawn or settled before getting to the tribunals, 5 were on appeal, and 36 were outstanding.
About one-third of trade union members are women. All unions are now committed on paper to equal opportunities. Many have equal rights courses, equal oppor. tunities officers, and reserved women's seats on their executive committees. But here too progress is slow.
Although women are the majority in the membership of six big unions - NUPE, NALGO, USDAW, CoHSE, NUT and CPSA - only one sizeable union is headed by a woman (Brenda Dean, in the print union, SOGAT).
The proportion of woren on the union executives has risen in the '80s, though nowhere does it match the proportion of women in the membership. NUPE (66 per cent women members) has a 50% female executive; NALGO (52% women members) has a 36% female executive; the TGWU (17% women members) has a 5% female executive; and the CPSA (71% women members) has a 44% female executive.
Full-time officials are still almost all male. The health workers' union CoHSE the one exception. 50 per cent of its national officials are women. But only 9% of NUPE's national officials, 20% of NALGO's, 0% of the TGWU's, and 18% of the CPSA's are women.
• Figures from Labour Research Bargaining Report, June 1989, and (for the unions) Labour Research March 1988.
Scan page 38
mass meetings.
Shop stewards are not subject to immediate recall and thus it will be difficult for workers to use the shop stewards as a
----- pull-quotes -----
"A rigorous and campaign
Wond PAY UP SAYS NOW!
Women in the workforce and unions By Jean Lane