The Eastern bloc: which side are you on!
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 34 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 34
Emma Colyer This summer we saw the Chinese working class begin to move into action as an independent force against the murderous ruling A working class that had been terrorised and kept down by China's totalitarian state for decades reappeared - full of force and fighting vigour. Together with the magnificent students, the Chinese workers marched and sang the Internationale, the anthem of international labour.
They organised an independent trade union in Beijing. Workers and students seized control of the centre of the capital from the hands of the murdering old men who run China.
Workers and students alike were massacred in Tienanmen Square on 4 June 1989 — but it is as certain as anything can be in politics that the workers and students continue to organise underground. One day, and perhaps soon, they will settle accounts with the Stalinist butchers who rule China.
All across the Eastern Bloc, the old Stalinist regimes are rotting and splintering, and workers are seizing the chance to organise. As this pamphlet goes to press, miners are on strike again in the USSR, complaining that the government had not kept promises made in order to settle their earlier dispute in July 1989.
Solidarnose has been made legal again in Poland, and holds leading positions in the government, even though the Stalinist party retains control of key jobs in the army, the police, and the state administration.
Hungary has several independent trade unions, small so far.
In October 1989, East German workers created the first trade union free of state control to exist in their country since 1933, when Hitler came to power.
The Soviet miners have been discussing the formation of a free trade union. In the meantime, they are maintaining their strike committees. In the strikes of July 1989, the official trade union leaders took part in negotiations on the management side.
As the workers recover their confidence after decades of Stalinist stifling, their natural method of selt-assertion is the mass strike. In Poland, a mass strike movement in 1980 established Solidarnosc and made it legal for the first time; another two mass strike waves in 1988 forced Jaruzelski to retreat from his drive to crush the independent trade union and to legalise it again.
In China, spontaneous mass strikes supported the democracy movement and then protested against its suppression after 4 June. In the USSR, mass strikes problems, have been used both by the miners and by groups of workers pursuing nationalist grievances.
In systems where the state is the only major employer and where state tyranny in society and economic exploitation in the workplaces are closely woven together, the mass strike is the natural, spontaneous act of self-assertion by workers who refuse any longer to be beasts of burden for the ruling Some of the recent strikes in the Eastern Bloc, like the Azerbaijani strikes against the ceding of Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia, or the Serbian strikes in Yugoslavia against autonomy for the Albanian-populated region of Kosovo, have been manipulated by local bureaucrats with an ugly chauvinist direction.
But that is not what complicates the response of British trade unionists to the workers' struggles in the Eastern Bloc. That nationalism can sometimes mobilise workers for reactionary aims is something we know from all-too-broad experience. We also know, or should know, how to distinguish such reactionary nationalist movements, seeking privileges or the suppression of a rival nationality, from progressive struggles seeking the liberation of oppressed nationalities.
For the Eastern Bloc, however, the response from British trade unionists is often uncertain and unclear even when the issues are ones that would be crystal clear elsewhere: battles by workers to improve wages and conditions or to assert the right to organise independently and to strike.
At Labour Party Conference in October 1989, Arthur Scargill refused to sign a Chinese Solidarity Campaign petition demanding the release of trade unionists and student unionists jailed in China. Ken Gill of MSF would not sign either, saying that he wanted to 'think about it' If the petition had been about Chile, South Africa, Turkey, or anywhere outside the Eastern Bloc, Scargill and Gill would have signed without hesitation. So would almost any trade unionist. But the Eastern Bloc is different.
In the same months, October 1989, Mikhail Gorbachev proposed a complete ban on strikes in the USSR, and actually got a wide-ranging limitation on strikes in "essential' sectors through the Soviet Parliament. Imagine the outcry we would make - and rightly so - if such a ban were legislated in a Western country. Not even Thatcher's Tories have dared attempt so sweeping a ban on strikes. Yet most of the left responded to Gorbachev's move with mild, dispassionate comment.
Opinion in the British labour movement has undoubtedly become more anti-Stalinist since 1980, when Solidarnosc first emerged from a mass strike wave.
Then, throughout the bitter and dangerous struggle of the Polish workers Some on the left even failed to side with the Chinest students against the murderous regime to win the right to have free and self-governing trade unions, the British TUC maintained friendly contact and cooperation with the strike-breaking government unions. Even when millions of Polish workers had repudiated them, the TUC continued to recognise the policestate 'unions' as genuine labour organisations. In the middle of the strike movement the TUC stubbornly refused to call off the scheduled visit of its delegates to the battlefield as guests of the scab 'unions' which were doing their best to help the Government beat down the insurgent workers. In the event the visit was called off by the Poles.
During the August 1980 strike movement, the then Chairman of Poland's official unions, Jan Sydlak, was one of the most outspoken and vicious of the bureaucrats in threatening the strikers and their helpers with tanks and slaughter. He called publicly for them to be "taught a lesson they would never forget". Yet our TUC leaders maintained friendly links with him.
And to this day they maintain friendly links with the government 'unions' in the USSR, the same unions which appeared on the bosses' side in negotiations during the July 1989 miners' strike.
They maintain the pretence that the official 'trade unions' in the Stalinist states are real working class organisations -when in fact that they are part of a policestate 'Labour Front' apparatus for controlling and policing the working class and for preventing real trade unions and an independent working class movement developing.
The British trade union movement still hesitates to give solidarity to workers in the Eastern Bloc — and even worse, those who hesitate most are often those who are quickest and most generous in organising solidarity for workers anywhere else, people like Arthur Scargill.
Scan page 35
workers and The trade union leaders who talk about adarity with workers in the Eastern Bloc • hypocrites like Eric Hammond, who uld not know an act of solidarity if it Happed them in the face.
Why is this? For decades, both the wers of the Stalinist states and our own lers have told us that Stalinism is cialism. Today the capitalist media are fully proclaiming that the decay of dinism means the collapse of socialism and the triumph of capitalism. Leftists and trade unionists feel uncom• table about unequivocal solidarity with i workers in the Eastern Bloc because it ans to mean saying something like what rgaret Thatcher and Eric Hammond 1. This is understandable, but it is a dly trivial consideration in a situation ere the workers of the Stalinist states d our moral and practical support. We e duty as basic as not crossing a picket = to give it to them. ! To allow the noise made by the Hamads and Thatchers to force us into ace on the struggle of a big part of the Id's working class is to sink into a kered national narrowmindedness.
As people who believe, with Marx and es, that the emancipation of the king class can only be achieved by the king class itself, we would be obliged support any independent workers' ament against the police state even if considered its politics to be seriously aken and wrong.
That a real labour movement should exs much more important than how ish industry is nationalised. ¡the discomfort we feel about denounc* systems which our exploiters also deace, and call socialist, is doubled by ≥ fact that, in the last few years, the ish workers' movement Solidarnosc come out officially and explicitly in our of private-profit, free-market nomics.
This policy tragic. led the Solidarnose leaders into coalition with the Stalinists who imposed martial law. It is likely to lead Walesa, Kuron and Mazowiecki into outright attacks on the jobs, security and living standards of the Polish workers, and outright confrontation with the Solidarnosc militants who will fight to defend working-class interests.
Western socialists should do all we can to help the socialists in Solidarnosc fighting against Walesa's free-market policies, groups like the PPS-RD. But we can't help them effectively unless we also support all the Polish workers' struggles, whatever the illusions of their leaders.
In the West we support trade union struggles led by Stalinists (in France or Portugal, say), by Catholic trade-union groups (in Italy, France etc.), by demagogic nationalists (Argentina and other countries) and by outright supporters of capitalism and imperialism (in the USA for example. We should have the same standard, the same attitude of unconditional solidarity with workers against their exploiters, for the Eastern Bloc — not a double standard.
Some trade unionists who hate Stalinism and believe that it was never socialism, are still reluctant to give full support to workers' struggles in the USSR because they value the changes being made by Gorbachev and fear that workers' struggles could upset the delicate process of gradual reform. But this is just another form of double standard. In Turkey, in Chile, or in Brazil, would we advise trade unionists to bow their heads because struggles might disrupt liberalisation from above? Would we condone legal bans on strikes and trade union action?
In the USSR as in Western dictatorships, the best guarantee of reform is a free, active, combative workers' movement, not the promises of a reforming ruler.
Many reluctant unequivocally with Solidarnosc against the Polish exploiters because by doing so we seem to praise by implication the regime which our movement exists to fight -that of 'liberal' capitalism. There is probably a subconscious reluctance to face the facts about the Stalinist regimes, ana their implications, because those regimes are so terrible compared with the political regimes in the historically privileged advanced capitalist countries that the latter seem almost good by comparison. And of course, horror at the reality of the Stalinist regimes has, in the last five decades led many one-time revolutionary socialists to reconciliation with 'liberal' capitalism.
But the choice is not confined to either Thatcher and Bush or Deng and Gorbachev: there is also the possibility of a working class socialist democracy.
Capitalism periodically ravages the lives of working class people with slumps and wars, and it is now ravaging the lives of over two million working class families in Britain alone.
In many areas of the world it imposes its own forms of dictatorship. In social crises like Britain's present crisis it has time and again resorted to savage repression. It is now attempting, as yet in a limited way, to tie our own unions to the state. Now less than ever before is there a basis for any labour movement reconciliation with capitalism or its advocates.
In fact, irreconcilable working class and socialist opposition to our main enemy at home cannot be stable or coherent if it is based on anything other than a clear and independent working class view of the world, and on the experience of all the struggles of the working class throughout the world.
Therefore we must not block out of our consciousness a real awareness of what our class faces under the Stalinist regimes. We must not mollify or console ourselves with half-conscious assumptions that the totalitarian Stalinist regimes are really not so bad; that they are really rather benevolent and paternalistic to those they deprive of civil rights and personal and group autonomy. We must stop pretending that their hands are not really dripping with the blood of workers who have dared to stand out against them.
Their hands do really drip workers' blood.
Yes, things have loosened up a great deal in the USSR in the last year or so. That is good. It means that the USSR might now allow its citizens the sort of rights they have in such capitalist hellholes as Turkey or South Africa, a limited right to strike for example. It is not enough. It is nowhere near enough.
And the loosening-up is not secure, either. Gorbachev, or some other entrenched bureaucrat, still has the power to turn around and shoot down the people, as Deng, the 'great reformer' of China, did last June.
Those in our movement who 'forget' how undemocratic the Soviet regime still is in order to praise Gorbachev should be ashamed of themselves.
We must actively support the workers in China, in the USSR, and in the other Eastern Bloc states in every way we can.
That means rousing the anger, the hatred, and the active hostility of the labour movement against their oppressors.
It is, to repeat, as basic as not crossing a picket line. And as basic as the attitude one takes to those who do.
New, problems, New struggles Page 33