Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Linking the left in Labour and the unions

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 27–28 · about 1,395 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 27 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 27

When industrial militancy and rank and file organisation in the trade unions were at their height, in 1972-5, there was no corresponding rank and file movement in the Labour Party.

The industrial upsurge brought down the Tories — and led to a Labour government which, within twe years, was curbing wages and carrying through cuts.

When the Rank and File Mobilising Committee was waging its greatest battle for democracy in the Labour Party in 1979-81, very little was done to organise a parallel battle for democracy in the trade unions. From the Bishops Storford conclave in 1982 the trade union barons were able to check and neutralise the fight to transform the Labour Party.

Lack of organised coordination between left-wing movements in the trade unions and in the Labour Party has restricted the possibilities of both. Yet that lack is not inevitable. There was a short period, in the mid-1920s, when a strong Minority Movement in the trade unions and a sizeable National Left Wing Movement in the Labour Party worked hand in hand, both heavily influenced by the thenrevolutionary Communist Party.

The Communist Party was formed in 1920 by the amalgamation of man! small socialist groups, brought together by the common inspiration of the Russian Revolution. The bigges of those groups, the British Socialist Party, had been affiliated to the Labour Party in the same way as the Fabian Society, but the dominant mood of the new Communist Party was impatient of any dealings at all with the Labour Party.

It took much argument by Lenin and other leaders of the Communist International to persuade the Communist Party to apply for affiliation to the Labour Party. The application was done clumsily, and rejected.

Through all this, despite the doctrinal arguments, many Communists had been active in local Labour Parties as individuals or as trade union delegates. Two Communists had been elected as Labour MPs.

It was about the same time as the Labour Party leaders were moving decisively against the Communist influence that the Communist Party finally got itself into shape for a coherent policy towards the Labour Party. Even at that late stage, they were able to achieve a great deal in the few years before the experimen was snuffed out by Stalin.

The story is told in the following cerpts from Brian Pearce's article, 'The Communist Party and the Labour left 1925-1929'.

own to the Liverpool ConferD ence of the Labour Party in 1925, Communists could be individual members of the Labour Party. A resolution adopted at that conference excluded them from such membership, beginning the final drive by the right-wing leaders to ban Communists from any kind of participation in Labour Party affairs.

A strong minority in the Labour Party indignantly opposed this drive. In December 1925, following meetings in London and Birmingham, a National Left-Wing Conference was held, under the aegis of prominent personalities such as Tom Mann, Councillor Joe Vaughan (formerly Mayor of Bethnal Green, and member of the London Labour Party Executive, Joseph Southall (ILP), Alex Gossip of the furniture workers and William Paul, the Communist editor of the Sunday Worker, a newspaper of leftwing sympathies, founded earlier in the same year, which claimed a circulation approaching 100,000 (Communist Party membership was then about 5,000).

The aim of the Left-Wing Movement was proclaimed to be "not to supersede the Labour Party, but to 're-mould it nearer to the heart's desire' of the rank and file."

It was reported at the

Scan page 28

nearly a hundred divisional and borough Labour Parties had suspended operation of the Liverpool decision. About fifty of these Labour Parties associated themselves with the National Left-Wing Movement, and Left-Wing groups were organised in many others. When Labour Party headquarters began disaffiliating Labour organisations which refused to operate the ban on Communists, this only intensified the conviction of the members affected that something like the National Left-Wing Movement was needed.

The betrayal of the General Strike in May 1926 gave a further fillip to the new trend, and in September of that year a well-attended conference of the National Left-Wing Movement was held at Porare with Joe Vaughan in the chair. keynote of this meeting was sounded in his call to "cleanse the Labour Party of the agents of capitalism".

At this time the Communist-led National Minority Movement in the trade unions commanded the support of nearly a million workers, a quarter of the total trade union membership, and was steadily growing. It was possible to look forward to the winning of both local Labour Parties and trade unions for the left-wing cause of a militant socialist policy in the During 1927, the National Left-Wing assumed increasingly organised form, with a leading committee, chairman and secretary. The Sunday Worker became virtually the organ of the new movement, regularly allotting space to reports of the organising of Left-Wing groups up and down the country, and to expositions of its programme.

A certain amount of trade union support for the movement's aims began to be recorded; in May, for example, the Lancashire and Cheshire Miners' Federation declared for the affiliation of the Communist Party to the Labour Party.

When the National Left-Wing Movement held its Second Annual Conference, in September 1927, fifty-four local Labour parties and many other groups were represented, aggregating, it was Ramsey MacDonald claimed, about 150,000 individual members.

Membership of the Communist Party at this time stood at about 7,500. There were large numbers of Labour Party supporters who were becoming disgusted with the policy of their leaders and who were desirous of changing both policy and leaders in the direction of militancy and a socialist programme but who, although friendly to the Communists and in favour of their enjoying equal rights in the Party as individuals, as before 1925, nevertheless did not themselves agree with all the Communist Party's ideas (especially on the then much-discussed question of "heavy civil war") and they did not want to join its ranks.

The National Left-Wing Movement served as a bridge between the Communist Party and wide leftward-moving sections of the working class.

To some leading members of the Communist Party it seemed, however, that it was not so much a bridge as a barrier. The leftward-moving masses would find their way into the ranks of the Communist Party, they felt, if the National Left-Wing were not there to intercept them.

Moreover, the prospect of transforming in favour of the views upheld by the minority. The Labour Party, it considered, was already well on the way to becoming a unitary Social-Democratic Party like those on the Continent, and this development must be accepted as irreversible.

It no longer made any sense to call for a second Labour government, with no matter what qualification or condition; the Communist Party's slogan should now be: 'For a revolutionary Workers' Government'. Candidates should be put up to fight Labour in as many places as possible. The questions of what was to be done about the Left-Wing Movement, and what the Communist Party should advise workers to do in places where there was a Labour candidate and no Communist candidate, were left without any clear-cut answer at this stage.

There now began a period covering nearly two years during which confusion frew within the Communist Party as to the implications of the "New Line'.

At the same time, the National LeftWing Movement continued to develop, and under Communist guidance concenwingers as Parliamentary candidates.

The reviving militancy of the working following the defeat of the General Strike, after the period of depression expressed itself in a new way in the launching of a manifesto for a socialist policy in the Labour Party by the miners' leader, AJ Cook, and James Maxton of the ILP, backed by John Wheatley, the most left of the Labour Party's leaders. The National Left-Wing Movement officially greeted its appearance.

The circulation of the Sunday Worker rose steadily and some 10,000 people turned out for the Left-Wing May Day demonstration of 1928. At the annual conference of the Left Wing Movement in September 1928, between 75 and 80 loca Labour Party Left-Wing groups were represented and the provincial representation in particular was better than it had been in either of the previous conferences.

This promising development collapsed as a result of intensified attacks by the

----- pull-quotes -----

trated on struggle in the localities to replace right-wing Labourites by left-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →