Democratising the block vote
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 25 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 25
dustry to organise itself so that it becomes a more viable partner to government" will change the tax system and accounting rules to nudge companies into spending more on research and development.
It will "persuade companies to train their employees by financial incentives rather than by legislation'. It s policy for job creation will be to "encourage loca authorities to invite local consortiums — consisting of local government, private enterprise and trade unions and community organisations - to develop a network of job-generation projects...
There is some talk of investment and training projects directly undertaken by the government, but very little; and even less about how and from where the government will get the resources for these projects.
Renationalisation will be confined to the major utilities (gas, water, electricity, rail, post, telecom). Even here it will not be rapid; and 'there will be no question of paying other than a fair market price" for shares (ie rip-off profiteers' gains will be guaranteed).
Only enough shares will be brought back to bring the government stake up to 51 per cent; and Neil Kinnock has insisted that the usual dividends will be paid on the other 49 per cent. In other words, even the renationalised enterprises will have to be run in such a way as to keep the shareholders happy — on orthodox capitalist lines.
"The market will not — left to itself -produce adequate investment in education and training, in science and technology, in new products and new capacity" , says the Policy Review. But its programme would give a Labour government no real grip against market forces. Words of encouragement, efforts at persuasion, will not move hard-bitten capitalists!
And what about inflation? The Policy Review's section on inflation is among its woolliest. "Inflation is a complex phenomenon", it sagely comments, "whose causes will vary from one situation to the next...There is [no] all-embracing solution"
The nearest the document comes to a policy is this: "We shall make it clear throughout the economy that our emphasis is on investment rather than consumption, and that money spent too generously on consumption today could prejudice jobs and services tomorrow"
"Throughout the economy"? So we'll have Labour ministers turning up at the single mother's council flat and at the bankers' dinner alike to warn that too many baked beans or too much caviar today could mean ruin tomorrow?
The Labour government would probably try credit controls. These would hit working class people trying to buy houses, but probably have no effect on the rich, who in today's fast-and-furious financial markets would surely find ways round them: Probably they would have little effect on inflation; and then the Labour government would be back to its traditional method of stopping money being "spent too generously on consumption" namely wage controls.
No socialist economic policy is possible without taking control of the vast financial system in the City and of the main productive enterprises, so that the economy can be planned internationlly if possible. Without that, a Labour government will end up ruining itself by attacking the workers on whom it has to depend for support.
Block vote" are the : dirtiest words in the dictionary t o many socialists by the end of a Labour Party annual conference.
In debate after debate we hear strong and persuasive speeches for a left-wing motion, with the feeblest opposition. Then the General Secretaries get out their voting cards and the motion is crushed.
Now John Edmonds, General Secretary of the GMB, says that the block vote must be abolished. Neil Kinnock clearly agrees, though how fast he will go along that road remains to be seen.
Should we support Edmonds and Kinnock! No, for three reasons.
ONE. The way the block vote operates today should not be idealised, but it should not be caricatured either.
Not even the most bureaucratic General 'The block vote is no more democratic than • ›cratic than the unions are generally, but no less so either' Secretary can do what he or she likes with the block vote. They are bound by their union's conference decisions and by the majority of their union delegation. The last general secretary to try to buck those rules was Sid Weighell of the NUR, in the early 1980s, and he was forced out of his job as a result.
The block vote is no more democratic than the unions are generally, but no less so either. The way to make it more democratic is to make the unions more democratic — a task which is necessary anyway.
TWO. The trade unions are not perfect organisations, but they are the mass organisations of the working class. Without the working class there can be no struggle for socialism; and without its organisations the working class is not a force to change society, but only a collection of victims of exploitation.
That the Labour Party rests on workers' organisations rather than just an aggregate of individual members is a strength, not a weakness.
If the Labour Party broke its links with the unions, it would transform itself into nothing better than a second-rate Liberal Party. In fact John Edmonds doesn't want that. He wants to retain the trade unions' influence in the Labour Party. Only he wants that influence to be exercised more bureaucratically!
The block vote is embarrassingly public, and therefore open to accountability. John Edmonds wants everything stitched up behind closed doors in cabals of union leaders and Labour frontbenchers called "policy commissions" Edmonds alternative to the block vote, is not as democratic as it sounds.
Firstly, all Labour Party members do have a vote now — which they can cast at a meeting. Secondly, Edmonds clearly means "one member, one postal vote"
Democracy is more than just about voting. Look at America. There is more voting there than anywhere else in the world. Thousands of public officials, from local dog-catchers to the President, are directly elected, and even the main candidates for President are chosen by popular vote through the "primary" system.
Undoubtedly it's better than the preGorbachev USSR, with its compulsory 99.9% "votes" for bureaucraticallyappointed rulers. But it's a very pale, corrupt form of democracy.
Politics is just a branch of show business. It has very little to do with informed debate on issues. Political campaigns consist mostly of spending millions of dollars on TV advertising about your opponent's alleged sexual, medical, psychiatric, or financial flaws.
The American people are not more gullible, or less educated, than people elsewhere. Most of them are disgusted with the way that politics works in the It's right that unions should have a collective voice. Photo: John Harris New problems, New