Will Labour outlaw solidarity
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 23 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 23
LABOUR AND THE UNIONS Miners join health workers' pickets, 1982. Photo: John Harris Wed che Dock la our tie hen the government abolishdockers could not strike against the decision because that would be 'political' They voted to strike instead for the demand that the port employers negotiate a national deal guaranteeing the same conditions as the Dock Labour Scheme. The employers got a court injunction to stop the strike.
They claimed that a previously unnoticed clause in the law setting up the Dock Labour Scheme had made dock strikes unlawful since 1947! The judge said he didn't know about that, but since the harm to the employers of a strike seemed more grievous to him than the harm to the workers of not striking, he would ban the strike.
By the time that a full court hearing decided that the Dock Labour Scheme did not, after all, ban strikes, the legal life of the dockers' original vote had expired, and they had to ballot again.
Even then, the union had to be careful to call for action only in the ports registered under the Dock Labour Scheme. Any action in other ports, or any picketing of those ports by registered dockers, would be unlawful "secondary' action.
The railworkers also had to ballot twice over the same industrial action in 1989. The judge decided that their first ballot paper was badly worded.
In October 1989, manual workers at three big engineering factories voted clearly for strikes to win a 35-hour week, and their unions called them out.
British Aerospace first tried to get the courts to stop the strikes altogether on the grounds that the ballot had not produced a two-thirds majority in all seven plants where it was held (although it had produced a simple majority); and then succeeded for a few days in getting an injunction against MSF manual workers at Preston striking on the ground that although they had a majority for striking, the whole MSF membership there, white-collar included, had not.
New proof comes in almost every week that the Tory union laws are not really about democracy for trade union members. They are about preventing effective industrial action.
Any action at all is unlawful unless it is against your own employer at your own place of work. That means that if your employer does what Rupert Murdoch did to his printworkers — provoke a strike, sack them, and re-open business elsewhere - there is nothing you can do lawfully against him. If your boss artificially divides his business into separate units, you can only take action unit by unit.
Even within those limits, you cannot strike unless you have first ballotted -and ballotted in a way that a crusty old High Court judge finds satisfactory. The number of things they can find wrong with ballots is increasing all the time!
Then you cannot have more than six pickets, and you can't expel strikebreakers from your union or penalise them.
If you strike unlawfully, your union leaders have to do more than just abstain from supporting you. As the National Union of Seamen found out in the Dover P&O Ferries dispute, they have to act effectively to wreck your strike. Otherwise the union's entire funds will be seized.
And the Tories are planning even more restrictions, including bans on strikes in 'essential services' The first duty of a Labour government should be to restore workers' legal right to take effective action for wages and conditions against the bosses. But the Policy Review falls far short of that.
It promises to repeal the "more objectionable" bits of Tory law, but it also says it will keep other bits. "Union members should have the right to a secret ballot on...strikes.
"Although in the nature of industrial disputes there will continue to be occasions on which walk-outs take place and strike action occurs before any ballot can be arranged, a ballot should subsequently be held. Any union member should be able to appeal to an independent tribunal if a ballot has not been held."
The problem here is not whether strike ballots are desirable. Often they are, so long as they are workplace ballots; held after collective diseussion. The problem is whether a judge, or a supposedly 'independent tribunal, should have the power to decide when and how a ballot New problems, New struggles Page 21
Scan page 24
Firefighters battling the last Labour government's disastrous incomes policy, in 1977 should be called, and a satisfactory one.
It doesn't take a lot of imagination to picture how judges could use such powers to call ballots at critical moments during strike action, timed to suit the bosses.
They should not have that power. Trade union democracy should be regulated by trade union members, not by the State.
The Policy Review goes on to say that unions' funds being seized ('sequestrated') by courts "is completely unacceptable", though it does not say what penalties it will propose for unions which call strikes which are still unlawful. And it promises that it will stop injunctions being granted to stop strikes without the union's case first being heard by the judge.
Whether the judge takes any notice is, of course, another matter. And the Policy Review indicates that Labour should keep manical and secondary seikes, loosen. ing them only where "workers have a geINCASE FIRE - * 10 PEC