'Agencies' in the civil
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 22 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 22
service Branches Against A Campaign (persona capacity)
The government wants to break and privatise the Civil Service. It wants to erode the national terms an conditions fought for by the Civil Service unions over the years. In 1981 enpore am proting Management in • Sir Robin Ibbs Government: The Next Steps'. It proposed re organising the Civil Service into separate management units or 'Executive Agencies'.
The 'Next Steps' report is a politi compromise between the hard line Thatcherites in the Cabinet who favour the creation of Agencies as a stepping stone to full-scale privatisation, and the Treasury who resist losing control of the purse strings. However, one of the Department of Social Security computer centres at Livingstone has already been privatised and it is clear that the Tories won't stop there.
Agency status will give managemen greater flexibility in personal and financial terms. Most government departments have been told they will become Agencies - some have already started the process.
Agency status will mean the break up of national pay bargaining and devolve disciplinary action down to local management. For example, at Companies House in Cardiff, one of the first Agencies, a long-standing member of staff has recently been sacked for a minor disciplinary matter. We have a lot to lose and very little to gain with Agency statu What have the unions done dext to nothing. The largest Civil Service union, the Civil and Public Sarvices Association (CPSA) has a leadership which makes Eric Hammond look radical. They have wolcomed Agency Status falsely Pago 20 New problems, New struggles believing it will halt privatisation. John Ellis, the CPSA General Secretary, wrote to a local Branch Secretary: "You will be interested to know, I am sure, that DSS computer centres would have been privatised had the Agency option not been around". This was written five days after the announcement that Livingstone computer centre had been sold off to Electronic Data Systems, a non-union subsidiary of General Motors.
The second largest union in the Civil Service, the National Union of Civil and Public Servants (NUCPS) have made more noise about Agencies, but failed to organise any action against it. The need for a fightback A CPSA branch, DSS Merthyr Tydfil, wrote to every CPSA branch in June 1989 urging branches to come together to fight Agencies. It initiated a campaign, now called 'Branches Against Agencies', which has begun to raise the issue among CPSA branches. It has urged branches to demand a recall CPSA conference (under union rule 1.2, 25% of branches can call a conference) but the National Executive Committee has totally ignored the policy.
The campaign, sponsored by over branches, has also laid plans for an unofficial conference next February should the NEC fail to organise a recali conference.
The conference will put the campaign on a firm footing to increas the pressure on the CPSA leadership to start recognising the danger of Agencies and also to increase the confidence of the rank and file branch delegates to mount an independent campaign if necessray to defeat the government's plans.
The Branches Against Agencies campaign has come under enormous pressure from the CPSA bureaucrac to halt its campaign, including threat of disciplinary action, but the campaign is refusing to back down because If Agencies aren't stuffai then the whole future of the union would be in jeopardy. bureaucratic caricature as long as the economic environment — trade, banking, the State — is controlled by market forces or by privileged classes. But there is every reason to believe that workers' control could work very well under democratic planning and a workers' state.
Neither the Bolsheviks in 1917-18, nor most other groups of workers trying to introduce workers' control, wanted to get rid of all the old managers. On the contrary, they wanted to keep them, use their skills, learn from them.
Trade unionists in Britain today often "Workers' control means putting the workers' wide-ranging knowledge about efficiency, safety and social need as the guiding intelligence in place of the shareholders' narrow knowledge of the bottom line. have more technical skills and more knowledge of how their workplaces are run than Russian workers had in 1917-18. In the late '70s, workers in Lucas, Vickers and other firms drafted detailed "workers' plans" for alternative patterns of production for their enterprises.
We would, however, still need to use and learn from the skills of the managers, accountants, and production planners. Many of these people are, indeed, workers themselves, only higher-paid.
To make sure that democratic accountability worked properly, and to stop the workers" betro would also indude aining lots of workers in managerial and accounting skills.
At present, managers are hired and fired by big shareholders, who judge them by their ability to produce profits. Under workers' control, they woula be hirea ano fired by workers' committees, who would judge them by their ability to produce for social need and ensure good working conditions.
Big shareholders know about profits. The workforce of any enterprise has a huge fund of knowledge about how the job can be done efficiently, safely and well. Workers' control means putting the workers' wide-ranging knowledge in place of the shareholders' narrow knowledge of the bottom line as the guiding intelligence.
It can work. It will work.