Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How to deal with 'Japanese' work methods

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 21–22 · about 1,556 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 21 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 21

Kenny Murphy, a senior shop steward at General Port car factory, discusses the bosses' drive for 'Japanese' working methods like Quality Circles and team work A have had success with what lot of American companies they call QWL, Quality of Working Life. It is a brainstorming cum brainwashing technique, but it only works if workers are willing to participate.

For General Motors, the jewel in the crown was the New United Motor Manufacturing Incorporated project, a joint venture with Toyota to produce cars in Fremont. They closed the Fremont plant down, laid everyone off, and then selectively re-employed. Productivity rocketed, and quality did as well.

It worked because people actually got something out of it. The average person on the shoptioor got easily suckea into it because in a boring, repetitive job, QWL gave you a little bit of kudos and a little bit of initiative, you haven't really but you feel you have a say in what goes on.

Around 1984 they tried to introduce the same approach in Britain. They decided they couldn't get anywhere by jackboot methods any more.

In the 1984 pay deal our grading structure was altered so that people could do work that they didn't normally do. For example, a lot of quality inspection has been given to people already on the track.

We have quite a lot of people doing that in our plant. In Luton they've got hardly anybody. It was negotiated. The dispute we had in 1984 was over the company trying to bring in merit money. We had a short dispute, and they said merit money was off the table. Merit money meant that the foreman would assess each person and say which should get extra money.

We got that thrown out, but we accepted the rest; and there's no doubt about it, it's worked in that people are building better quality cars.

Some things which we signed for in the deal never happened, mainly due to the ineptitude of the management. Then they brought in a new bloke called Angel Perversi. Sweeping changes were made in management from 1986.

In 1987 they introduced 'versatility' but we got paid for being versatile. They changed the 'C' grade — which is the production operators, where I work — to what they called CTC production. They also said there'd be no forced redundancies during the lifetime of the agreement.

They introduced three shift maintenance work for the skilled people. They tried to get us to days we stopped that one.

The whole strategy is one of piecemeal change in different places and different workforces, depending on how organised you are.

In the paintshop at Luton, for example, they have it all going, teamwork, the lot. At Luton they've also got the IBC, the Isuzu Bedford van Company on the same site as Vauxhall. At IBC they do everything. They've got no measured day work, no time study, nothing like that; instead it's all team work and Quality Circles. And it's worth a few bob to anyone who's on it.

When they took over the IBC, they consolidated all the bonus into basic pay. They must be among the best hourly paid production workers in Britain, with the bonus consolidated into the hourly rate. But they lost a lot of jobs, and their up. At the ena or in day it's all geared to one thing...more cars with less deodle"

union-company agreement is the worst in the industry. It's even worse than Nissan.

At Ellesmere Port we got a bloke over from America and educated the stewards about Quality Circles. We didn't just give them the T&G booklets, which aren't really that good, we went through the whole history of Quality Circles.

We explained how QCs can mean losing jobs and the pace of the track increasing.

But they've increased the suggestions scheme. For the first time ever they have made it worthwhile to put suggestions in. People are getting thousands of pounds now where they used to get £20 or £30. The top pay out now is about f8,000.

It's part of the company's plans. It's called continuous improvement. You don't have time study or anything like that — when someone puts in a suggestion on a job, it gets carried out regardless of measured day work. You just do it.

It's buttering people up. At the end of the day it's all geared to one thing, and that's to do more cars with less people. Trade union activists know that but the average worker doesn't know.

They want team work, too. I've heard people say we could gain control through team work, but it doesn't work like that.

I'm a steward for 32 men. That would be four groups. How can there be a steward for four different groups of people? It doesn't work.

If we do accept team work, we'll have to insist on four stewards. If you're split and you have one steward looking after four groups of men, you can't possibly have control.

Our strategy with these new working methods ever since 1984 has been to negotiate through them, placing demands ana conditions rather than trying to just keep knocking them back. We're lucky that we've had a boom while we've been negotiating our way through it. If there was a recession in the industry, we'd have problems, because then they'a be able to come in with anything they wanted. But luckily, up to now, we've been able to negotiate our way through.

In this next pay deal, this 'Meeting the Challenge' package, the company wants to do away with time study and measured day work altogether. We've got them to back off on that.

The company's been clever too. Where they've had a problem with a job, they've robotised it, mechanised it, or altered the whole set up so it's got to be re-timed. They are now aiming to do this without re-timing.

The international GM combine committee meets once a year now. But there isn't anyone in the world who has successfully resisted the changes they are looking for.

And when our people go to international conferences, the other people, except the Brazilians, seem to be in the opposition camp. The union leaders in the plants are all up to their bollocks in employee involvement, QWi, and the rest I believe we've got to change our union structure if we are going to have anything to do with team work. If they then offer the people on the shopfloor enough money, we're going to have it, so 1 believe we've got to alter our structure in work to cope with it, to keep intact the union's integrity.

They are going to break people into small groups of 8, 10, or 12, each group will have a team leader ana the team leader will be totally responsible for that group.

Our attitude has always been that if the company want to talk quality, we'll talk quality, but we're not talking Quality Circles. It's taken a long time but the people we work with are coming round to that now.

If they'd come at us in 1984 and said take all this or we'll close you down, we'd have been beaten. But we had five years to prepare.

It's hard to fight an invisible enemy. The company keeps changing the goalposts. You have a vision of what's going on, and all of a sudden they change.

back again with another plan to do what they wanted in the first place.

No Fit Mon see : 19

Scan page 22

The workers can n every modern workers' revolution, workers fight to control production and distribution.

In Poland's second city, Lodz, the workers' movement Solidarnose won control over the distribution of food in summer 1981. Meanwhile there was a strong movement in the factories for workers' control over production. In September 1981, 90 per cent of the 24,000 workers at the Lenin steelworks voted for "the workers' council running the enterprise" and "choosing and recalling the manager"

In Portugal, in 1975, workers' commissions were the major power in many factories and banks, often the decisive voice in getting the enterprise nationalised.

In France in 1968, distribution of food, petrol and electricity in the city of Nantes was controlled for a period by the workers' Central Strike Committee. In Barceiona especially, were controlled by workers' committees.

In the USSR in 1917-18, factory councils monitored everything the manager did.

But is workers' control sustainable as more than a short experin ent? None of the revolutionary experimel Its in workers' control lasted long. Even in the USSR, where the workers took state power, control by the factory councils collapsed under the pressure of the Civil War and the catastrophic dislocation of industry during it.

The workers' cooperatives set up in several workplaces threatened with closure in Britain in the 1970s all collapsed. In Yugoslavia, each workplace is formally under the democratic control of its workers, but the economy combines most of the vices of the free market with most of the vices of bureaucratic planning.

All these experiences prove that workers' control in single workplaces can only be a brief experiment or a

----- pull-quotes -----

It's buttering people 2. At the end of the

workers ndustry!

Spain in 1936-7, at the beginning of the Civil War, many factories, around

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →