Who gains from new technology?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 18 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 18
«Within the capitalist system methods for raising the social productivity of labour are put into effect at the cost of the in dividual workers; all means for the development of production undergo a dialectical inversion s that they become means of domination and exploitation of the producers; they distort the worker into a fragment of man they degrade him to the level o an appendage of a machine, the destroy the actual content of h labour by turning it into a torment; they alienate from him the intellectual potentialities of the labour process in the same proportion as science is incorporated in it as an independent power; they deform the conditions under which he works, subject him during the labour process to a despotism the more hateful for its meanness they transform his life-time in 1o working time."
Karl Marx performance-related addition.
Numerical flexibility should al: so be opposed, with the demand to bring as many jobs as possible 'in-house' under a uniform union agreement.
If the battle cannot be won unions should demand:
• Full-time rights for part-time workers.
• 'Peripheral' workers to have the same conditions and rates of pay as 'core' workers doing comparable jobs. 'Top-up' money to bring workers on government training schemes up to trade union rates.
• All 'peripheral' workers, including those working for sub-contractors, to be unionised, preferably in the same union as the 'core' workers.
• Offers of full-time jobs at the end of their contracts for all government-scheme trainees and temporary workers.
problems, Computer technology has had an impact on all types of wook, •from supermarket check-out operators through assembly line workers to doctors, and journalists.
Since the development of micro processors in the early 1970s, it has been possible to include the capacities of a computer in almost any tool used in production and to develop many new tools such as industrial robots, computer-aided design systems and word processors.
And computer technology has different capacities from all previous forms of technology. It can mechanise mental work as well as manual or physical work, and put 'intelligence' into all sorts of products. It can monitor its own, and its operator's, actions and use this information to trigger other activities. It can provide and transfer information as well as controlling devices to transform inputs into finished products.
Computer technology could be used to reduce radically the amount of time humans have to work. It could increase the flow of useful goods and services, and reduce drudgery.
At present, however, it is being introduced to further the aims of a capitalist economy in a period of deep crisis. New technology is used as a way of restructuring capital, both to increase its profitability and to shift the balance of power further away from the workforce.
This is not an inevitable result of the technology itself, though applications are often designed with these ends in mind. How successful the employers are depends on the response of trade unionists and their power to enforce certain choices about how new technology is designed and implemented.
Although very high levels of automation in manufacture are still rare in Britain, computer technology is widespread. One third of manual workers and two thirds of office workers in 2000 establishments surveyed in 1987 were using new technology introduced, and the proportions are still increasing fast.
The content and effects of technology vary across different sectors of the economy, though there are some general trends such as a polarisation of skill levels and a trend towards a more flexible workforce.
In manufacturing industry, there were over 2,000 programmable robots by 1985, mainly in jobs such as welding and paintspraying. Other parts of production can also use computer technology: computeraided design (CAD) is increasingly replacing traditional draughtsmanship; and computer numerically-controlled machine tools (CNC) can be programmed to produce a range of components.
Increasingly the aim is to integrate these processes and add other features such as stock control and order processing to bring the whole of production under the control of a single computerised system.
Such systems are rare at the moment, both because the vast cost of such systems means there must be a huge market for the products and because there have been some very expensive failures. In these systems the trend is for the worker to take on a number of functions: maintenance, supervision of the process and controlling parts or all of the process through computerised mechanisms. This overall control is traditionally a manager's function.
More common is partial computerisation of production, as on the BL Metro line. Here CAD, CNC for engine production, robotic welding for car assembly and automated pressing of bodies were introduced without full computer control. Even that level of computerisation is still rare in British manufacturing, though new plants tend to use similar advanced manufacturing technology.
Computerisation tends to be far more advanced in process control industries such as chemicals where there has been a high degree of automation for some time.
In retailing, computer technology has made work increasingly like work on an assembly line. Computer systems are tied to tills to provide records of what is sold and this is used for stock control. Bar codes allow items to go on the shelf without pricing. Workers on the tills may be expected to work at a particular rate, which can be monitored by the computer. Warehousing is also increasingly automated. Computerisation allows the
Scan page 19
number of sales assistants to be cut, and the big firms to cut their overheads and compete on smaller margins.
Office work has also been radically transformed by new technology. The word processor (WP) is only one of a series of technologies that have increased the speed of producing a document by 50%. The development of electronic communications has led to talk of 'the paperless office, though, in fact, the effect of introducing word processors has often been to produce more paper and even to require more workers.
All the evidence shows that there is little general opposition of office workers to new technology. After all, a word processor makes the job of typing and editing documents less irritating than a typewriter. Workers have, however, objected to side-effects of the way word processing has been introduced.
The way jobs are redefined can lead to a new division of labour in which the unskilled operator is given a monotonous job, typing with little human contact, while the skils of traditional secretaria work are hived off to 'personal assistants'. Computers can also be used to monitor the workers' speed here.
Much traditional record-keeping work can also be computerised, and the number of jobs in this field will decline drastically. An example of this is the DHSS, where the government want to centralise and computerise benefit payments at the cost of 15,000 jobs and a worse service to claimants. The DHSS wants both to cut costs and undermine a traditionally militant group of trade unionists.
Similar computerisation can take place in all areas involving records and transfer of information or money, such as banking and finance. The number of local banks has declined, and the Midland is now offering a computerised telephone-only banking service.
Employers can have a number of motives for introducing new technology. The most common is to become more competitive by cutting costs. This can take the nced to keep touring overheads (88. place through jobs cuts, by reorganisation Another element can be the wish to reduce the level of skill required to do the job, either because (as in the print before Wapping) the old technology gives the workers a degree of control, or because new technology allows costs to be cut, and skill shortages to be overcome.
The use of CNC machines, for example, removes control of setting the machine from the worker on the line to the programmer of the machine. In the mines, new technology has been used directly to increase management control.
The deskilling effect of new technology is, however, neither as inevitable nor as entirely beneficial to management as it is often presented. New technology can often be made to adapt to the workers' skills and needs rather than the other way round. This means that the design and content of the technology must become part of the unions' bargaining agenda, though this is not easy to achieve. In 1983 only 7% of agreements on technological change involved the unions at the stage of planning the system. Trade unionists often lack the technical skills required to negotiate effectively on these issues.
The use of computer technology often creates new skills, usually of a different type from the old skills - more conceptual or logical than based on making or doing something. It is up to the unions to ensure that those skills are made available as widely as possible and that retraining is provided for existing workers.
However, it is a matter of dispute whether a computer system can ever totally replace successfully 'making and doing' knowledge of skilled workers, and computerisation that does not provide for using those human skills may fail. For example, in chemical processes workers may develop knowledge based on the appearance, and or feel of, a substance that cannot be reproduced on a VDU.
There are other risks in computerisation for the employers. First, a system that doesn't take account of how workers do a job may not be accepted by them. It may not work. In the Passport Office dispute workers refused to use a system which aimed to cut jobs, but made issuing a passport take 15% longer. It has subse'There always choices about how new technology is implemented. Trade unionists must ensure it workers' interests quently been scrapped. The workers often know best how to do a job, but have not been given decision-making power, or even consulted, in the design of the system.
Computerisation can also give a considerable amount of power to a small number of key workers, who keep vital computer systems going. The recent NALGO strike showed the power of such workers to hit their employers hard, as did the strike at DHSS Central Office a few years ago, which cost the government millions of pounds.
How should the unions deal with new technology? Many of the workers worst affected are in sectors where traditionally organisation is difficult and unionisation is low - for example, office work (outside the public sector), finance and retailing. In addition, many firms where high technology is produced, or implemented, are on greenfield sites, where unions are either banned or have low membership For example, in 'Silicon Glen' Scotland, even unions such as the EETPU have to bring people in from elsewhere to recruit members by leafletting outside the gates at some of the electronics plants.
Some firms such as IBM or Nissan try to buy out the need for unions, either by offering lots of bonuses and perks subject to individual assessment or by using consultation mechanisms to give the appearance of an identity of interests between the workers and management.
Before the unions can take on the issues of new technology in these areas, they need to recruit heavily. Gimmicks like the EETPU's offer of BUPA schemes are unlikely to attract either highly skilled workers in greenfield sites or low-paid workers in offices or retailing. They need to be convinced that joining a union will make a real difference to their working conditions which in turn requires a fighting rank and file policy Secondly, the unions need to develop a policy on new technology itself. Two strategies should be avoided: outright rejection of new technology on principle and 'business as usual' shopfloor militanThe first can rarely be successful in the long run; the second doesn't realise that the introduction of new technology can radically alter the balance of power on the shopfloor, undermining the existing bases of union power. Both leave the context and method of implementing new technology to the employer.
Instead trade unionists should not see new technology as something given to be accepted or rejected as a whole, but as a focus for struggle. A starting point must be that any changes in job content or introduction of new technology must be notified to the union beforehand and negotiated. Such negotiations should be on the basis of no job loss and retraining of existing workers.
There should also be moves towards cutting working hours where new technology is introduced to ensure that its benefits do not all go to the employer and that the policy of no job loss can become a reality.
If trade unionists are to maintain or extend control over their jobs, they must be involved in the design of and decision-making about new systems.
Two researchers, Hugo Levie and Robin Williams, explain why: "By the time the technology is being implemented, many characteristics of the system will have been fixed and the scope for negotiating over the impacts may • be reduced... the union is left with a reactive role. Influence of this sort is unreliable, especially in the not infrequent situation where new technology is designed to undermine such job control."
They also stress problems with this approach. One is not having the technical knowledge to challenge management and thus running the risk of being co-opted, and supporting proposals because we have no alternative. "A major problem confronting this strategy is the way given policies of new technology and associated systems are, presented as the only possibility...
Apart from the accountability of the negotiators, they see a solution in the "development of an independent trade union perspective on charactertistics required of new technology, to help the representatives avoid identifying themselves unreservedly with the systems being proposed."
This would also require access to full information and training.
Given the relative weakness of shopfloor organisation and control after ten years of Thatcher, it may be unlikely that such a policy could be won at company or shopfloor level. We may also need to campaign for legislation along the lines of that in Sweden and Norway, where employers are forced to negotiate the introduction of new technology.
A 'Charter for New Technology' could take its place alongside the 'Charter for Workers' Rights' as part of a strategy to force a Labour government to redefine the balance of employment law in favour of the unions.
The watchword of trade unionists' attitude to new technology should be "It can be done differently" • There are always choices about how new technology is implemented. Trade unionists must ensure it serves workers' interests.
Scan page 20
Pete Keenlyside, Manchester Amalgamated Branch, UCW Up to the mid-1970s, the Post Or Parcels Offee