Pulling together the wages fight
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 16
ducer services (telecommunications, accountancy, banking, etc.) have increased their share of total employment; but some of this is a matter of the same work being contracted out, and thus appearing in the statisties under 'services' • rather than 'manulacturing', not the work changing. The biggest increase over a long period has been in social services - health education, etc. The Tories' cuts have stalled this increase for now, but it is likely to continue in future.
The shift from blue-collar work to white-collar has been much more drastic and unambiguous. In 1911, only 19 per cent of workers were white-collar. By 1971, it was 43 per cent; by 1985, 55 per cent.
And these growing sectors of the working class are being 'Fordised', pushed towards factory production-lines methods of working, rather than 'post-Fordised'. Whatever is happening in manufacturing, the trend in hospitals, colleges, social security offices and telephone exchanges is towards more concentration and centralisation.
Trade unionism is growing fast in those sectors. It has not been growing fast enough to make up for the terrible losses suffered by trade unionism in its traditional bastions in heavy industry, but it has been Twenty years ago, workers in health, education, social security and so on had no shop stewards and never struck. Now they are sometimes among the bestorganised and most radical sections of the working class.
This shift raises strategic problems for the labour movement. Many of these public service workers produce no profits directly (though the Tories' policies of privatisation will begin to change that), and it is difficult for them to work out methods of industrial action which hit the bosses hard while minimising the effects on patients, students, or claimants. Difficult - but not impossible.
Certainly the trade union movement has suffered defeats in the 1980s — as it suffered defeats in most advanced capitalist countries in the 1920s, and again in the late '40s and early '50s. But defeats do not abolish the working class or the class struggle.
In the late '60s and early "70s, the great post-war expansion of capitalism faltered and lurched into slump. The first result was a tremendous explosion of industrial militancy.
soon, the left had a chance to impose its political answers. After twenty years of uninterrupted Christian Democrat rule in West Germany, the Social Democrats became the leading party of government from 1969 to 1982. Labour took office in Britain after the miners had defeated the Tories in 1974. The Socialist Party quickly became Spain's leading party after the fall of the fascist regime in 1976. France's Socialists and Communists won power in 1981.
And everywhere the left failed. Its old Keynesian policies neither replaced problems, The rise in inflation which makes inflationproofing of wages so 'disruptive' for the bosses also makes it more important for the unions. The fact that price rises could continue high for some time or even accelerate, underlines both these messages Since the stock market crash of October 1987, the risk has been clear of a drastic new slump, which could swiftly wipe out all the limited gains that some sections of workers have made in the last few years.
'Escalator clauses', of a 'sliding scale' -committing bosses to pay rises, preferably monthly, in line with the cost of living -are an old trade union demand. It's time give them more prominence and more urgent consideration.
A sliding scale cannot replace the fight for a real increase. London Underground workers are fighting for catch-up rises to make good the whittling-away of their re wage levels over recent years; the sliding scale is not a substitute for that fight either. But it can very well be fought for, and even won, alongside those demands.
Many countries - from Italy to the United States, from Australia to Belgium - had forms of sliding scale for many years, covering major industries or even a workers.
The sliding scale is most relevant today in countries like Poland, where rapid inflation is pushing the working class into desperate poverty. It was a major issue in the early-'89 talks between the Stalinist: government and Solidarnosc.
In the end the Solidarnosc leaders agree to 'pay for' the government's limited liberalisation by limiting sliding scale pay rises to only 80 per cent of the price rise. Militants in Solidarnosc have protested strongly.
Even where it is not such an urgent and central issue, however, the sliding scale cal be important because it is a unifying factor in wage struggles. It is a demand that can be raised by and for all workers.
The essential idea is that workers should assert some conscious control over our standard of living rather than being the helpless victims of market forces which allow us some gains in booms and then throw us down again in slumps. Control is also important over the calculation of thi cost of living index. Official government figures can grossly underestimate the rei inflation rate for most workers. Sliding scale agreements should be linked to Unite for 35 hours At present the UK has the highest average weekly working hours for men in the EC. The figure stands at 42.4 hours per week.
A cut in the average working week to 35 hours would quickly cut unemployment.
But the bosses don't like it. Reduced working hours would mean reduced profits for the bosses - unless they could cut pay drastically at the same time.
The TUC should take up this infition indexes worked movement.
The sliding scale can and should be raised not just as an element for trade union claims, but as a demand for legislation by a future Labour government.
Instead of blathering about how a Labour government "won't be a soft touch for the unions", Labour leaders should be committing themselves to safeguard working class living standards by a sliding scale which underpins all wage agreements and also safeguards state benefits against inflation.
Sometimes the sliding scale demand is not very useful. Obviously it has little bite when inflation is low.
In 1972-3 a sort of half-sliding scale -threshold agreements - was pushed by the Tory government. The Tories imposed wage controls, and tried to ease them in by saying that workers would get increases above the decreed maximum at the rate of one per cent for each one per cent the inflation rate rose above a 'threshold'.
The idea of threshold agreements was launched not by the Tories but by the TUC in early 1972; but the Tories then used the formula to try to tie the unions into wage controls.
The Tories were trying to damp down, obstruct, diffuse and divert a great wave of industrial militancy which had already broken their previous efforts at wage controls and made their Industrial Relations Act unworkable. To agitate for a full sliding scale in place of their half sliding scale, instead of opposing the whole affair, would have played into their hands.
Times are different today. In fact the threshhold agreements of 1972-3 rebounded nastily on the bosses, producing big wage rises in 1974 as inflation rose to levels that no-one had expected.
Since then bosses have been much more wary about anything like a sliding scale; and its value for workers has been much clearer. Over the years since the runaway inflation of 1974-5 and 1979-80, bosses in many countries have fought hard to get ri of sliding scale agreements dating from thi '50s or the '60s.
Working class confidence is reviving today; but we do not have anything like the great industrial offensives of the early '70s. Demands which can begin to knit together unity and map out a solid defensive position are at a premium. sliding scale is one of those. the engineers and campaign for a 35 hour week and an end to overtime working, linked to a serious fight for a minimum wage of at least two-thirds of the average manual worker's wage.
At the moment the engineers are in the front line of the battle for a shorter working week. The labour movement as a whole should take up this cause and make it central to a crusade against the Tories.
Scan page 17
Losses talk a lot about flexibility these days. It all sounds very go-ahead. Who wants to be rigid and hidebound when you could be flexible and adaptable?
The real issues are more complex. When the demands of profit point one way, and workers' interests another, the question is not flexibility or no, but who will be flexible.
The bosses want workers to be flexible to fit in with the rhythms and tempos of Capital. Those rhythms and tempos should be the fixed, rigid factor, and workers should adapt.
The bosses want workers to be flexible about our job security, our living standards, and our health and safety, to fit in with the ups and downs of the market and the urgent demand of new, expensive machinery to have workers operating for as many hours as possible in the week.
The bosses' flexibility is about capital and machinery using workers as a means to make profit, rather workers using machinery as a means to make useful things.
That is how capitalism works. The bosses buy workers' labour-power by paying wages just sufficient to sustain the workers and their families at the sociallyestablished minimum standard of living. Then they strive to use the labour-power to create the maximum possible amount of new value-added. The difference between that value-added and the wages yields profit, dividends, interest and rent.
The purpose of labour, under capitalism, is to feed capital's drive for self-expansion.
But labour is also human beings deploying their skills, their talents, their intelligence and their creativity. The two aspects of labour — service to capital and human activity — are at war with each other under capitalism. Truce lines shift constantly.
Capitalists accept some human 'rigidities' because they know they need human skills to do business. But they accept them only provisionally. When competition sharpens and technology changes rapidly, as in the '80s, they try to shift the truce line.
In his book Trade Unions in Britain Today John Mcilroy tabulates the four main fronts of the drive for flexibility.
Functional flexibility means removing job demarcations and being able to move workers from job to job. British Leyland cars brought in a major functional flexibility package in 1980, and similar packages followed in steel, cars, engineering, oil refining and shipbuilding after 1982.
Numerical flexibility means dividing the workforce into core workers, with core skills and some job security, and peripheral workers, who are part-time, temporary, self-employed, employed by sub-contractors, homeworkers, or uo government training' schemes.
The peripheral workforce can be boosted or cut at short notice as the market fluctuates, while the company maintains continuity with its core workforce.
Japanese industry has long used this system. British government estimates for 1985 showed that part-timers, temporary workers, homeworkers, and the self-employed were 34 per cent of the entire workforce — an increase from 30 per cent in 1981. The government is trying to expand this sort of flexibility in public services by introducing agencies in the civi service and forcing local authorities to put up jobs to competitive tender.
Flexibility of time means new shift patterns (like flexible rostering on the rall), flexitime (workers being able to start and finish when they like, as long as they turn up for certain 'core' hours and do a fixed amount of work in a month or a year) and job-sharing.
Financial flexibility means pay being related more closely to work performance. In the United States, though not yet commonly in Britain, some employers have also established different (lower) rates of pay for newly-recruited workers, even when they are doing the same jobs as established workers.
The unions' response to flexibility cannot be simply to oppose it all, across the board. Dogmatic defence of agreements and demarcations linked to outdated technology is futile and doomed to defeat.
Functional flexibility can allow workers to learn new skills and have more interesting jobs; and it can cut away harmful divisions between different grades of workers.
Trade unions should demand:
• Consultation with the union over workers being moved from job to job. Otherwise flexibility can be used to break up organised groups of workers and to victimise militants.
• Proper training for any new jobs that workers take on.
• Guarantees against flexibility being used to cut employment.
• Extra pay for new jobs and responsibilities.
Flexibility of time can give workers, as well as bosses, more flexibility.
Many workers who look after children, especially women, need flexible hours. And 'flexible retirement' schemes, which already exist in Sweden, Denmark, Finland, France and Spain, allowing older workers to mix part-time work with pension income, are certainly much better than throwing such workers onto the scrapheap when they want to continue But trade unions should demand:
• Full-time rights (on unfair dismissal, sick leave, holidays, parental leave, and so on) for part-time workers.
• No shift patterns which damage health, endanger safety at work by imposing excessively long shifts, destroy workers' family and social life, or make workers' free time unusable (with gaps between shifts which are too short for them to go home.
• Flexitime not to be used asa substitute for parents' rights to time off to
Scan page 18
look after children when they are sick.
• Flexitime not to be used to get time worked at standard rates when it was ed to compensate.
• Provision for union meetings to held in 'core' working time when workers can attend.
Financial flexibility should generally be opposed. It sets worker against worker, gives scope for favouritism, and makes workers' incomes insecure. If a battle to defeat it outright cannot be won, trade unions should at least demand:
• All performance-related elements in pay to be decided by objective criteria, open to trade union monitoring and negotiation, not by managers' whims.
• Basic rates of pay sufficient for a decent standard of living even without any Print workers against Murdoch SI BRANCH
----- pull-quotes -----
previously worked at overtime rates; or, if it is so used, standard rates should be rais-