Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Taking stock

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 901 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

3y Tom Rigby Until the summer - when the and other strikes intervened -it had become increasingly fashionable, even on the left, to talk of the irreversible historic decline of the unions and of the working class itself.

Norman Willis had spoken of the trade unions facing "a serious crisis... challenges more profound than at any time in the movement's long history"

Since 1979 the unions have lost over 3 million members, with a decline in TUC membership from 12,172,000 in 1979 to 8,700,000 in 1987.

Before we panic we should decline in perspective.

Firstly, almost every slump cuts union *membership. Vast membership losses - much bigger than the present one have 4 been caused by slumps, then made good in subsequence booms. The current decline has been less serious, in some ways, than past decline. There is little evidence of - already organised workers quitting the unions today because of their ineffectiveness. But that happened on a big scale in the depth of the inter-war recession.

The changes in union membership between the wars were on a vast scale, far more traumatic than today.

Between 1920 and 1928, the 42% of their membership. By 1933 — in the depth of the depression — union density was, at 22.6%, less than half its level of the start of the twenties and much less than half of union density today. But by 1939 the unions were recovering - union density rose to 30% in just 6 years.

The decline in union density between 1979 and '88 — from 58% to 51% - was much less drastic than the decline in membership.

And the fall in membership has not been even across all unions. The T&G lost 33% of its membership between 1979 and '86. The Town Hall union NALGO lost only 0.4% and the telecom union NCU increased its membership by 16% (partly thanks to a merger with the CPSA P&T section).

The overall picture is a decline in union membership due to drastic job losses in some sectors of industry which has not be compensated for by unionisation of workers in new expanding sectors.

Why? Not because it is impossible organise these new sectors. Look history.

Industries like cars, which formed the backbone of workers' organisation in the years of the post-war boom, were once unorganised.

Unionisation in new sectors will not be automatic. No inevitable automatic process' organised the mass production industries in the 1930s and '40s, people did it, in real struggles. And the unionisation of new sectors today, too, depends on the struggles of the labour movement. establishment level over redeployment of labour, whilst 4 years later the figure fell to 29%. There were similar declines in negotiations over physical working conditions, staffing levels and recruitment (Millward and Stevens, 1986, 248).

These developments, which apply to both manual and non-manual groups, added to changes in flexibility, could mean that workplace representatives have ceded a measure of the control over work organisation which was regarded as an important achievement of shop stewards in the last 3 decades. They provide some evidence that, if the institutions of workplace unionism are the same as a decade ago, some of the outcomes are different.

Shop stewards' power in the past was not simply based on their ability to increase members' pay — many plants, for example, lacked piecework systems — but on mutuality, their ability to negotiate over staffing, redeployment of labour, speed of work and overtime. The picture emerging of union co-operation in changing the organisation of work could represent a process, already well-developed, of management regaining control by paying for it. Other evidence, such as the increased contact between steward and union officer, could also be interpreted in terms of workplace organisation losing an element of independence (Millward and Stevens, 1986, 127).

The CBI's view is that extensive changes in the organisation of work are occurring, that pay is a crucial lever in securing change and that workplace organisation is "able to secure only minor modifications in the changes requred" (CBI, 1987). The point is reinforced by case studies of management attempts to re-establish control over work which New problems, New struggles

Scan page 14

argue that, on a range of issues including wages, the process of bargaining is increasingly ritualistic, with the outcomes decided in advance by management, who, nevertheless, want to see that 'things are done properly' and maintain the influence of workplace organisation (Chadwick, 1983).

This is related to the argument that recent developments disclose a growing potential for 'enterprise trade unionism' Shop stewards, it is claimed, are becoming detached from the wider union and intergrated more with the employer.

"This does not necessarily mean that they necessarily become more docile but that they identify their interests more with the success of the enterprise and less with the job controls, employment anxieties and concern for the poorly organised of the wider union.

The structure of trade unionism orginally developed for the strategies of the employee solidarity is increasingly being shaped to the needs of the Year 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 (Sou No. of stoppages 2,946 2,332 2,034 2,737 2,498 2,125 1,348 1,344 1,538 1,364 1,221 1,704 1,016 of Employn rolved (000)

1,625 1,166 1,041 4,608 1,513 2,103 1,464 g days t (000)

14,750 6,012 3,284 10,142 9,405 29,474 11,964 4,266 5,313 3,754 27,135 6,402 1,920 3,546 3,702

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →