Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What the NHS White Pap means and how to fight it

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan p. 12 · Max Gordon · about 691 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

The government's plans for the NHS, outlined in its White Paper, will seriously undermine patient care and replace it with profit as the main object of 'British Health PLC' Larger GP medical practices will be able to apply for their own budgets - buying drugs and hospital care for their patients from the cheapest source, public or private. Half of any 'surplus' or profit left over can be kept.

This will be an incentive not to treat 'expensive' patients such as the disabled, the chronically ill, and the elderly. All of these kinds of patients usually need more drugs and medical attention than others, and this will eat into the budget surplus. Thus the most vulnerable in our society are the most likely to be penalised, having to tout themselves from one surgery to another hoping to find a GP that will take them on.

300 British hospitals with 250-plus beds will be able to apply for self-government within the NHS. Their money will come from borrowing (from government and the private sector) and from selling their services to GPs, the health authorities, and other hospitals, public or private. They can also buy services from these sources and must provide certain 'core' services such as Accident and Emergency facilities.

The effect on NHS staff will be dramatic. These hospitals are to be run by a 'trust' governed by a board of 'Executive Directors' who must be able to demonstrate 'strong and effective leadership' and 'financial expertise' These are obviously code words for union-busting and making cuts. Staffing levels, pay and conditions for all staff are to be settled locally. National negotiations and settlements would go out of the window.

For patients these changes would have an equally large impact. Apart from the 'core' services, the large hospitals are free to market whatever services they like. It stands to reason that they are going to opt for the most profitable and marketable sectors of health care. Expensive long-term care is out: high patient turnover and fast protits are in. (Sponsorship hasn't been ruled out - the age of the Benson and Hedges lung cancer clinic perhaps?)

Also in is the prospect of having to travel long distances for treatment because your local hospital had decided it doesn't get a sufficient rate of return by treating your ailment. The least able and those most of care will again be the hardest hit.

On the other hand 'optional extras' such a: a choice of meals or a single room can be yours - provided you pay for them.

'Medical audit' will be used to police GPs and hospital consultants. In itself medical audit is no bad thing — it consists of analysing the use of resources, type of treatment and outcome for the patient to measure the quality of medical care. In the hands of our 'Executive Directors' and the new, restructured Family Practitioners Committees, however, it is likely to become a rod for the back of medical staff. It can be used to ensure a high turnover of patients in those all-important profitable areas of treatment at the expense of the downright unprofitable.

A 'review' of 'merit awards' - separate payments currently made to consultants with particular skills — will ensure they fall into line. In future, to get a merit award, they will have to 'demonstrate their commitment to the management and development of the service' and all awards will be reviewable every five years. Finally there is a small concession to the loony right. They wanted the wholesale scrapping of the NHS in one go - instead they've got a halfway house and the introduction of tax cuts for elderly people with private medical insurance. The White Paper also outlines an expanded role for the private sector in the new set-up, but in competition with new cost-cutting hospital managements the private sector is not likely to fare very well, as the history of competitive tendering has shown.

The basis is here for a concerted fight against these proposals organised on the broadest possible basis. NHS trade unions and local Labour Parties, along with other

----- pull-quotes -----

BAKE /UR HOSPITAL

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →