Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The road to recovery

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 3–10 · Mick O'Sullivan · about 8,402 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

LEARNING THE LESSONS During the tube strike. Photo: Pam Isherword, Format.

Margaret Thatcher came to M power in June 1979, and immediately set about using the state power to cripple the labour movement.

A whole range of anti-trade-union laws have been put on the statute book, giving Britain the most illiberal labour laws this side of Stalinist Europe.

At the same time Thatcher set about demolishing large parts of British industry - steel, coal, shipbuilding. Britain was spiralling into slump. Thatcher and her friends determined to sweat it out, letting unemployment rise higher and higher and using it to help depress, demoralise, and control the working class.

A full-scale Tory counter-revolution was launched, aimed at cutting social benefits, selling off nationalised industry to profiteers, and decimating the Health Service.

A decade later, Britain has been transformed into a happy hunting ground for the spivs and speculators, and a truly wretched place for many millions of working-class people. Thousands of homeless people throng the streets of Thatcher's capital city, many of them young people at the start of their adult lives who, thanks to Tory policies, can any welfare benefits.

The unions are legally hamstrung and reduced to their lowest level of effectiveness for 50 or 60 years. The welfare state has been battered so that it is now a half-derelict sium.

Now Thatcherism has begun to crumble. There is huge dissatisfaction with the Tories, and a good chance that they can be driven from office. But ten years of Thatcherism have convinced large parts of the labour movement, Labour Party and trade unions alike, that the only realistic goal we can set ourselves now is a new right-wing Labour government - a government which will not even undo all the legal shackles that Thatcher has placed on the unions.

It could have been different - so different! When Thatcher came to power, the working-class movement was still immensely strong, and undefeated.

Five years earlier, in 1974, the miners had driven the Tory Government of Edward Heath from office. We could have done that to Thatcher. Mass unemployment had not yet sapped the strength and confidence of the movement.

What did the working class need in response to the slump and the prolonged crisis of capitalism which Thatcher, after 1979, set out to resolve for the bosses by Now

Scan page 4

beating down the working We needed socialism: the socialist revolution!

Now it was unlikely that a socialist revolution would be the first response of the British working class to Thatcherisn and the slump.

What was immediately possible was an explosive rejection of the Tory Government's programme of making the working class pay, an explosive refusal by the workers who had been so militant in the previous period to let themselves be driven out of the factories on to the streets and the dole queues.

What was possible also was for the working class to impose a radical Labour government which was held accountable to the interests of the working class, and which depended for its ability to act on working-class mobilisation.

We didn't get that. What we got was a second and a third Tory election victory. We got a TUC veering to the right, unable even to be decent trade unionists.

Worse than the collapse at the top was the collapse of rank and file militancy. For two and a half decades the rank and file had been able largely to ignore the top union bureaucrats and to defy and even defeat governments. That rank and file militancy collapsed just when it was most needed.

There have been some industrial victories; but all in all industrial militancy has been at a low ebb.

There is reason to be depressed - but no reason to give in to the cosmic gloom and despondency which has overwhelmed super revolutionary left around the sections of the lett, and even of the SWP.

The sun rises and sets, and short of nuclear annihilation it is equally certain that the class struggle will revive. Even devastation like that inflicted on the Chilean workers in 1973 — and we are still far short of that — could not indefinitely prevent a revival of the class struggle there.

Despite the murderously unfavourable conditions, we have had some big trade union struggles in the '80s. The great miners' strike of 1984-5 was one of the epic struggles of the world labour movement. Even as late as that, we could have won, and crippled the Tories, if the miners had got the solidarity of other key sections of workers.

On two occasions during the miners' strike the dockers were briefly on national strike. Dockers and miners together could have beaten Thatcher. With competent leadership, the dockers would have served both their own immediate interests, and those of the working class in general, by raising the demand for the extension of the Dock Labour Scheme to unregistered ports and joining the miners in an onslaught on Thatcher.

But it was not to be. The dockers settled for small compromises; the miners went down to defeat; and the Tories targeted the dockers. In 1989 the dockers had their hard-won rights brutally trampled on, the Dock Labour Scheme abolished, and their union hamstrung by the courts.

While miners and (briefly) dockers were striking in the summer of 1984, the Labour left held power in local government in a number of key cities. The Tories were closing in on them, pressing them to pass on cuts, blocking their option of raisingrates, getting ready to a anish the Greater London Council and the metropolitan authorities.

problems, The miners' strike: defeated for lack of solidarity The local government left could have mobilised their communities against the Tories, opening up another front in a coordinated offensive. What happened? They muddled through and left the miners in the lurch.

In Liverpool, where the self-proclaimed Marxists of Militant had local government power, the month of May 1984 saw the 'Marxists' demobilising their campaign against the Tories and going for a deal with the government.

Deputy council leader Derek Hatton called that deal, announced in July, a "95 per cent victory". In his memoirs he has revealed that the Tory minister told him that he was throwing sops to Liverpool because the government wanted its hands free to 'deal with' Scargill and the miners. They would get Liverpool later, he promised. The Tories kept that promise.

The tantalising near-combination of miners' , dockers', and local government struggles in the summer of 1984 illustrates Conference Saturday 27 January 1990 January 1990 rsity of London Unio :y of London (ULU) the tragic consequences of the lack of a labour movement centre able to integrate and coordinate the different fronts of the class struggle. In 1984 we could have done to Thatcher what we did to Heath a decade earlier. Instead we fought separately and were defeated separately.

Most important, and decisive for the future, is to learn the lessons.

We often talk about the class struggle in military language. Frederick Engels long ago defined the class struggle as a war on three fronts, the industrial, the political, and the ideological. We have had defeats and setbacks on all three fronts. Why?

The visible and obvious reason was the slump, which undermined the strength of the labour movement through mass unemployment. But even at the worst of the slump, the working class still had great potential power. Slumps produce varying effects. After the initial shock was over, the slump in the US in the 1930s spurred Malet Street, London Tubes: Euston Square, Russell Goodge Street)

Speakers from Britain, Europe & the Eastern Bloc Solidarity sessions • Analysis • Ecology movements Labour movements in the Eastern Bloc • Debate The fight for women's rights • National movements • creche • social • videos • food • bookstalls More details from: Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc, c/o 56 Kevan House Wyndham Road, London SES

Scan page 5

the workers to create mass industrial unions for the first time.

The reason why the slump of the early '80s had such a bad effect on the British labour movement is to be found in what went before. The Labour government's betrayals in office opened up workers to despair and disillusionment.

In 1973-4, tremendous industrial militancy had pushed out the Tories and led to the Wilson-Callaghan government - the only thing the labour movement had to put in place of the Tories. Labour won the election on a promise of "an irreversible shift in the balance of wealth and power towards working people" And the result was attacks on the working class and a decline of real wages! In 1976 Dennis Healey and Harold Wilson obeyed the dictates of the International Monetary Fund and started a series of savage cuts in public spending, the beginning of the policies that were later, in their full-blown form, to become known as Thatcherism.

Disappointments sapped the morale of the labour movement.

Those setbacks, in turn, have to be understood in the perspective of the 25 years that had gone before. The rank and file militancy of the '50s, '60s and '70s was tremendously effective on wages and conditions. But its strength and success there was also the root of its political weakness.

It did not have to concern itself very much with the problems of the official leadership structures of the unions, or with the political wing of the labour movement, the Labour Party.

The labour movement was sectionalised and chopped up into segments. Workers on the shop floor, led by their shop stewards, got on with bettering wages and conditions; the politicians did their thing; and nobody except for a few Marxists on one side and Tory strategists on the other bothered too much about the ideas department.

The labour movement provided the rank and file with no socialist perspective into which to fit its militant activity. In the 1920s the shop stewards' movement had seen itself as the industrial wing of a revolutionary socialist movement, clearly linked to a political wing in the Communist Party and the left of the Labour Party. The then-revolutionary Communist Party integrated the three fronts of the class struggle into a coherent strategy. Nothing similar existed in the '60s and '70s in Britain.

Our movement was a series of badlycoordinated prodding and jabbing fingers, which dissipated the strength they could have had if bunched into a good proletarian fist.

When the shop stewards movement and the rank and file militancy were at their peak, what was going on in the Labour Party? Very little. In the mid and late '60s, the best of the left just walked out - as many leftists are walking out now — leaving the shell of the Labour Party to the right wing and to the sectarians around Militant, who controlled the youth movement and concentrated on building up their own organisation in devout seclusion while the class struggle and the struggle against the Vietnam war were raging outside, on the streets and in the factories.

By the time the struggle for internal democracy started shaking the Labour Party after 1979, the slump was already dragging down rank and file industrial militancy. And it was in the trade unions that the left-wing offensive to renovate and reshape the Labour Party met with defeat. In the symbolic contest between left and right over the deputy leadership of the Labour Party in 1981, Tony Benn got 83 per cent of the constituency votes, but the right wing carried most of the unions.

The Labour Party struggle for democracy was itself, of course, a result of the experience of Labour in government in the '70s and the industrial struggles. Yet the two currents, the industrial militancy in the trade unions and the movement within the Labour Party, never properly cohered. They never united their strengths.

The left has had setbacks in the Labour Party because it has failed to win in the unions, not because the Labour Party is the bad side of the labour movement and the unions the good side, as some of the addle-headed sectarians say. By standing outside the Labour Party during the great left-right battles of the 1980s, calling from the sidelines for fainthearts to drop out and retire to the comforts of simple industrial militancy and socialist propaganda, those sectarians, in their own way, have contributed to the setbacks.

The central problem has been our failure to integrate the different strands of labour militancy into a coherent strategy. That's why we could not handle or control the Labour government which rode to 1974 Cars of the movement ha reacted as it has to the slump and Thatcher's exploitation of the slump.

The official leaders have always played a bad role. The slump, the entrenched leadership, but above all the disappointments and limitations of what the movement was and did in the period of its greatest power and strength - those were the reasons for the downturn.

The limitations of the rank and file movement, in turn, are to be traced back Where now on the docks?

Billy Jenks, a Liverpool docks steward, analyses the dockers defeat.

The biggest mistake we made in organisi to defend the National Dock Labour Scheme was the amount of faith we plac in our General Secretary Ron Todd, and the General Executive Council.

We did a lot of work preparing for the Tories' attempt to abolish the Dock Labour Board. We organised numerous national shop stewards' meetings, two national docks conferences, and we got commitments of international support from other dockers with representatives of the German and Spanish dockers attending our conferences.

But having all our members ready wasn't enough. When the National Docks and Waterways Committee took our resolution for an all-out strike to maintain the scheme to Ron Todd and the Executive they rejected it in favour of following the law to the letter and attempting to avoid what they though might be embarrassing to Labour's leadership.

The second problem we had was when we took action we didn't get supporting action from other docks and workplaces.

The financial support was good especiall!

locally, but secondary action was held bac by the fear of the union leadership losing their funds through sequestration.

There is no doubt that we have to be prepared to break the law if we are going to the limitations of the Left — its confusion, its divisions, and, in the case of the Marxist left, its small numbers.

Throughout the '60s and '70s the mainstream broad Labour Left was ideologically bankrupt. Many of them, like Michael Foot, supported Wilson, with criticisms of course.

Their allegedly socialist answer to the problems of British capitalism amounted to the idea of bringing back a version of the controlled siege economy of the Second World War. Many of them managed to be simultaneously soft on Stalinism and blinkered little-Englanders. They responded to the EEC not by trying to build links between British and European workers, but with a benighted littleEngland campaign to keep Britain out.

The decisive defeat for the broad Labour Left which crushed its resistance to Wilson and Callaghan during the 19749 Labour Government was a futile and unnecessary one — its defeat in the June 1975 referendum on whether Britain should withdraw from the Common The Marxist left was numerically feeble, and often (as on the EEC) much of it was tainted by the same confusion as the mainstream left.

Those who do not learn from history often wind up repeating it. Groups of Marxist socialists are the memory of the working class. We must preserve the memory of these defeats so that we can analyse and learn from them. The class struggle has begun to revive. Our job is to be ready for the bigger upsurges that will come.

There is still tremendous strength in the labour movement. If we learn from the lessons of our defeats we can change the whole industrial and political situation, perhaps very quickly.

What do we need to do now?

1. Repair the ravages to shop floor organisation, only this time on a higher to win when we take action, not we get official backing.

Workers have got to keep fighting back and supporting others who fight back. The activists and the socialists in the trade union movement have got to find some way of working together and ending the divisions.

During the strike I went to a lot of dif. ferent meetings and saw that the divisions between socialists often mean that despite us having the same end aim action is less effective because of those obvious divisions. The Tory government is having its worst time since 1979 and now is the time for us to go on the offensive.

We have got to be pushing in our unions pushing our councillors and MPs to make sure that we get the Tories out and replace them with a Labour government that represents us and not one which does the Tories' job for them It doesn't look likely from the present leadership. Michael Meacher is a classic example of what's in store for us. I heard him at one of our conferences before the strike and what he and Labour weren't go. ing to do to protect the National Dock Labour Scheme was nobody's business.

What happened during the strike and what's happened after? The silence is deafening. There is no talk of re-instating the Dock Labour Scheme and ha's even talking of keeping many of the anti-union laws.

We want a Labour governmernt commit red to repealing all the anti-trade-union legislation.

Scan page 6

Laws against strikes and picketing in tain are now harsher than anywhere in Western Europe.

A report from the International Labour Office, a joint body of trade unions and governments, says that Britain's laws suppress what it considers to be minimum democratic rights for workers in eight different ways.

The Tories did not introduce these anti-union laws all at once, and they were very careful about it when they did introduce them.

The Industrial Relations Act in the early 'seventies provoked widespread opposition from trade unionists, building up to a big strike wave in July 1972 when five dockers were jailed. The strikes made the Act almost unworkable, and eventually the 1974 Labour Government repealed it.

The Tories were anxious not to create a similar situation this time round. And the almost complete inaction of the trade union leaders — especially the central TUC leadership - has helped them enormously.

There are four anti-union laws: the Employment Acts 1980, 1982 and 1988, and the 1984 Trade Union Act.

The 1980 and 1982 Acts made it possible for unions to be taken to court for a large number of reasons. Individual employers or individual scabs take the initiative to prosecute, so shifting the target for opposi tion away from the government itself.

Those two Acts made industrial action unlawful unless:

• It is between workers and their employer.

• It relates wholly or mainly to pay an conditions, dismissal, jobs, discipline, unir membership or a similar issue.

• It is to do with a dispute in the UK.

In other words, industrial action is unlawful if it is: • It is in support of other workers. • It is political; or • It is to do with a dispute outside the (e.g. solidarity with workers who are employed by the same multinational company, perhaps in South Africa).

Solidarity action is unlawful under almosı all circumstances. Picketing is severely restricted. A Code of Practice, not strictly part of the law but supposed to guide the courts, limits pickets to six.

The 1980 Act also severely restricted the closed shop. Closed shop agreements had to be approved by 85% majorities. Since most workplaces managed to win those 85% majorities, the 1988 Act has now made closed shops completely unworkable, by making it unlawful to enforce them.

The 1982 Act also banned 'union labour only' contracts, or industrial action in support of them.

The 1982 Act reversed British law since 1906 by making unions liable for damages. That means fines of up to £250,000 for big unions.

If those fines are not paid, all union funds can be seized ('sequestrated'").

At first, bosses were cautious about using these laws. Two climbdowns by trade union leaders after the Tories' second election victory in 1983 gave them the green light.

First, a High Court judge ruled that the action by the Post Office Engineering Union (now National Communications Union) against Mercury telephones was political (opposition to privatisation of telecommunications), and therefore problems, unlawful. The judge, it turned out, shares in Mercury. But the left-led executive called off the action.

Second, Eddie Shah won his battle to establish a non-union printshop in Warrington for his Stockport Messenger newspaper. The print union NGA organis ed mass pickets and called on the TUC fo support. The TUC abandoned the NGA, which lost a lot of money, at one point having all its assets seized. The NGA had to pay Shah €250,000 in damages.

The 1984-5 miners' strike also saw a lot of legal action. Although most of it was under laws much older than the Tories' re cent legislation, it proved to union leaders the dangers of 'unlawful action', and to th bosses the benefits of going to court.

In 1984, a new Act became law. The Trade Union Act 1984 made it illegal to strike without first holding a secret ballot of all the workers involved in the action and winning a majority. The wording in the ballot must require a 'yes' or 'no' answer, and must specifically ask if you are prepared to go on strike in breach of contract.

Another bit of the Trade Union Act 1984 failed. All unions had to hold ballots on the "political levy', which pays for trade union affiliations to the Labour Party and for unions' political campaigning. The Tories hoped to cripple both the unions and the Labour Party in one fell swoop. But it backfired.

Every ballot on an existing political fund was won, and a number of unions won ballots to set up new political funds.

The 1984 Act also required ballots for union executives.

The Employment Act 1988, as well as fectively outlawing the closed shop, also laid down that ballots for union executives must be by post. (Strike ballots can still be held at workplaces). The 1988 Act also made it unlawful for unions to expel or penalise strikebreakers, even if the strike is entirely lawful.

A big increase in the number of court cases (70 by August 1985) scared off trade union leaders. Unions gradually incorporated secret balloting into their constitutions. And in more and more disputes, the laws become an apparently insuperable obstacle. Big recent examples were the seafàrers' dispute with P&O and the dockery dispute over the Dock Labour Scheme.

But in many cases - like the postal strike, or the health service dispute - the Tories felt unable to use the laws.

Rank-and-file activists and some national officials were coming to look to unofficial action as a way around the law. This was the case in the recent London Underground strikes.

The inevitable next phase in the Tory anti-union legislation, therefore, is to hit at 'wildcat' strike organisers. The Green Paper recently published was expected also to outlaw certain strikes - in transport for example - but they have retreated on this. But it does propose to force unions to distance themselves completely from 'wildcat' action, and to give employers right to sack 'troublemakers' without redress.

The laws can and should be fought, although TUC timidity in the early '80s makes resistance harder now. The way to beat them is to build solidarity within and across the unions to campaign for the nex Labour government to scrap all the anti-union laws. political basis. The shop stewards' movement must be equipped with socialist perspectives and a programme for trade union democracy which also concerns itself with the broader labour movement.

Is it whistling in the dark to talk like this when the movement is only just beginning to pick itself up? Remember how the Minority Movement, the most effective, integrated, and comprehensive rank and file movement ever, started! It was launched amidst the collapse of militancy in the early '20s, and was effective thanks to a strong political backbone.

2. Continue the fight in the Labour Party. The Labour Party is still the political arm of the labour movement. There is no serious alternative to continuing this fight. Kinnock has control for now, but he has no answers.

3. The entire labour movement must be regenerated and renewed, and given the objective of taking power, in place of its old, merely reformist, objectives.

4. The struggles in the Labour Party and in the trade unions, the struggle of sections like blacks and women, must be linked together and integrated into a movement with a coherent strategy not only against the Tories but against capitalism itself.

One of the lessons of the miners' strike is the great need for a national network of rank and file militants, linking up across the unions and capable of delivering the solidarity denied by the union leaders. Right now, militants should work within the existing Broad Lefts, inadequate and bureaucratic though they are, but with the perspective of creating a genuine broad democratic rank and file movement on the model of the Minority Movement. The next step must be an attempt to link up the existing Broad Lefts.

6. We must organise and regroup the revolutionary socialists in the labour movement. This is the precondition for everything else.

'Build the revolutionary party' has become one of the most discredited of the sectarian catch-cries. Those who counterpose this slogan to the existing labour movement, and to the task of changing it, deserve to be discredited.

But still: the Labour Party is a 'broad church' , the trade unions are vast and politically heterogeneous organisations. The only agency that can overcome the fragmentation and political incoherence of the working class movement and the movements of the oppressed in an organisation of socialists with a clear-cut, comprehensive strategy.

Socialist Organiser has made some impact in the labour movement. If we had been better organised, we could have made a bigger impact. To prepare for a new upsurge of working-class struggle, we need to build and strengthen Socialist Organiser Subscribe!

To receive Socialist Organiser weekly, or to find out more abor us, write to SO, PO Box 823, London SE 15 4NA. Subscription rates: £l6 for one year, £8.50 for six months, £5 for three months.

Scan page 7

1954. September: Thousands of dockers in the Northern ports break away from the very right-wing and bureaucratic TGWU. 1955. May-June: Dockers strike for recognition of their breakaway union. 1956. January: Left-winger Frank Cousins becomes general secretary of the TGWU after the sudden death of the previous right-wing secretary.

Cousins' appointment is confirmed an election in May. 1958. May-June: Seven-week London busworkers' strike over pay. 1960. July: Productivity deal signed at Esso Oil Refinery at Fawley, near Southampton. These deals will become a very common bosses' stratagem in the late '60s, in their efforts to curb shop stewards' il. June: Court appoints rightwingers to take over electricians' union after previous Communist Par.

ty leadership is found guilty of ballot rigging.

July: Tory Government announces a 'pay pause', as part of its move towards 'economic planning', also represented by the setting-up of such joint government/business/union bodies as the National Economic Development Council.

All this does very little to stem growing shop-floor confidence and militancy. 1964. October: Labour government elected. 1965. Manufacturing employment in the UK reaches its highest-ever level and starts to decline.

Business, media and politicians (both Tory and right-wing Labou agitate about strikes and shop DX050597 economy.

In a less-noticed development, white-collar unions are beginning to affiliate to the TUC and organise industrial action.

February: Labour Government sets up the Donovan Commission to investigate trade unions, and the Prices and Incomes Board to control wages (and, supposedly, prices). bo. March: New general election. Labour wins increased majority.

May-July: Seafarers' strike. Labou prime minister Harold Wilson denounces it as being led by "a tightly'knit group of politically-motivated men"

July: Labour government tightens its wage controls with a six-month wage freeze. 67. Almost whole year: a building workers' strike at the giant Barbical site in London.

September-November: Unofficial dockers' strikes against the Devlin report, which aims to reform the Dock Labour Scheme.

November: Labour government devalues the pound. Harold Wilson makes his ill-fated claim that "the pound in your pocket has not been devalued"

Left-winger Hugh Scanlon elect president of the AEU. 1968. May: Near-revolutionary general strike in France.

June: Donovan Commission

reports. 1969. January: Labour Government announces plans for anti-union laws ('In Place of Strife'). June: TUC re jects these plans, and government withdraws them.

September: Jack Jones elected general secretary of the TGWU.

.are aok!

SINgy..IN encourages shop steward organisation in the union. Bosses and press become frantic about the presence of two left-wingers, Scanlon and Jones, at the head of Britain's biggest unions.

October: Yorkshire miners' strike (the first big miners' strike since 1926). 1970. June: Tory Government elected. December: power workers' work-torule causes power cuts but ends in defeat. 1971. January-March: Postal workers' which ends in heavy defeat.

February: 140,000 on TUC demonstration against Tories' proposed anti-union law (Industrial Relations Bill).

July: Workers at Upper Clyde Shipbuilders start 'work-in' against closure of the yard. Work-ins and sit-in strikes will become common in the '70s. 12. January-February: Miners' pay strike, ending in substantial victory. Flying pickets at coal depots and power stations.

July: Five dockers jailed under the Industrial Relations Act for picketing container depots. 250,000 workers strike in protest; TUC calls one-day general strike; government backs down and gets the dockers freed.

July-September: Building workers' pay strike, with flying pickets.

November: Tory Government, which has previously rejected wage controls on free-market principles, troduces them. Successive 'phases' wage control will continue throughout the rest of this ment's life. 13. February: Gas workers' pay strike.

March: 24 building workers arrested and charged for their activities on flying pickets during the 1972 strike. Two of them will eventually receive long jail sentences.

December: With an oil crisis and the miners applying an overtime ban, the Tory Government declares a three-day week for industry.

Scan page 8

1974. February-March: strike.

February: Labour Party announces "Social Contract' with trade unions, prepared in discussions over 1973, and forms minority government after general election. A big wave of pay strikes follows.

July: Industry minister Tony Benn offers government support to worker cooperatives at the Meriden motorcycle factory and the Scottish Daily News. Such worker cooperatives will become a popular answer to the threat of closures, but all the larger ones fail.

October: Labour wins absolute ma jority in a new general election. 15. July: Labour Government, with TUC agreement, imposes a £6 limit on wage rises. Jack Jones, the union leader who used to terrify the bosses, is the main architect of this formula. Strike rate drops sharply, and real wages will fall 10 per cent the next two years, but unemployment continues to rise (to one and half million by 1979). 16. January: Labour Government applies to IMF for a loan. Februar it announces a programme of cuts.

January: "Rescue plan' for Chrysler, involving the Labour Government's only 'planning agreement' , which turns out to much waste paper. 17. January: Bullock report on industrial democracy. Also waste paper.

March: Labour Government, having lost its majority, forms pact with Liberals. Meanwhile strike action against government's wage controls begins to revive.

Summer: Mass pickets battle with police at Grunwicks in North London, where mainly Asian women workers are striking for union recognition. Solidarity action by post workers is ruled illegal by courts. Grunwick workers are eventually defeated.

September: Ex-leftist WORKERS' stalim s LIBERTY heirs face the workors renter Maron Thomss. an seshytem versus Stellalam in • The road to ocal Democracy pots Theschence problems, defies his union's mandate to cast AEU vote for wage controls at the TUC.

November-January 1978:

Firefighters strike. Troops used scabs. 18. February: Michael Edwardes, new boss of the nationalised British Leyland car firm, announces a pian including 12,500 job cuts. Littie union resistance. Over the next few years Edwardes will decimate Jobs, conditions, and union agreements in BL.

May: Right wing takes control of the AEU, with Terry Duffy elected to succeed Hugh Scanlon. Scanlon goes to the House of Lords.

September/October: TUC and Labour Party conferences oppose ther wage controls. Ford workers strike for, and win, pay increases above the government limits. A 'winter of discontent' follows, wit strikes by lorry drivers, ambulance workers, water workers, dustmen, and other public service workers.

November: Times locks out its workers and suspends publication several months in an unsuccessful tempt to break the unions. 19. 'Winter of discontent' continues. Trade union membership reaches its highest-ever level.

May: Tories win general election. Rapid decline in unofficial strikes and in battles against closures and job cuts. 10. January-April: Steelworkers' strike over pay. Under very right-wing leadership, it ends with only marginal gains, and is quickly followed by huge job cuts in the steel industry.

Industry is slumping, as the Tories apply rigid monetarist policies, and unemployment rises rapidly, to over three million by early 1982.

May: TUC day of action against the Tories. Quite successful, but the TUC soon decides against any repeats.

August: The Tories' first anti-union law (James Prior's EmployIn this issue: Stalin's Theirs face sho workers: The road to Tiananmen Square • Wang Fan-hsi: Trotskyism versus Stalinism in the Chinese Revolution • The nature •f the Eastern Bloc: a sympesium with Robert brenner.

Martin Thomas, an Iranian socialist, Oliver Macdonald and Frank Fured! • Art and the Russian Revolution • NOW times and elass struggle: a with Marxism Today • Clare Short on Ireland • Soctal Democracy goos Thatcherite Workors' Liberty is •vallobte prom PO BOX 823, London SEIS 4HA for Elecu plus 320 p&p ment Act 1980) comes into force. 1981. February: Unofficial miners' strike forces Tories to back down plans for pit closures.

December: Arthur Scargill elected president of the NUM. 1982. April-December: campaign of industrial action by National Health Service unions, with well-supported TUC day of action in solidarity in September. 1983. January: Water workers' strike. February/March: Unsuccessful attempt by South Wales miners to get national miners' strike against closure of Lewis Merthyr colliery.

December: TUC abandons the print union NGA, facing seizure of its funds because of its picketing of Eddie Shah's non-union printworkers in Warrington, and NGA has to concede defeat. This is a turning point for the Tories' anti-union laws; previously cautious employers start using them more and more. 14. January: Tories ban unions at GCHQ in Cheltenham.

March: Miners start national strikr against pit closures, which will continue until March 1985. Most unions promise solidarity to the miners, but fail to deliver.

July and August: National docks strikes against threats to the Dock Labour Scheme. 35. March: Miners' strike ends in defeat.

March/April: Most of the left-wing Labour councils which have said they will fight rate-capping collapse and capitulate.

September to February 1986: Liverpool, the last Labour council standing out against the government, collapses after its leadership (influenced by Militant) sends out redundancy notices to the entire workforce.

October: Breakaway miners' union UDM, formed, based on the miners who had scabbed on the 1984-5 strike. 16. January: Rupert Murdoch provokes a strike, sacks all his printworkers, and moves his newspapers to a new site at Wapping, where they are produced by a scab workforce recruited through the EETPU. February: Courts seizes assets of the print union SOGAT because of its ac tion against Murdoch. 1987. February: Print unions' campaign against Murdoch defeat. 1988. January-February: First signs of recovery. Ford pay strike. Ends in victory. Two-year deal mean at least 7% in second year. This fuel a wave of pay action. Nurses strike i defence of NHS.

July: TUC suspends EETPU for signing single-union deals to the disadvantage of other unions.

September: Postal workers' strike. sab Ation of the Dock abounces Scheme.

July: Dockers' strike, demanding employers negotiate conditions equivalent to the Dock Labour Scheme, ends in defeat. Docks workforce and union organisation decimated.

Successful pay strikes, however, Town Hall workers, rail workers,

Scan page 9

Paul Whetton (Manton NUM) draws some lessons Ween was or he red and one hat are the lessons of the ism was on a high and we kicked the Tories and their Industrial Relations Act into touch, and the miners won two great (1972 and 1974) strikes.

Everybody remembers '72 and "74, but nobody remembers '73. That was the year that we accepted the Coal Board's offer "in the national interest". That led to '74.

And when in 1972 the police had to pack up and march away from Saltley Gate they learned their lesson, and they went away and did their homework, and they vowed and declared that that would never happen again. Nevertheless we won again in 1974. But they continued their preparations so that one day they would repay the miners, and repay trade unionism in general. Because — and the cops knew it well - Saltley Gate was as much a victory for the engineers as it was victory for the miners.

So they plotted and learned their lessons, and they built up their forces and rehearsed them. And in 1981 they went for the South Wales miners, and when the South Wales miners reacted the Tories backed off. They still didn't feel ready for a showdown. But they continued to get ready.

Then came Warrington, where police thuggery won a victory over the printers for Eddie Shah and the union busters. They had flexed their muscles, and now they felt they were ready for the mineworkers.

And so they deliberately provoked a strike. We could have walked away from that strike. We could have refused to be drawn into it. But then they would have gone ahead and shut down the pits anyway. We had to fight.

And we fought as many others have had to fight — in isolation. Although we got magnificient support in finance and food, that was not enough. It is not enough to give sympathetic solidarity. It needs to be the kind of solidarity that means coming out on strike and standing alongside other workers in struggle. That's the only solidarity that will beat the Tories.

The miners were allowed to go under. We warned other workers: "if the miners , and each battle has once again been fought in isolation.

We look at Silentnight. We look at the seafarers. We look at the Fleet Street printers, we look at the dockers and we see each one in its turn fighting in some instances a magnificent battle, but still going down to defeat.

The message that has got to be built on is this: the rank and file must organise and unite across industry, linking miners and hospital workers and teachers and engineers, linking the whole of the organised working class and in every strike action be prepared to go out and demand class solidarity for workers in struggle - for all workers in struggle.

A rank and file movement which says "to hell with the Tory anti-union laws!" An unofficial movement which can say that without immediately falling victim to the union-busting fines which Mrs Thatcher's skinhead judges itch to inflict.

Out and out solidarity - that's got to be the message. The trade union rank and file must organise for it. The rank and file must be prepared to both demand it and give it. That is the only think that is going to beat the Tories and beat employers who use Tory legislation in order to defeat the organised working class.

I think the main reason for the lack of effective solidarity in the struggles I've listed was fear.

First of all the fear of the dole queue. And every worker has been living in an atmosphere of fear that if they stick their head up above the parapet they will get it shot off.

Of course, it was magnificent what the rallway workers did during the miners' strike. And many of them have paid the penalty, or are still paying the penalty.

I know that if enough workers had really come together and shown adequate solidarity that in itself would have been a defence against any workers getting picked off as some workers were picked off when they did risk it.

If there had been an overall response from all the trade unions in the struggles I listed above, then the Tories and the bosses couldn't have done it. They can't imprison 11 million workers! It is when only a few brave souls are prepared to stand up that they can make an example of them, to put the fear of god into others.

When we all come together and we all rise at the same time, then we are unstoppable, and untoucheable.

A central lesson, the lesson of lessons, if you like, is this: the rank and file must never trust the trade union leaders, or the leaders of the Labour Party.

We have to use them but then especially we must keep a watchful suspicious eye on them. We miners were in an unusual position — we had a leadership we could trust. But such leaderships are very, very few and far between, and that is why so much depends on the rank and file being organised and ready. Then if it looks like being a sell-out, the rank and file itself can carry on the fight without the leadership and aginst them where necessary.

Remember that the leadership nothing without the rank and file. Many of them have climbed the ladder of success and pulled the ladder up behind them. We have seen many excellent leftwing rank and filers go up that ladder and then they change, as if they have climbed into a different world. The truth is that it is a different world, the world of the trade union leaders, with their managementlevel salaries, expensive union cars, lots of perks, and so on and so on.

If the rank and file itself is prepared to organise and carry on the battle then the official leaderships can be pushed into some useful actions and, at the same time, the rank and file is organised and prepared, armed with their eternal vigilence which is the prize of a health labour movement, to carry the battle forward - with or without the leadership.

New puttams, Mom si Aft= Rago

Scan page 10

By Mick O'Sullivan, Haringey UCATT and former Chair of London Bridge stewards' committee For most of the post-war period Foral backwater in she trade of a 'backwater' in the trade union movement.

Yet the workforce rose from 1,422,000 in 1950 to 2,993,000 in 1975 and NALGO membership increased from 247,000 in 1960 to 625,000 in 1975.

Militancy emerged in the late '60s and early '70s. A strike by London dustmen started in one borough, rapidly spread to other London boroughs through the use of flying pickets, and was soon made official. London. teachers and-NALGO members struck over London weighting. Previously quiet sections of the working class were following the example of manufacturing industry.

In 1970 NUPE officially recognised shop stewards. The other manual unions followed and from the mid-1970s the major white collar union, NALGO, also tentatively supported stewards. Sectional and localised strikes became more common.

The government was attempting to change working methods - to make workers work harder. But workers were able to turn local negotiations around such issues as productivity to their own advantage. It was estimated in 1979 that 90% of productivity deals had had the main effect of increasing the earnings of low paid workers.

Major cuts in council expenditure began in 1975. But at this stage their direct effect on workers was minimal. Union branches worked out policies to counter them, for example no cover for vacant posts.

Many of the militants engaged in building branches and stewards' committees looked to manufacturing industry as a guide for creating independent trade unionism. However, it soon became apparent that the tasks facing them were very different. For example a manual workers' branch in education would organise four of five different groups of workers. The full-time male caretakers would be a small minority alongside the majority of part-time women workers, cleaners, dinner ladies, etc. It was difficult to see how the part-time cleaners, for example, could develop economic leverage at the workplace. Trade unionism in local government would have to link the workplace to the local branch or stewards' committee and take up issues such as child care and full-time rights for part-time workers.

The 'dirty jobs strike' in 1979 was part of a wider wages explosion against the Callaghan government's pay restraints. The advances made in organisation by Page 8 New problems, New struggles local government workers were shown by their ability to sustain a strike for six weeks, not only by the most organised group, the dustmen, but also by many other sections.

Such national action by manual workers split into many different occupations and boroughs demanded either an extremely powerful rank and file body -which did not exist - or a committed national leadership. At the time the NUPE leaders were on the extreme left wing of the trade union bureaucracy. They had led the fight against the Labour government cuts, and they actively argued for the strike, giving a clear and unequivocal lead and drawing in behind them the other unions, the G&M and T&G. By then shop stewards had become almost universal. The most militant organisation was generally in the urban areas which had a tradition of industrial employment and were more than likely to have a Labour council. Yet amongst manual workers there was very little evidence of rank and file groupings which attempted to exercise control over the leadership. In branch-building and •There are two key are two lessons. fight to democratise and trol of the trade structure...confr sectional strikes the national union bureaucracies were not an obstacle: indeed NUPE in particular was actively encourging shop floor and workplace organisation. So the union machinery was left in the hands of the trade union bureaucracy, albeit at the time a left-wing bureaucracy.

In NALGO there was 'NALGO Action', a group including members of the SWP (then called IS) and, for a time, of the CP. It made propaganda for socialist ideas and provided a forum for the radicals in the professional services such as social workers. The CP left it once they had a foothold in the bureaucracy, and then in the late '70s the SWP abandoned rank and file organisation in favour of 'building the party'. The activists turned to building in their individual branches.

The election of Thatcher in 1979 reopened the issues of trade unionism and politics in local government with a vengeance.

The lack of any rank and file grouping in the unions that could even begin to assert control over the leadership was cruelly felt. The NUPE leaders moved sharply to the right, and there was no force to stop them.

Within two months of Thatcher's election victory, the leading left-wing Labour takı unt council of the day — Ted Knight's of the dav — Ted Knio Lambeth — was proposing cuts. Strong pressure trom Labour Party activists and trade unionists forced Knight to climb down and begin a vigorous campaign against the government. But at budget time in Spring 1980 that campaign faded away. The council 'bought time' with a 49 per cent rate rise.

The policy of rate rises to 'buy time' and avoid cuts became the orthodoxy of the Labour local government left. By allying with the rate-raisers, local government trade unionists effectively ceded the task of protecting jobs to the councils. Individuals or small groups in the union branches supported the 'three nos' - no rate rises, no rent increases, no cuts — but an alliance with the council leaders against ratepayers and tenants, through rate rises to protect jobs, made sense in narrow trade union terms.

Most of the forces of the left were grievously split. Labour Briefing, then an influential force through its links with Ken Livingstone and the London Labour left, called for a fight but failed to organise it, acting instead as ideological rationalisers for the rate-raising councillors. The SWP, by standing outside the Labour Party, effectively abstained from this political struggle. Militant, though inside the Labour Party, also largely abstained at this crucial stage. The only organised force arguing for a fighting strategy was the relatively small group round Socialist Organiser.

Any, study of the turmoil in the boroughs over the rates issue will show that it was far from a foregone conclusion what policy the Labour Parties would take over the cuts. Many of the activists and trade unionists were undecided. But the left was unable to create a political climate in which workers and trade unionists could see that 'these people meant business' An inkling of what might have been possible was shown in Liverpool during 1984, when the Militant-influenced Labour council had a mass mobilisation of workers in support of its policy of no cuts and rate rises only in line with inflation. Once the local elections of May 1984 were over Militant changed tack, demobilising the workers, fixing a compromise deal with the government, and then stumbling into a fiasco in 1985. But the positive work they did in early 1984 showed the power of a united trade union and Labour left. Similar things could have been done elsewhere, but they weren't.

Mostly the local government unions collapsed into piecemeal branch activity. The period had many similarities to the attempts to 'institutionalise' the shop floor movement in industry, but there was one major difference. In industry the development went hand in hand with attacks on the shop floor to get the unions to police and regulate the members. In local government the councils, because they were able to bankroll their policy through

----- pull-quotes -----

steward power wrecking Britain's IIS GOCOEAL FEX V2 T00

MAKE WE EARNED FORD PAY NEWANT 11 U81 C MOMUM !

go under, then you're next". And lo and next, many trade unions have been

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →