Stick it out for 35 hours!
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Rank and file control an the Confed leadership be trusted to hold out for the 35-hour week with no strings?
Recent history suggests that rank and file engineers should not trust them. Twice in the last three years the Confed leadership have been prepared to put forward proposals that combine a cut in basic hours with concessions to the "It's important have a national Confed stewards conference to discuss any possible settlement. It's the lay members who have put the money in, they should have a say what happens"
Darren Keown employers over "flexibility".
As the Sheffield Engineering Gazette Group pointed out early on in the campaign:| *By October 1986, after a series of meetings between the CSEU and the EEF, agreement was almost reached for a shorter working week for engineering workers. Those proposals were dropped by the CSEU as a result of effective lobbying by the rank and file.
"In the current round of negotiations, those unacceptable proposals proposals under pressure but it is hardly fantastic to believe that he may try and reintroduce major concessions in a new form in negotiations this week.
The EEF this weekend implied that they are prepared to accept a 37-hour week in return for the Confed giving way on accepting most of their "flexibility' proposals. So Jordan must be tempted. He has already suggested a 37 hour week could be a 'stepping stone' to the 35 hour week.
Jordan's willingness to talk down the union's claim to 37 hours undoubtedly helped lose the vote amongst white collar workers who already have a 37 or 37½ hour week in many cases. This was compounded by the inactivity of many local white collar union officials.!
As Alan Marshall, MSF rep at GPT Beeston, pointed out: "The strings that GPT are after reflect the Engineering Employers' Federation's talk about introducing a shorter working week with the strings - stopping breaks, flexibility and payment appraisal. It's a fraud for them to say they're giving us something - they're not giving us anything, they're taking it away.
"Our plant is one of the largest federated firms in the East Midlands. If the workforce here capitulates because they don't get supported by the Confed strategy, it's feasible that other firms in the East Midlands will follow suit.
*The Confed have been told they can ill afford to have an agreement forced on their members here, because it will have an obvious effect on the complete national strategy."
So separating the dispute at GPT Beeston from the national 35-hour week campaign sends all the wrong signals to the employers, especially after GPT was on the original 'hit list'.
Finally, there is the question of local deals. The bosses' paper, the Financial Times, pointed to some of the dangers. 'The irony is that the unions' subsequent strategy of targetting specific companies for industrial action among the EEF's 5,000 affiliated employers may lead to the conclusion of local deals.
"Last week, shop stewards at the Cheltenham site of Smiths Industries, one of the plants being balloted, were initially tempted to enter talks with management on the company's offer of a self-financing 37½ hour week for manual workers. They decided not to do so, after advice from the CSEU national co-ordinating committee, partly because it offered no hours reduction for white collar workers.
*The EEF says that it has no objections to deals of the type proposed by Smiths; but that even if a deal was concluded by the company there is no reason why other employers should follow suit.l *Union leaders counter that the realiBy an AEU steward According to a spokesperson A for the Conted strategy committee no money whatsoever from the levy will go to workers laid off as a result of the dispute.
"In any industrial action there are casualties, " he said. "It shouldn't be beyond the imagination of local trade unionists to make arrangements," he added, underlining that there will be no money from the national fund.
But if laid off workers are not subsidised from the strike fund how will potential divisions be avoided?
In the IG Metall dispute, which the Confed leaders hold up as a model, within two weeks there were 10 workers laid off for every striker. It's not ty is that the EEF would be forced back to national talks if it saw a danger of its members being picked off one by one through the threat of selective strikes."
At present no local deal on hours or pay can be signed without being approved by the Confed national committee. With the dispute now entering a new, critical stage that power should pass to a national Confed stewards conference.
At a time when the EEF is discussing its own abolition and clearly wants to see the end of the national agreement, local deals on hours at the three striking plants could lead to the breakdown of the national agreement and open up huge differences between different engineering workers on basic hours, one of the few remaining unifying factors.
Clearly such a result would be disastrous: for that reason rank and file ratification of any local deals is vital.
enough to rely on improvisation.
The only way to overcome these problems is to put the dispute under rank and file control so the lay members themselves can determine what benefits to pay out. Local Confed stewards strategy committees should be set up to do this.
The Confed leadership's policy of keeping their strategy secret makes sense in relation to the employers who could, for instance, provoke lay-offs if they thought it would quickly drain the strike fund. But the policy of secrecy pursued by the leadership is preventing information getting through to the rank and file. We might not want the whole world to know, but it would be a help if engineering stewards knew what the hell is going on and what's going to happen next. At the moment we don't.
----- pull-quotes -----
Convenor, Rolls Royce Hillington