Life, words and revolution
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
reviews 'Old Gringo' Id Gringo' isn't very Oop you enjoying lean it stop you enjoying it.
Marred as it is by racial stereotyping, pretentious, deafening music, and rather lame, portentous dialogue which tells us things we've already worked out ourselves, it still communicates on an emotional level.
Political it's not. Even Jane Fonda, who produced it and played one of the main characters, admits that. Don't go expecting to learn anything about the 1 Mexican Revolution circa 1913. It's basically an intimate story about the coming together of three very different people, padded out and almost overwhelmed by the few gory shoot-emup bits that seem to belong to another kind of picture entirely.
Spinster governess Harriet Winslow (Fonda), American writer Bitter and Mexican revolutionary general Tomas Arroyo meet up in Chihuahua when Harriet is trying to get to the hacienda of the wealthy Miranda family, who have hired her as governess. Bitter is based on the real life writer Ambrose Bierce who disappeared in Mexico some time during the revolution, and played with wit and grace by Gregory Peck in what may be his last screen performance.
Arroyo and some of his men offer to escort Harriet as a means of penetrating the securely defended hacienda and seizing it for the revolution. Bitter, the 'old gringo' of the title, meets up with them again there, and the story begins.
The three characters are all caught between two worlds. Bitter, in his seventies, looks back on a full, rich life and savours to the full Fastits which, with Death at his Lows he may never have who came to Mexico to seek truth, discovers appetites she never knew she had, and begins to change and blossom.
Arroyo, who falls under the spell of the world he came to destroy, is the most tragic of the three. Unable to escape the thrall of the hacienda, he refuses to move his army out to their rendezvous with the main revolutionary forces led by Pancho Villa. He roams the hacienda restlessly and dances with Fonda in a hall of mirrors, where he admires the picture of himself with middle-class woman in his arms.
When Arroyo finds historic Spanish deeds ceding ownership of the Miranda lands to the Mexican peasants, he sees the revolutionary battle as won. His followers, illiterate like him, are at first overjoyed, and it is left to Bitter to try to bring them to their senses. The papers mean nothing, he says. The Mirandas, and others like them, will always have other papers.
Later, when Arroyo still refuses to act, Bitter condemns him for giving up the fight for the sake of words on paper. It isn't papers that will give the peasants the land; only by fighting for it will they be able to wrest it from the landowners.
That's not a bad message for any film to have, but that's not all. There are two images from the film that stay in the mind.
In one early scene, Fonda is escorted to her room by maidservants and some of the state's armed guards. The maids, alerted to the revolutionaries' presence within the hacienda's walls, slit the throats of the guards and strap on guns and ammunition over their demure servant garb. It's a startling and exciting transformation./ Much later, the revolutionaries camped in the grounds enter the hacienda's stately rooms and catch sight of themselves in the mirrored hallway. They point and laugh and strike poses as they recognise themselves. It's not a well written scene, yet it lingers in the mind, recognising themselves as inpeople waging a struggle, the recognition that together they form a group, united in purpose, with demands that cry out to be met. In the hall of mirrors, those peasants came face to face not just with their own faces, but with their own overwhelming numbers, with their strength and their determination.
These are the high notes. The weak points are the script, the stereotyping of Mexicans as hard drinking, hard fighting, whoring Small Mary places papers all along the kitchen, On table, dresser and chairs: these are children; Herself a nun, alone with the children in her den. Mary is playing school, Convent school, Where little girls are shaped for life, and cut By saintly women married live to God's strict rule. Now she begins to teach: she stiffens and starts to: Before the desks, facing her kids like Nemesis, A long thin stick in hand. Slowly, she starts to "Tu To "Tút Tut-Tut". Soon anger sparks to rage, Deep-rooted rage: a wounded eyeless Id Seethes with stifled poisoned life, within a cage. Now she begins to shout: she scolds her paper kids, Upbraiding them as little fools and dunces, Ne'er-do-well thick little stupid Patsies and Brids. From shouting now to action: she starts to hit The table, the dresser, the unfeeling chairs With the long stick, her face twisted as in a fit. She "slaps" the table, the dresser and every chair Wood rings on nerveless wood with rapid blows, In frenzied mimic violence. - And now with tear Mary slaps on, her eyes so hot they glow, Lost in that wounded reenactment there At home, in De Valera's Ireland long ago, Small Mary slaps on, her eyes so hot they gli Lost in that wounded reenactment there At home, in De Valera's Ireland long ago. dimwits and the casting of Jimmy Smits as Arroyo, Smits simply cannot match up to the heavyweight screen presences of Peck and Fonda even though her performance is poor, relying too heavily on an irritatingly innocent wide-eyed stare), and Smits' weakness throws the triangle out of kilter.
Peck is the stand out. He's wonderful to watch and to listen to, and he has the best lines. When he talks to Fonda of his life, wooing her with the poetry and feeling of his words, it's the only time her wide-eyed sense of wonder seems to fit.
----- pull-quotes -----
dividuals, but as an army. That "recognition' is essential for