Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[first-past-the-post system: the Greens would undoubtedly get more…]

Socialist Organiser no. 420, 26 October 1989 · scan p. 7 · about 544 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

first-past-the-post system: the Greens would undoubtedly get more votes in a PR system, but Labour would still be the only alternative to the Tories. (In practice, although it might be blamed on the electoral system rather than the Greens, a Green vote at the next election will often help keep the Tories in office).

Even if the Greens were an explicitly working-class, socialist party, they would have to address this problem: because Labour is the actually existing working-class party, a strategy that does not take ac count of it is, in fact, a strategy to abandon the working class.

That is what the desire to leave the Labour Party and join the Greens represents. It means giving up trying to change the workers movement, in the hope that this new movement will be more suc cessful. But that hope will prove vain. If thoroughgoing Green politics have to be socialist, they have to win the working class: if we fail to do that, we will never get socialism, and never be able to "guarantee the Earth"

The battle to win the labour movement to genuine socialist politics is, of course, very difficult. Perhaps in the short term it might be easier to do battle with non-socialist Greens for the soul of the Green Party, which is new, and has no consolidated bureaucracy.

But several factors tell against this perspective. Paradoxically, the move out of the Labour Party into a more radical competitor can signal a move, in the long run, to the right. Because there is such a strong element of "giving up" many of those who leave the Labour Party now will be unreliable allies for socialists in the Greens in the future. Many of those on the right of the German Greens were ultra-left Maoists a decade or SO ago: for them, too, the underlying impulse was demoralisation and disillusionment with the working class and the prospects for socialism. Green politics were a substitute for redressing their own earlier failures.

Moreover, the current depressed state of the Labour Left is unlikely to last. Possibly before, and almost certainly soon after the next election, especially if Labour wins but fails to live up to expectations (as it will), there will be renewed opposition to Kinnock and co. Nothing could be worse than for that new opposition to be without the experience of socialists active in the Labour Party now. In the late sixties, hen the Left socialists left began to revive in the late seventies and early eighties, many socialists continued to stand outside. The result was to weaken the Left, and therefore aid the rise of Kinnock.

We cannot allow that pattern to be repeated in the 1990s. If we do. we are writing off all prospect of building a serious working class socialist movement Lin Britain. Those of us who have learned the lessons of the 1980s and understood what Kinnockism represents, need to be there to help ensure that next time there is a struggle against the right, it is successful. Next time the Left needs to be more prepared have more roots in the unions, and above all, be stronger politically have coherent, socialist answers Abandoning Labour for the Greens will only make our tasks harder in future.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 420

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →