Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Don't leave La for the Greens!

Socialist Organiser no. 420, 26 October 1989 · scan pp. 7–8 · Clive Bradley · about 2,282 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

FOR THEI Contac ford Tech Su 061-736-2636 TION LIGHT Paul Herrmann (Profile)

Clive Bradley argues that people leaving Labour in disgust are misguided f you were to switch off the TV after the Labour Party conference and pick up the Green Party's manifesto, the contrast would be pretty dramatic.

Not only are the more obvious radical commitments that Labour has now expunged to be found among the Green Party's policies, like unilateral nuclear disarmament, so too are plenty of other policies that have always been too radical for Labour.

Green politics are indeed radical politics. The Greens propose a wide range of measures, from a decent health service to the repeal of the Public Order Act, from racial equality to policies to help the Third World, which would warm the heart of any socialist who has just endured the Labour Party Policy Moreover, the economic policy of the Greens is not as far fetched as it is often made to seem: we "are not anti-technology", they say: *We favour appropriate technology: technology that is good and satisfying to work with, produces useful end results and is kind to the environment. Many such. technologies will be 'high-tech'."

And they propose reforming the tax system to make it equitable, introducing a 'basic income scheme' to guarantee a decent standard of living, and various other sensible measures. Unlike Labour, they also favour an uninhibited right to strike.

Even the language of the Greens is familiar to socialists: a Green economy "satisfies the full range of people's needs, not just their financial needs", "measures itself using meaningful' indicators like health, low crime rates, human fulfilment and ecological diversity" "supports socially-useful products, not *works to redress inequalities commercially viable ones" "secures greater democratic control over economic decision making" and so on.

For many Labour Party activists depressed after Labour's remodelling by Neil Kinnock, the temptation to abandon Labour and Join the Greens must be enormous. Yet such a move would be a mistake. For all its ills, the Labour Party is still the place for socialists to be.

The Greens may be, in a way, «'unconscious socialists", and some of them of course are quite consciously socialist; but the resistance of many delegates at the Green Party conference to any such labelling is not incidental. For sure, any concerted attempt to convert the Green Party as a party into an avowedly socialist one would meet much resistance, and certainly it would result in splits.

It is hard to believe that the hostility ot many Greens to the word "socialist" is simply the negative effects of Stalinism on the one hand and Labourite "statesocialist' failure on the other. There is no denying that these two factors have done an immense amount to discredit socialism, but the existence of socialists who are opposed both to the Russian system and to old-fashioned Labourism is not SO little known that mainstream Greens can be unaware of it. Such people exist within the Green Party itself.

The resistance of Greens to any socialist attachment represents a much deeper problem: it is a middle-class movement. This is meant not merely abusively. As a movement, the Greens have no link with the working class, and as a movement can see no need for one. Individuals are active in trade unions, poll tax campaigns, etc. But the Green Party neither sees itself as a working-class movement now, nor is it ever likely to.

What many Greens oppose in socialism is not only state control, centralisation, and so on. It is the project of the self-liberation of the working class. They oppose politics that are explicitly working class politics.

For the Greens, the working class is only one section of the population that needs to be convinced, "In the late sixties, socialists left the Labour Party. When the left began to revive in the late seventies and early eighties, many socialists continued to stand outside. The result was to weaken the left, and therefore aid the rise of Kinnock. We cannot allow that pattern to be repeated in the 1990s."

along with others. The others can include — and, logically, do include for example, multinational capital, which the Greens hope one day to persuade to behave in a more environmentally friendly way.

Green politics identify what's wrong with society globally - inequality, the squandering of the world's resources - and some of the causes - the profit motive but draw back from putting a name to these phenomena: capitalism. To achieve the end of changing the world, they propose nothing more radical than eventually forming a parliamentary majority, backed up by some non-violent direct action - as if, faced with the challenge to its power that would be required if things were really going to change, multinational capital would just roll over and play dead.

The Greens can only identify the problem, or aspects of the problem. By their nature they cannot be the vehicle for solving it.

The Labour Party, despite everything, remains the party of the trade unions, and therefore, for the moment, the party of the working class, or at least the nearest thing there is to one in Britain. This is true not only organisationally, but politically. For most working class people who want to get rid of the Tories, Labour will be the only practical choice at the next election. And this is not only because of the

Scan page 8

Last week Philip Vine looked at the history of trade unionism in El Salvador. In part 2, he looks at economic and social conditions in the country The economic package which Cristiani has implemented in his first hundred days is one of liberalisation, trying to hold down wages while prices of basic commodities continue to spiral upwards. Life for the lower paid and unemployed is becoming increas ingly harder while the oligarchy and the noveau-riche, including the generals and the colonels who've lined their pockets from the war, strengthen their grip on their wealth.

Rojas considers this a completly regressive outlook and is a formula for continuing insurgency from the workers who are suffering.

*Cristiani is projecting a better economy in a year and a half. He says people will have to make sacrifices for the short run.

But the sacrifice is not being borne equally. It is the burden of the ordinary people and they won't stand for anymore of this."

The emphasis of this 18 month package is on increasing the export of traditional products like coffee, sugar, cotton and bananas. But this means that the prices of domestic necessities are inflating because of short supply, as more land is utilised for agro-export industries.

Eggs have risen in price by 60 per cent since the start of the year; the staples, beans and maize, by 100 per cent in some parts of the country.

Adding to this cost push inflation is the taxes Cristiani has imposed on electricity, water and other amenities. In the capital the changing of the pricing structure has led to people burning buses in the streets.

The plan also includes the privatisation of the banks and the lifting of the trade barriers to allow for tree trade, which is going to have detremental effects on employment. Cristiani has also laid off masses of public employees in the name of efficiency.

The liberalisation theory allows for a freeing up of the labour market which goes hand in hand with the oligarchy's attempts to repress the unions as a forum of political expression.

The government called a conference with the UNTS in midSeptember to try and brow-beat unionists into accepting a wage squeeze until the economy has had a chance to recover'.

*Wages have been effectively frozen since May and they wanted to implant the idea that we shouldn't demand any increases for the sake of the economy, but people are starving. The workers won't take this"

The unions calculate that the basic wage under present prices to support a family is 2,150 colones (US $430) a month. At present the average salary in factories shops is 155 colones (US $30) a month. Campesinos (peasant farmers) get about 10 colones a day but only work for six months of the year, which gives them even less than urban workers.

*The government has called us reactionary to the new economic climate, but it is the package itself which is backwards thinking.

They want to impose an economic model which is historically ineffectual. The government wants to return to 1979, to recreate the structure which helped trigger off the civil war.

The crisis here is structural, the country is run by the rich families and the army. Any real change is impossible without first changing the structure. Cristiani is not interested in changing the structure, so the economic plan will achieve little for the benefit of the people"

Cristiani on his own may have made some concessions, but he doesn't hold the power at ARENA, it lies in the hands of people like Robert D'Aubuisson, assassin of Archbishop Romero (killed in 1980 by a right wing death squad).

ARENA pays lip service to improving the welfare of the Salvadoreans by way of a social plan included in the 18 month economic package. It proposes to spend 945,000 colones over a year and a half on a programme of encouraging healthy living, preventative medicine and advice on cor rect diet. A sick joke!

The government line is that social welfare will be lifted in the long run by the improved economy. But the trickle-down ettect has little benetit in a drought.

Rojas also believes the ARENA government is trying to subtly derail the agrarian land reform. Although Christiani makes a big publicity exercise out of handing out public land titles personally to campesinos, Rojas says this is a farce.

"What D'Aubuisson is trying to do is to divide up the land into very small plots and break up the cooperatives. The army is terrorising the co-operatives with bombings and disappearing campesinos to try and regain control of their land"

He says the tactic is to fragment the land so that individually campesionos will have little political and economic clout. With the incentives for export crops which need to be grown on a large scale, the small plots will be sold back to large landowners.

*The government knows tradifional export crops like coffee are best grown on farms of 100 to 500 hectares. It also has plans to rent out public land to campasinos and tell them what to grow. To grow for the interests of ARENA. In these ways it is trying to destroy agrarian reform.

It is a basic problem of dependence. As individual peasants they can't act politically. It is a reversion to the feudal system"

The election of the ARENA party has institutionalised the connection between the oligarchy and the ultra-right death squads within the military.

When Duarte took power in 1984 and was under pressure from the United States to try and control the death squads, there was at least some effective political oppostion to the ultra-right.

Now that the ARENA party is in power again the connection has been institutionalised. Cristiani's so-called civilian government comprises, alongside the technocrats, army officers feared and reknowned for their human rights abuses under Duarte.

D'Aubuisson The Vice Minister of Defence and cabinet minister, Col Juan Zepuda was promoted from command of the First Infantry Brigade and Vice Minister for Public Security, Inocente Orlande came from the head of the Sixth Brigade. Both brigades have histories of civilian massacres, torture and assasinations behind them.

There is much talk of a power struggle within ARENA between the hard-line military and the civilians. But the partnership between the oligarchy and the army has ruled El Salvador for at least fifty years and there are no signs that Cristiani is trying to purge the extreme right.

Observers say the absence of any high ranking military in the commission for dialogue with the FMLN is an indication of a split. Cristiani says the first meeting with the guerillas held on September 12-14 in Mexico was merely to establish guidelines. At the investiture of the commission he gave them the 'complete power' to speak for the government of El Salvador.

The dialogue did not seem to cover any ground which had not been trodden in the past. After the meetings the FMLN commanders told the Washington Post they Wednesday 25 October Forum on Ireland with Patrick Mur phy (SO), Redmond O'Neill (LCI) a a speaker from the CPGB. 7pm Merseyside TU Resources Centre, Hardman St, Liverpool.

Saturday 28 October Birmingham Trades Council demonstration against the poll tax. 12 am assemble Chamberlin Square. Friday 3 November History Workshop Conference 1989. Salford University. Contact Helen Bowyer, 51 Crescent, Salford M5 4UX (061-736 3601) Saturday 4 November *Fight for the Right to Study! Defend NUS!' Conference organised by Kent Area NUS. PCL, Marylebone Rd, London W1, 11.30. Details: Mark Sandell, Kent Area NUS, 0227 766725 Monday 6 November SO/Socialist Outlook debate: 'The nature of the Soviet Union'. 7.00g Institue of Education, London WC1 Saturday 11 November Socialist Conference 'Building the Left in the Unions'. Sheffield Poly Student Union, Pond St, 10.30. Credentials E6 waged, £4 unwag from Socialist Conference, 9 Polal St, London W1 Friday 17 November Labour Youth conference (three days), Bournemouth Friday 17 November CND annual conference (three day -City University, London EC1. Con tact CND, 22-24 Underwood St, London N1 7JG Defend Iranian political refugee Demonstration 28 October Assemble 1pm Marble Arch Break links with Iran!

Called by the Campaign.

Against Repression in Iran the Iranian Community Centre and other Iranian organisations

----- pull-quotes -----

A FAIR GRANTALL STUDEN

Grai MA VE GOT

ACTIMIST'S RIARY

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 420

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →