Lessons in bourgeois justice
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
VIORITHLAND Of the release of the Guildford 4 is a vindication of British justice, then, in the words of Private Eye editor lan Hislop, I am a banana.
All the factors that led to the wrongful conviction and 15-year imprisonment of these people are still firmly in place. The main events of last week stand as a powerful condemnation of British justice.
Annie Maguire and her family, for example, have not been cleared, and yet they were convicted by association with the Guildford 4. One of them was Guiseppe Conlon, father of Gerald, who died in a prison he occupied only because of fabricated evidence.
The two most important features of the Guildford case were uncorroborated confessions gained in custody and proof that the Surrey police falsified evidence. And yet six men have been in prison for nearly 15 years in precisely the same circumstances but the Home Secretary has rejected calls for a new appeal. The Birmingham 6 were convicted on their own confessions plus circumstantial evidence which has since been thoroughly discredited. Since their last appeal it has emerged that the West Midlands Serious Crimes Squad, which investigated the case, had been fabricating evidence for years. Officers have been removed, yet six of their best known victims languish in jail.
What the Guildford case does vindicate is the campaign to release them organised by the families and their supporters. It vindicates, and must surely boost the continuing campaigns to clear the Maguire Seven, and the campaign to free the Birmingham 6.
There is not a shred of evidence that the judiciary or government would have lifted a finger to discover the truth about these cases without the immense pressure exerted by the campaigners. The Tories know this, which is why Ivor Stanbrook was left isolated in his denunciation of campaigners. In his pathetic loyalty to British justice Paul Hill with his daughter Stanbrook resembles Igor Ligachev defending the continuing validity of Soviet-style "socialism' Each new turn of events 'confirms' his view!
Given the overwhelming evidence, even before the news of police misconduct, Why were they jailed in the first place, why did they stay in so long and, above all, why is this sort of injustice so much more likely to happen in Irish political cases than any others?
Of course, there are many 'bad" police officers. But the idea that interrogation methods in British police cells are, as a rule, liberal-democratic is an absurdity which still deludes too many people. (Of course it's a bit rough...it has to be...but there are rules...we have checks and balances..." etc.)
The fact is that Britain taught most of the world, outside the Eastern Bloc, the most effective and brutal interrogation techniques. They pioneered a form of torture known as Psychological Operations (PsycOps) in the 1960s in Asia, and used it extensively in the 1970s in Northern Ireland, especially in the early years of internment. This work is not done by 'bad apples' but more the more senior, trained officers. Even initially 'good' people recruited to and trained in this system do it.
There are corrupt officials, but none more so than the DPP who withheld alibi statements from the original trial and the appeal. The problem is not a few deviants but the whole system and the people who run it.
The fact that the legal elite is selected from such a narrow privileged social group is no small consideration. There is naked class prejudice in the judiciary.
At the time of bombings like Guildford, Birmingham or Deal there is an hysterical atmosphere in which the press and public cry for action and revenge There is pressure on police to get results.
and a real frustration within the police at their lack of ability to deal with the IRA's tight cellular struc ture.
The result of these pressures combined with good deal of chauvinism is a scapegoating of the Irish community. Most Irish people hostity in traile experienced sat some stage. It is no good just blamng a tew police, the press playec the major role at the time, politicians warned the Irish community to distance themselves from the "terrorists'!
A few months later the police select their victims and present them to the courts. Who are they?
Young, Irish and working class they are unemployed or casually employed, they live in hostels, bed and breakfasts. The people who make up the judiciary cannot comprehend their lifestyle. It is without a regular routine, so they cannot account for their every move. In short, they are the type of person decent middle class British people should expect to be a villain.
The most striking example of this clash of cultures and classes came in the Birmingham case. Some of the accused explained that they were on their way back to Belfast to visit their family when arrested. They were not on the run. But, the prosecution announced triumphantly, their family didn't know they were coming! The whole idea of a culture where people turn up unannounced to visit each other, where there is any spontaneity, was alien to the English upper-class mind They live in a world of formality, appointments, diaries, weekends booked. There is much to be said for such organisation, but that isn't how most working class people live and it's certainly not how the Irish emigrant community lives.
So the naked class prejudice counts as a material factor in these cases. People from our class are judged in every detail by the standards of an alien class. To read some of the account of the Birmingham trial is to see two lifestyles stare at each other uncomprehendingly. The tragedy is that one has such vast power over the other.
In the short-term, this side of socialism, what can be done about such tragedies? For start the powers which allow these injustices must be removed.
Uncorroborated evidence is still sufficient to convict in England and Wales. But the conditions in which police can extract that evidence are provided by the Prevention of Terrorism Act which allows police to detain suspects for two days with no legal help. If no evidence has been extracted the Home Secretary can renew the detention order for another seven days.
That is where these false confessions come from.
The Act was passed in 1974 by a Labour government, as a reaction to the Birmingham bombings, and the Guildford 4 and Birmingham 6 were detained under its terms. The PTA must go.
Labour has promised to repeal it, but the numbers of MPs turning up to vote against renewal has been a disgrace.
The lesson for the Labour Party should be that repression is no part of an answer to the Irish question. Labour has been responsible for too. much of the apparatus and laws which allowed these miscarriages of justice to occur. So when they appear at the front of protests about their consequences they should be forced to give commitments to dismantle this repressive machinery.
As usual, intimidating and scapegoating an entire community has been used as a substitute for dealing with their concerns.