What Trotsky really said about the USSR
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
14 Nov 2026, after a reader report: no 'By' line is printed; the standfirst, 'Laurens Otter replies to Duncan Chapel', names the writer. Transcribed from the scan of page 10, replacing the machine reading: the article fills the page, ending at the foot of the fifth column. The photograph caption is left out. 'inevitable lead', 'Trotksy', 'obvioulsy', 'inablility' and 'aplogise' are as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 10
Laurens Otter replies to Duncan Chapel
By the very march of events this question is now posed very concretely. The Second World War has begun. It attests incontrovertibly to the fact that society can no longer live on the basis of capitalism. Thereby it subjects the proletariat to a new and perhaps decisive test.
“If this war provokes, as we firmly believe a proletarian revolution, it must inevitable lead to the overthrow of the bureaucracy in the USSR... In that case the question as to whether the Stalinist bureaucracy was a ‘class’ or a growth on the workers’ state will be automatically solved...
“If, however, it is conceded that the present war will provoke not revolution but a decline of the proletariat, then there remains another alternative...
“The historic alternative, carried to the end is as follows: either the Stalin regime is an abhorrent relapse in the process of transforming bourgeois society into a socialist society, or the Stalin regime is the first stage of a new exploiting society. If the second prognosis proves to be correct, then, of course the bureaucracy will become a new exploitative class”. (Extracts from ‘The USSR in War’: ‘The present war and the fate of modern society’ New International 1938, available as pages 10 & 11 of ‘In Defence of Marxism’.
The passages omitted arguably paint a bleaker picture of what would happen if there were no world revolution at the end of the war, than did in fact happen. But 50 odd years after Trotksy wrote that, there can be no doubt that at the end of the war there was no world revolution that swept away the Stalinist bureaucracy — though there was an extension of the area of Stalinism, the product not of proletarian revolutions but of peasant armies or Russian troops.
Cde. Chapel claims that Trotsky did not say that if there were no world revolution then the bureaucracy would have become a new exploiting class. For him Trotsky only thought “the war could lead to revolution”. He is obvioulsy right in saying “but he stressed that revolution is conditional on the strength of the workers”. But Trotsky’s passage: “The inablility of the proletariat to take into its hands the leadership of society could actually lead under these conditions to the growth of a new exploiting class from the Bonapartist fascist bureaucracy” — hardly proves his case.
“A quarter of a century proved too brief a span for the revolutionary re-arming of the world proletarian vanguard and too long a period for preserving the Soviet system intact in an isolated backward country...
“If contrary to all probabilities the October Revolution fails during the course of the present war, or immediately thereafter, to find its continuation in any of the advanced countries: and if, on the contrary, the proletariat is thrown back everywhere and on all fronts — then we should doubtless have to pose the question of revising our conception of the present epoch and its driving forces... Have we entered the epoch of social revolution and socialist society, or on the contrary the epoch of the declining society of totalitarian bureaucracy”. (Ibid. foot of page 17 ff)
I fear it is Cde. Chapel, not I, that distorts Trotsky. Moreover when he says: “if a wrong prediction means you have to junk one of Trotsky’s theories, why not junk the rest?” he ignores the fact that it was Trotsky, not I, who said that if revolution did not happen within a generation (of the writing of the Revolution Betrayed) then this theory must be thrown in the dustbin of history. So, comrade, it is you who have junked one of Trotsky’s theories — your own question rebounds on you.
(Certainly for me the matter is different — I am a Rosmerite, ie an anarcho-syndicalist who despite basic differences in fundamental conceptions with Trotsky, nevertheless sees great merit both in the bulk of his actions out of power and in his theoretical method. Like Rosmer before me, I am continuously asked by anarcho-syndicalist comrades, why I have not junked the whole of Trotsky?)
Cde. Chapel thinks it is dishonest to quote Lenin, (it wasn’t actually one quote, it was a phrase Lenin used very often), to show that the term a ‘workers state’ was in fact a short hand for a workers’ dominated — through the soviets — state capitalism. Presumably that is because he quite rightly noticed that Lenin was using the term state capitalism in rather a different way from — say — Tony Cliff; and he failed to notice that the part of the phrase I stressed was workers’ dominated. That is, that the term workers’ state (as a short hand) was used by Lenin — not I agree, necessarily by Trotsky — to denote a society in which despite the economic basis political power was exercised by the proletariat.
Even Trotsky said: “The statification of the means of production is, as we said, a progressive measure. But its progressiveness is relative; its specific weight depends on the sum total of all the other factors” (ibid pp 23) — which shows that he did not agree with Chapel that “so long as they were under the control of the state it would not mean a return to capitalist power”.
But Cde. Chapel is here more markedly mistaken. Lenin did not mean by state capitalist merely “using some capitalist methods”, he meant the fact that 85% of all property was at the time still in capitalist hands, and only through state intervention was it possible to prevent unrestricted capitalism operating. Being a Marxist and therefore believing that the state represented the interests of the dominant class, he recognised that a state in such a society has to be a capitalist state. (Cde Chapel evidently thinks it is one of his virtues that he has never read anything by the reformist, Lassalle. But considering that Marx held that the particular document was essential reading for any socialist, the virtue is less than evident).
It was this fact (the 85% of the economy in capitalist hands at Lenin’s death) that occasioned the first article (by Simone Weil) in Revolution Proletarienne sketching out the theory of bureaucratic collectivism.
During Stalin’s ‘Third Period’ the bulk of this was taken into state ownership. Consequently, if one believes — with Cde. Chapel — that state control is the sole criterion, one has then to believe that Stalin in 1929-33 made a revolution, — albeit in a brutal and barbaric way. When people who had admired Trotsky, — as well as many who had until 1923 been left critics of Trotsky — said that for all the fact he had a courageous revolutionary past, was urbane, humane and a notable Marxist thinker, Trotsky was nevertheless now an ‘objectively counter-revolutionary’ they meant just that: Stalin was objectively — though not subjectively — a revolutionary and so Trotsky was...
Precisely because the state capitalism analysed by Lenin was being abolished at the very time that all the elements of workers’ autonomous power were being crushed, and when tens of thousands of good revolutionaries were being executed, it was necessary to find a new term, distinguishing what existed from what Lenin had described.
Trotsky certainly opposed the belief that the bureaucracy was already a class and at first that it ever could be. Note incidentally how his theories developed, as one would expect those of any dialectician to do.
In 1923-4 he was still opposed to the formation of factions within the communist party, backing the 1921 ban on factions. The communist party world wide was identified with the revolution.
In 1928-9 (when he was exiled) he decided that factions were necessary, but still was opposed to permitting any other soviet parties, let alone to trying to form such; he insisted that Russia needed to be reformed but denied emphatically that this amounted to any form of revolution.
In 1933-34 (after Hitler’s accession to power) he came to believe in revolution — albeit political revolution — in the Soviet Union, and the need for new revolutionary parties on a world scale. He then denied that it was possible that there could be a bureaucratic collectivist ruling class.
In 1938-39 (after the purges/Moscow Trials, the betrayals of Spain) he conceded the theoretical possibility of a new class rule; though insisting that it was a premature analysis.
What would he have said after the Third International was wound up?
Would he really fifty years later still be saying exactly the same as in 1938, and not — as he did on earlier occasions — allow the realities of the world around him to influence his thinking, and see a need to modify his analysis?
Obviously Cde. Chapel has less respect for Trotsky as a theorist than I have. Incidentally I must aplogise to Cde. Chapel for being ‘a bloody foreigner’, I didn’t notice that I had lapsed into my native language — which I now speak rather badly — but I may have done; to Cde Chapel and any other British chauvinists I duly and humbly apologise. (I suppose he was referring to discussion of Thermidor, a fairly frequent aspect of Trotsky’s theories). He says he has never called himself orthodox, implying that no other Trotskyist does. Experience over forty years, of Trotskyists in four countries, tells me differently.