An open letter to a Green Party supporter
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Dear Jean The Green party, as its name implies, starts from a feeling that the environment is under attack, that this will have profound effects on the living things that are part of that environment, that these effects will be profoundly harmful to living things (including us and that this is the fundamental political question of our time.
We, on the other hand, start from the situation that peoplethe working people of the world and their families - find themselves in. Our 'Where we stand' statement deals entirely with the rights of working people and how they may gain democratic control over their lives.
Though we must agree that logically the environment is fundamental to our well-being — we live in it and are part of it; our livelihoods come from it; and we may be harmed by it — we do not agree that it should therefore be the focus of our activity. (Nor, to be fair, does the Green Party solely on the environment).
Let us therefore look at our different philosophies to see if we cn explain the apparent paradox.
The Green Party sees the problem starting (or perhaps suddenly getting worse) with the Industrial Revolution, which they place some 160 years ago. At that time, they claim, there was "every expectation that an increase in material affluence would ease poverty".
For working people then there was every expectation that things would continue to get worse! The picture painted by Friedrich Engels, of the condition of the English working class in 1844 is not a picture of the beneficiaries of increased material affluence but rather of the debased victims of a new system of production. "industrialism and they claim that its logic is a relentless pursuit of economic growth' • They are correct to observe that this 'industrialism' has wasted and depleted the 'natural resources of a finite world', They could go a lot further. It tramples on the rights of people; it steals from them the fruits of their labour; it (or the political systems DuIlt 10 .. gian and be enemies set up or Ba претоібрес all sorts of divisions between people; and it has plunged the world into innumerable bloody conflicts, including two colossal and bestial world wars.
Not for nothing has a slogan of our movement been "Socialism or But what is the motor of this "industrialism'? And does it always push for economic growth?
It is true that there have been periods of economic growth in the last 160 years, and we are certainly better off than the workers of the early industrial revolution at least in Britain). But there have also been slumps, when the economy contracted and machinery rusted away, and the many wars have often thrown the economies of the participants (even of the "winners') back to a lower level.
Has the British economy grown during the Thatcher years? The steelworkers and miners might not think so! And the bureaucratic regimes of the Eastern bloc are in crisis largely because of the chronic stagnation of their "industrialist' (according to the Green Party label) economies.
I believe the Green Party has been fooled by appearances - and perhaps even that but b neton politica 1 parties and There is a rhetoric of economic growth which promises to alleviate poverty by giving more to everyone. That is the argument of the Tories. Working on the same principle. as feeding more oats to the horse to provide more pickings for the sparrows in the horse's dung, they shower more money on the rich, It is also the argument of the reformists in the labour movement, unwilling to alarm the rich by talk of redistribution of wealth.
n contrast to the Green Party's rather superficial approach, we in Socialist Organiser, as Marxist socialists, look under the appearances of "industrialism' and find a system whose motor is the struggle for profit and which we call capitalism.
Capitalism is a class system whose under-class, unlike_ underclasses in previous societies, has the organisation and power, but not yet the will to take control of society and run it in the interests of all. We believe that the socialist society thus established would have to swiftly develop a balance with the environment.
Not understanding the reason for the environmental despoliation of the last 200 years, the Green Party relies on moral arguments and appeals to reason, based on what they incorrectly see as a 'natural' order of things.
Unfortunately, their assertion — their 'Manifesto for a Sustainable Society' (MSS) that the Earth is a "steady state system" and that we, the organisms living on it, are "steady state systems" too, is untrue.
If it were true, we would never die - indeed, we could not be born! And on a world scale, it seems that the climate can change drastically over quite a short period of time without the intervention of
Scan page 7
THE ENVIRONMENT 7 d the green The dilemmas of Green politics countries In many issues, socialists have little disagreement with the Green Party. Eventually, a level of production which is sustainable would have to be established by a socialist society though the steadiness of its state might depend on factors outside our control (like the weather).
We agree on other issues too -nuclear disarmament and withdrawal from NATO are two of the more contentious ones in the Labour Party at present. And their idea of a guaranteed "basic income" has similarities with the socialist goal of "from each according to his/her ability: to each according to his/her need"
Their criticism of the centralised power of the state doesn't go as far as ours, though, because they do not understand its class nature. Their goal of decentralising and spreading political power, putting industry, technology, agriculture and social development in the hands of the people they affect echoes our vision of the withering away of the state, with its powers of repression and coercion, after the replacement of the profit system by a socialist one.
On some other policies of the Green Party, we have not taken such a specific position (eg nuclear power) but there would probably be a fair-sized overlap of opinion on these.
But the enormous question begged by the Green Party in its manifesto is "How?"
What little there is speaks of gradual, piecemeal changes, presumably by a Green Party government. But, as someone once said, "You can't skin a tiger claw by claw" (I apologise for the nature of that analogy!)
There is little about camp ning in MSS, except for a very oodconference resolution on hting the Poll Tax.
There is no understanding shown of the possibility of opposition to the implementation of Green Party policy and yet we constantly find all manner of pressure, verbal and physical, placed on those who seek to. interfere with capitalism's (or 'industrialism's") drive to survive. This ranges from hate campaigns against The miners, pol, a sin the the miners, and, as in the case of the Brazilian Chico Mendes, defender of the rubber tappers and of the Amazon forests from which they draw their livelihoods, murder.
The sole Green Party i strategy seems to be to win elections, and they are a long way from doing that with their admittedly impressive 15%. Atter all, the SDP/Liberal Alliance couldn't break through in 1984 with 27%!
I would like to suggest to the Green Party supporters an alternative approach. Join the fight to win the labour movement (Labour Party, trade unions, tenants' groups, action groups around a whole range of issues) for socialist environmentalist policies.
The biggest group of 'green' MPs in Europe is to be found among Labour MPs and MEPs, some 46 of whom are members of the Socialist Environment and Resources association (SERA) (together with a solitary Welsh Nationalist!) many of whom were elected despite challenge by a Green Party candidate.
SERA and other groups, such as Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth, have had quite a success getting environmental issues on to the public agenda and the Green Party has benefited from this. Of course, individual Green Party members have participated in this work.
So I would like to see the Green Party become a socialist green party and help in the struggle to transform the labour movement into a socialist and green movement.
Yours, Les Hearn Green politics is full off C interesting dilemmas Nuclear vs coal power, 1 one example. Depending on your starting point, you can come up with convincing arguments for either (or rather against the other one). Or take global warming - It's the temperature would allow the USSR to exploit vast new tracts of land for food production.
Or did you know that irrigation can actually be bad for the land? Making the desert bloom can drastically lower the water table and create acute water shortages, cause rivers to silt up and (over time) wash nutrients out of the soil.
When it comes to the environment there are no easy answers. - Having said that, there is much observable damage happening all around us which demands instant and obvious action. Had the political will existed Britain could have introduced lead free petrol 10 years ago, or banned aerosols, both of which steps were taken by the Americans.
It has been obvious to British holiday makers for a long time that the countryside, the coasts, the rivers and the mountains are not what they once were. There have been far too few prosecutions of polluting companies, local amenity managers and water authorities.
Dirt in all its forms - chemical pollution eva f, lise has brian spreading for decades and is slowly but surely poisoning our environment. Even leaving questions such as nitrate fertillisers and pesticides aside for those more competent to answer them, the wanton destruction of the countryside, the poisoning of the water supply and the air we breathe are obvious to everyone.
You can see how much destruction has been caused. Take litter. Litter, like the Royal Family, is part of our national heritage. Visit most other European countries and you will see that they are visibly cleaner. But the issue is not so much that we Brits just drop our rubbish and leave it to lie where it falls, but that there is a vast litter creating industry of multinational companies making a fortune out of selling us packaging.
Whether we drop it on the streets or put it in the bin at home all that paper, plastic, tin and expanded polystyrene has to be disposed of somehow. As it is we rape the land for raw materials to make the packaging, then poison it disposing of the waste. The whole process is motivated by profit. The whole process is self-evidently mad!
We currently have the technology to recycle much of our rubbish -tins, paper, plastic and in most cases its cheaper to recycle (in the long run in large quantities) than to get more raw materials. But change on the necessary scale would need massive investments — and it would lead to a drop in short-term profits.
It would also mean a loss in income for. those countries and companies which produce the raw materials. Such steps are not taken lightly by capitalist governments precariously balancing their national import/export figures and their banks' shares in 3rd World debt. Such governments take a very short-term view.
An illustration of this is provided by looking at britain's consumption of energy. Anyone interested in the environment knows that : burning coal helps create acid rain. Therefore we need to clean up our act in coal fired power stations. The technology is available but using it puts up the price of electricity.
Burning fossil fuels also contributes to głobal warming.
Within this irrational capitalist system, of course socialists back the coal miners in their fight to keep pits open. Though, in a proper socialist world you wouldn't send men to dig in the bowels of the earth for their living.
And of course we can't trust the capitalists or the Stalinists to operate nuclear power safely. But from the point of view of the overall needs and well being of human society the truth is, that coal is bad news for the environment.
Other sources of energy are available and could be safely used under socialist planning.
Hydro-electric power is very "clean' but it does damage the countryside, sometimes leading to the extinction of plant or animal species. The same is true of tidal barrages. We may not notice the difference but local flora and fauna cetainly do, and their disappearance will come to have an effect on us over the years.
The obvious solution is to conserve energy - to simply use less. Most of us agree in principle with that as an idea. But have we the money to pay for it? Given a choice most people would opt for €10,000 off the price of a new house and pay more for heating bills continue to pay for fuel becaues we haven't got £2,000 for double glazing.
GRANDPA -TELL ME ABOUT THE OZONE LAYER.
Of course the government couc insist by introducing regulations for things like home insulation or most simple, direct and quick by raising evergy prices. What government stations and let someone else worry about the environment.
The problems cannot be solved in one financial year. If an economy depends on consistent profits, long term projects like recycling or halting pollution are not on the agenda. Capitalist governments dare not take the political risks associated with protecting the environment - although it must be said that most are prepared to stick their necks| out further than Thatcher!
Above all the issue is not a national one. We need internationally co-ordinated long term action. We need to know that what is begun now will not be stopped in 10 years because it is no longer expedient, politically or financially.
But we live in a system where that isn't possible. To hang on to power for another few years the Tories may agree to a few changes and they may be rude to Brazil at the UN. But one nation's government is not pulling all the strings. Until we have a system of rational international planning, the environment will still be the victim everytime someone spots a quick profit.
The ecological crisis facing humankind is one more illustration that the old socialist posing of the alternatives before us is true: it must be either socialism or The answer to the ecological barbarism in which we now live is rational, international working class planning of the economy. That is the answer both to the exploitation of the working class and to the chaos and barbarism endemic to the capitalist way of organising production, and also to the way the ruling bureaucrats in the Stalinist police states run their economies. The ecological crisis is one of the most threatening aspects of this capitalist and Stalinist chaos.
MERKER
Scan page 8
Philip. Vine tells the battle of El Salvador's trade unionists against repression next The UNTS is the largest union in El Salvador. Right now it has two Bolamos, Raphael Zepeda, Juan Francisco Massi, Christia Chan Chan..." and half a dozen more who were all captured in August. Some of them are now in prison and others have 'disappeared'. Despite eye witness accounts of their caputure, the security forces refuse to acknowledge their involvement.
It is usual to just categorise these people into statistics. But they are all individuals whose commitment to their principles have led to death or indefinite imprisonment.
In most cases captured union Wednesday 18 October Cardiff SO: 'After Labour Party Co ference'. 7pm The Comet, Moira Street, near Cardiff Royal Infirman Saturday 21 October NALGO Broad Left conference. 11 am Mechanics' Centre, 103 Princess Street, Manchester. Saturday 21 October Hands off Our NHS! Demonstrate against the White Paper. 4pm
----- pull-quotes -----
current "big fear' of the western world, but a small rise in
would dare do that? It's far, far easier to keep building new power
AIC TIMISES DIARY