[Be had, and have, no wish to denounce…]
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Be had, and have, no wish to denounce the Iranian comrade concerned to anybody -certainly not for leaving Workers Power and becoming a supporter of Socialist Organiser. That is his political right.
As a member he voluntarily committed himself to observing our constitution which says clearly that Internal Bulletins are and remain the property of the group. Comrades who resign are expected to return them for reasons of security. The need to be protected Reply:
Readers can judge the sincerity of this "explanation' in two ways:
(a) By its glib linkage — which is close to being an equation — of the danger to British socialists from Labour Party witchunters who expel people from the Labour Party, with the threat Iranian eftists face from the murdering Khomenite state!
Think about it...It's either a piece of smug little Englandism and Labour Party cretinism or evidence that Stocking et al don't let themselves think too concretely about the realities of Khomeni's "anti-imperialist state". Or it is just empty words.
(b) By the incident 5 years ago, when Workers' Power published documents about the situation in the Labour Party circulated within the, now scattered, from the witch-hunters in the labour movement and the press is dear to us as indeed is the desire not to see harm come to an Iranian leftist. For that reason his branch organiser asked for the return of the originals which he refused to do. Of course we have no sanction against such a comrade except to make clear to other left wingers who know him and us that this constitutes disloyal behaviour. wual our organiser said to him was that we would brand him on the British and Iranian left as a thiet, a nar and a supporter of a pro-Zionist newspaper.
Dave Stocking Workers' Power WSL". It was Labour Party Conference time, and right-wingers like John Golding gleefully showed Workers' Power's middle-page-spread around conference to discredit the left. Later, a WLer spotted Workers' Power leader D.Hughes on a demonstration, and reprimanded him for their factional irresponsibility. Hughes commented: "That's your problem"
D.Stocking sent us a long letter. The except — which we publish here to give them their right of reply to the serious charge we made against them — is the gist of their reply. The rest is self-indulgent abuse, comparing us to the old WRP, etc, ete. We are not inclined to indulge Stocking. "Thief, a liar... Yes, and smarmy little hypocrites too.
John O'Mahony