Back to 1926 LEFT PRESS
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Labour Briefing gives the general impression of being a rather worthy, even dull, publication. It is very concerned with the day to day minutuae of Labour Party affairs and the problems of left wing councillors.
But Briefing's industrial coverage can be quite extraordinary. During the dock dispute, its central slogan was "Todd must defy the law" - a demand that was repeated in successive articles and was even used as a front page headline.
Now, everyone with any sense knew that a successful dock strike would inevitably involve breaking the law. But to make "Defy the law" your main demand on the T&G leadership, was to get things arse-about-tip, to say the least. SO called on Todd to give a lead to the militancy of rank and file dockers and to do what was necessary to build an effective strike: as we pointed out, that meant being prepared to break the law. But we didn't call for defiance of the law as though it was a matter of principle for its own sake.
This is not just nit-picking: Briefing's approach implied a lightminded attitude to the union's funds (and, indeed, its very survival) that went far beyond making the point that defending effective trade unionism means being prepared to put union funds at risk at crucial moments. Worse, it was, in effect, a call on Todd and the ETITERS Alan Thornett: the brains behind 'Briefing"
TGWU to do single-handedly what the entire trade union movement had failed to do over the previous 6 years - defeat the full panoply of the Tories' anti-union legislation.
Since the end of the strike, Briefing's industrial coverage has continued on its fantastic course, constructing a grandiose scenario in which the defeat of the dockers takes on "historic proportions, not just for the dockers but for the British trade union movement as a whole"
Of course, no-one wants to minimise the tragedy of this serious and unnecessary defeat. But an "historic defeat" ... of the "British trade union movement as a whole" ....? Even the 1985 miner's defeat wasn't that. If Briefing means what it says, then we're talking 1926.
As SO pointed out, the dockers against Southwark and Camden have been dropped, it seems he is going to pursue this "loss" and we may be faced with paying a further, defeat took place against the general trend of industrial struggles, which have been on an upswing for some time. How does Briefing explain the victories of other groups like NALGO and the railworkers against the background of this "historic defeat'? Easy! *The recent industrial upsurge was eventually contained by wage concessions designed to isolate the dockers. But it was a high price for the Tories to pay...
The idea of the government deciding to allow the railworkers the London Tube workers and 500,00 local government workers to win significant concessions simply ing's own description of the government "squealing with anger" at the NALGO settlement. It also squares rather uneasily with this simple fact: the NALGO settlement and the London Tube settlement were both reached well after the end of the dock strike. The BR settlement came a month after the high point of the dock strike - the National Port Shop Stewards' attempt to organise an unofficial strike between 10th and 12th June.
When SO supporters have raised these points with some leading Briefing supporters we have been accused of insulting' the dockers, as though it was all a matter of not hurting peoples feelings.
Attempting to put the dock strike into context is no "insult' to anyone. Militant dockers don't need their egos massaged by Briefing: like serious trade unionists everywhere, they want a realistic assesment of the present state of the class struggle. They certainly won't get that. from Briefing's wacky (and ultrapessimistic) industrial 'analysis"
please keep it going.
And if you haven'- can you consider giving one?
Stephen Bubb,