Lift the ban on Sinn Fein!
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
John Downes was victim of a police attack on a peaceful demonstra of the Unionist establishment. BBC's normal policy assumed tl When independent television was existence of a rational audienc set up in 1955 the chief manager of The Northern Ireland audience Ulster TV was a man called that moment were not rational"
be the chairman of the Unionist to ban programmes under ti Many programmes such as for Realm Acts by issuing 'D' notic example a profile of lan Paisley by this was never done. Instead the ITV's "This Week' were shown in could rely on self-consorship by ti Britain but not in Northern Ireland. media albeit, often, after a goc Others. such as an early attempt to deal of pressure.
EDITORIA L is one year since the government introduced its broadcasting restrictions against organisations supporting 'terrorism' in Northern Ireland. Discussion of the issue this week has centred on how journalists have misunderstood it and implemented it more rigidly than they are required to under law.
On BBC2 and in the 'Sunday Correspondent Peter Taylor of Panorama stressed that the measure, introduced by Douglas Hurd last year was not a *ban against Sinn Fein'. First, it isn't a ban it just imposes restrictions which mean that interviews with certain organisations must be broadcast with subtitles or voiceovers, rather than the actual soundtrack. Second it is aimed at all illegal groups, and at the large organisations, Sinn Fein, the UDA. So both loyalist and republicans are affected.
Taylor and others have also pointed out that broadcasters have over-complied with these measures. Interviews with Sinn Fein have decreased sharply. There has not been a single defiance of the ban and people sympathtie to Sinn Fein's aims have been needlessly affected ITV for example, refused to play the words of the Pogues song Birmingham 6', despite the widespread support even from the establishment for its sentiments There is something both naive and hypocritical about media comments on this undemocratic anniversary. In the first place the restriction may not be solely against Sinn Fein, but it is clear that they are the target.
It was introduced shortly after last year's bombing in which 8 soldiers died. There was right wing and press clamour for "strong measures' Internment was discussed in Cabinet. There was pressure to do something. The result was the media restriction.
Proof of its effect was the fact that Gerry Adams blamed the measures for Sinn Fein's poor results in the local elections in May.
The over cautious compliance of journalists and broadcasting organisations can be no surprise to anyone who has tried to discover anything about what has happened in Northern Ireland in the last 20 years. There is much truth in the old saying that, *If you don't know what has been going on in Northern Ireland you must have been watching British TV and reading British newspapers'. The most effective restriction on reporting on Northern Ireland has been the self-censorship and bias of the media themselves.
Before the Troubles there were hardly any programmes on Northern Ireland produced. But those that were could be vetoed by the local Northern Ireland chiefs of BBC or ITV who tended to be part The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race"
Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01 639 7965. reports: first post Henderson who happened also to Party's publicity committee.
discuss the border by Alan Whicker were simply banned When the Troubles came bans and cuts became commonplace.
The rationale came from the broadcasters themselves, Lord Hill, BBC Chairman in 1971 stated "As between the British Army and the gunmen, the BBC is not, and cannot be impartial". Desmond Taylor, BBC Editor of News and Current Affairs in 1972, said, "The phone Monday PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU).
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser at Despite the government's abill Official Secrets or Defence of tl 1 Programmes on RUC torture in interrogation centres; on the Provisionals; programmes critical of Northern Ireland ministers were all taken off the air after intense government pressure.
A recent example was the BBC "Real Lives' programme which attempted to show a day in the lives of Martin McGuinness of Sinn Fein and Gregory Campbell of the DUP. After a government protest the programme was withdrawn.
But the government and press have used other techniques which the media in general has rarely resisted. Typical is the accusation that programme-makers have endangered lives or been taken for a ride by republican fifthcollumnists. The vicious attack on *Death on the Rock' suggested that the programme-makers were disloyal to Britain or sympathetic to "terrorism'. Another nasty feature of that incident was the vicious Photo: John Spier treatment of Carmen Proetta by the tabloid press, who accused her of being a high class prostitute and a liar. She was neither.
So the media's poor treatment of Northern Ireland is neither new nor goverment imposed. In fact, the thrust of most liberal criticism of the current restrictions is distinctly illiberal. Underlying the broadcasters complaint is an appeal to leave it to us, to beat the republicans in our way"
For example, the argument that the restriction lets Sinn Fein off the hook after certain atrocities.
The case for lifting the restriction should be that people need to understand why the ideas of Sinn Fein, or the UDA have the support they do. What is unique about Sinn Fein is not thier connection with violence, it is their articulation of the grievances of the Catholic under-class in Northern Ireland, a group whose voice is rarely taken into account.
What the British media establishment is asking for is the right to return to a more subtle self-censorship, the right to uphold British values their own tried and trusted way. With a few honourable exceptions that is what we had before and it was not free speech.
We need free speech on Ireland - free from government bans and free from "liberal" media self-censorship.
The annual gathering of the Tory faithful for what is officially known as a "conference' is normally the occasion for an orgy of brownnosing and triumphalism from the delegates and from most of the press.
This year it was a little bit different. With Labour ahead in the polls, inflation hitting 7.6%, the pound plummeting and mortgages soaring triumphalism was not exactly the order of the day Mrs Thatcher, of course, is never to blame when things go wrong. But the press must have their villain: step forward Mr Nigel Lawson.
In an extraordinary front page attack, headlined "THIS BANKRUPT CHANCELLOR" the Daily Mail let rip in no uncertain fashion. Lawson's policies «Jay in ruins" his treatment of homeowners was "scandalous" . He must, of course, go; but go where? "Would you give this man a job, as chairman of a bank or a city editor of a national newspaper? The Daily Mail certainly would not. So it is no good him applying here for a position. He would be kicked downstairs quicker than you could say Another rise in base rate' formulated the Mail, Who wrote this tirade? When questioned, editor Sir David English did not exactly fall himself to deny authorship.
Today, which is presently posing as a non-Tory paper (it supported the Greens in the Euro-election) competed with The Mail in Lawsonbaiting. "If he cannot do better than stick out his double chin while raising two fingers at ordinary people, he should stop pretending to be in control of the economy. And like emperors who have outlived their usefulness, fall on his sword".
The Express stopped short of demanding hari-kari, but it did put its finger very acurately on the real reason for all this vitriol - "the plight of Britain's 9 million homeowners: the people who are bearing the brunt of the government's economic policy and are now seeing their mortgage repayments rise by about 50% in little over 15 months. If this increased burden was leading to a substantial capital gain there would be some comfort to be had. But it is not."
There you have Lawson's unforgiveable crime summed up in a nut-shell: he has clobbered the children of the "Thatcher revolution' - the young couples encouraged to buy house for the first time, the older people enticed into buying their council houses, the middle class families tempted to "buying upwards' as an investment. And worse still, while their mortgage payments go through the roof they see the value of their property actually falling!
The Tories can attack the unemployed and claimants, the tenants of the inner cities and all those recalcitrants who still live in council houses. But when homeowners, many of them readers of papers like the Daily Mail and Today start to suffer then things have clearly gone too far. The middle classes of South East England whipped up into a frenzied mob outside No. Downing St would make fearsome spectacle - especially with Sir David English at their head.
----- pull-quotes -----
enemy et GANIG Daily Express DAILY