Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A rose by any other name

Socialist Organiser no. 418, 12 October 1989 · scan p. 11 · about 1,296 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

By Sleeper addenly it begins to look R though Labour might win the next general election.

In this context, an article by the Observer's Economic Editor, William Keegan, in this month's AEU Journal takes on a particular significance:

*The most difficult nettle a future Labour government would have to grasp 1s the one marked wage inflacher/Howe/Lawson approach has been ion™ writes Keegan. "The Thatto fight inflation either with recession or with a high exchange rate, which makes industry less competitive, or with both. Then comes the crunch: "Mrs Thatcher and Mr Lawson will never concede the need for some kind of incomes policy, yet that is what is required. It will fall to Labour to have to admit this, however unpopular the concept is with trade unions."

Now, the AEU Journal is an admirably non-partisan publication noted for its wide variety of contributors (including, recently, Mary Whitehouse) and its expert gardening tips. A piece by the Economic Editor of the Observer The Somnolent One begs to differ.

Traditionally, Labour governments have tried to achieve two things: running capitalism more efficiently than the Tories and, at the same time, appeasing their working class electoral base with a few concessions.

Incomes policy is the so far unspoken, but inevitable, logic of Kinnock's Grand Plan for rescuing British capitalism from the mis-management of Thatcher and Lawson. From now until the next general election, the likes of Jordan and Edmonds will be softening up their members for a deal on wage restraint. The deal, may or may not be statutory (voluntary arrangements coupled with penalties against employers who break the norm would be an easier pill to swallow, at least initially) and it probably won't actually be called an 'incomes policy'... but a rose by any other name...

The 'left' unions like the TGWU and MSF are formally committed to opposing incomes policy, but it is worth remembering that it was the left wing 'terrible twins' Jones and Scanlon who were the main architects of the Wilson government's -Social Contract. Left unions with a large proportion of low paid members like NUPE and NALGO (soon to merge) could be bought round with vague promises of a deal on a minimum wage.

In all the horse trading that will certainly be going on around the question of incomes policy, one phrase that you will not hear from the Labour leadership or the trade union bureaucracy is 'Social Contract.

But that in essence is exactly what is native accepting dismissing yourself.

He then added that he was there to listen. Speaker after speaker took the floor and told him that there was going to be no agreement! • Less than 24 hours later, management backed down. The DLO workers had won a round.

It can, however, only be a temporary retreat on the part of the council, and sooner rather than later they will come back with more threats and intimidation to cut wages and sack workers.

Despite the intimidation, and despite the national union, the workers said no, and solidarity won.

2,500 administrative and support grade jobs. With so much of the civil service being cut and privatised, PSA management are refusing to rule out compulsory redundancies.

Other civil servants will inevitably suffer through the provision of poorer accommodation and maintenance standards.

It is essential that the industrial and non-industrial unions immediately establish joint rank and file action committees açross the country.

now being cooked up. A detailed history of the 'Social Contract 1974-78' would make useful reading for the generation of activists too young to remember the dreadful days of Phases 1, 2 and 3, Suttice for now, to note that real incomes fell by 5 to 6%, the self-sacrifice, belt-tightening and so forth was never mateched by the government's fine promises of price controls and special consideration of the low paid. Finally, the Social Contract led to a mass defection from Labour-amongst the skilled and semi-skilled working class of the industrial Midlands, paving the way for Thatcher and all that followed.

Remember that as Bill Jordan and John Edmonds start their campaign for an incomes policy| under whatever name.

Tower Hamlets strike This is pure and simple union victimisation — but we won't let them get away with it".

That's how one NALGO striker put it at last Friday's branch meeting which voted overwhelmingly to carry on with the all-out strike action.

Derek Relph, the NALGO branch secretary, was sacked for alleged intimidation of scabs — a charge he and other eye-witnesses refute. After the settlement of the national dispute Tower Hamlets decided to carry on with their selective action. They gained support from the national leadership of NALGO and local Labour Parties. However the notorious Liberal Council seem determined to get rid of Derek.

With a 75% yes vote in the ballot 2,500 Tower Hamlets NALGO workers started an all-out indefinite strike. The national union is providing 100% strike pay.

Last Wednesday at Derek's hearing it was recommended that he be given a final written warning. However at Friday's branch meeting, attended by over 1000 strikers, this was thrown out as Derek had done nothing wrong in the first place.

The Friday vote was tremendous. The course of the strike must continue to be determined by the NALGO strikers and other trade unionists affected by the strike.

Contact numbers: 729 6682 Strike HQ (Bethnal Green Labour Party); 519 7457 Branch; 375 0114 Derek Relph.

would face the prospect of Dr Death or Ashdown holding the whip hand, and we'd be in the same boat as if the Tories had full rein.

It's pretty dismal.

But we have to look at history.

The organised working class is stepping up its demands and its actions.

t seems to me that whatever th utcome of the next election. tha action has got to continue.

The only answer we've got is not to desert, but to stay in the Labour Party and take it back off the hijackers. We have to organise: the rank and file within the trade unions and the Labour Party have to get more organised, get their act together, so we'll know exactly how to deal with whatever problems face us after the general election.

We mustn't be despondent. The Labour Party belongs to us - the working class. We have to take it back.

Labour Party conference was a non-event as far as the pit goes. *Red Ken' being defeated was noticed. But Kinnock is appealling to the non-activists. And I'd like to issue a word of warning.

Kinnock is building on a bed of sand, appealing to disillusioned Tories, middle-of-the-road liberals and the party non-activists. When it comes to the crunch, they will desert him as quicly as they flocked to him.

He's taking the activist and the committed vote for granted. understand that you have to do that on some occasions, but it doesn't mean you have to turn you back on hem entirely, or desert your prin ciples. And I'm afraid he's putting his faith in people who will desert him.

We'll accept Party policy, but retain the right to get that policy changed, to get the party back on what we consider socialist principles.

We should be as firmly committed to our principles and policies as Thatcher. If that means we have to remain in the wilderness, so be it.

would rather remain in the wilderness and fight, knowing that when we do get back in • which is inevitable the principles, aims and objectives will still be there.

If we made a stand on principles, the support would be there - rock solid support, which would remain.

Paul Whetton is a member of Manton NUM, South Yorkshire.

----- pull-quotes -----

advocating incomes policy is surely not particularly noteworthy, you may ob-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 418

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →