Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A different film of rebel youth

Socialist Organiser no. 418, 12 October 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 1,155 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Belinda Weaver "Dead Poets Society"

The lesson that we physically exist separately and alone is hard, but it's one we learn to accept within the first year of life.

A much harder separation comes later, emotional separation, the process of striking out on our own path in life.

In growing up, in battles with our parents and teachers, we push against the walls of what is wanted of us, and if we're lucky, we break free. We discover our own voices.

If we're not lucky, we never break free, and end up either living out our parents choices for us, or rebelling against their authority. Either way, we haven't left home. The life we live feels wrong somehow, like an ill fitting shoe. Something has been lost -ourselves.

"Dead Poets Society" is concerned for that fledgling self hidden within each of us. Set in an exclusive American boys prep school, it concerns a group of identikit schoolboys who blossom into thinking, feeling, and sometimes incompatible people under the tutelage of Mr Keating, an inspirational poetry teacher, played with brio by Robin Williams.

Till now, the boys have been ground down by the combined power of parents and school. Set unthinkingly on the path of worldly success, destined for careers as bankers and bosses, the boys are encrusted with a mixture of conformity and cynicism that is blasted away by their first contact with Keating.

Using a mixture of goading, inspiration and calls to rebellion, Keating tries to help each boy uncover who he is as an individual. Keating understands the pressure to conform, but he wants the boys to fight against it, to test the rules to the limit, and if necessary, to break them. Only thus will they learn to think for themselves.

Finding our own core, our own voice, is never easy. Most people have conflicting needs - the need for individual achievement, and the need to be liked and approved by others. Resolving that conflict, finding the balance that suits us, requires the separation of our self from others.

To find that self, we have to feel pity, love and concern for the child we once were, with all our hopes and dreams. If our parents failed us, and bullied us to do only what they wanted, it's harder. In the film, both Tod and Neil, the boys from unhappy homes, find it harder to break away from unloving, controlling parents. Having missed out on love and acceptance, their sense of their own worth is shakier. It takes confidence and courage to choose your own life.

In the film, Keating represents the ideal parent, the person who encourages you excel, who recognises you as unique, while accepting you as you are. It is an over sentimental picture, though. Keating is presented as unflawed, as warm, generous and empathetic, with none of the controlling, lifedenying features of the other teachers or the parents. It's as if Peter Weir, the film's director, was unable to get into the mind of the teacher and see him as whole, but sees Keating the way the boys do, as omnipotent, as perfect.

Keating is flawed. True, he inspires the boys, but he is also blind to the seriousness of Neil's torment, and pushes the boy further than he can safely go. Yet much of what he does is helpful, and if he is implicated in Neil's downfall, he is also instrumental in the liberation of several others.

Keating's motto is Thoreau's, to *live deliberately...so that when I came to die, I should not discover that I had not lived."

In the closing scene, some of the boys show they have understood that, and their courage and pride is heartening to see.

Unlike "If " that other schoolboy fable of rebellion, "Dead Poets Society" is genuinely subversive. In "If.. " the boys finally take to the roof with guns and shoot it out with the society they detest. Their rebellion is nihilistic though, a dead end, a mere reaction to the status quo. It poses no real threat.

"Dead Poets Society" is different. In teaching the boys to think for themselves, Keating is arming them with different weapons - the ability to say no to conformity, to stand up for principles, the courage to be different, and to speak out against wrong.

So why did Hollywood make this film? It's hardly the usual message.

Over the years, Hollywood has Breakina awav from careers as bankers?• financed many films about misunderstood youth. Foreseeing box office gains, the studios have bent over backwards to identify with teenage rebels and have flattered such audiences by showing the spoilsport grown-ups as wrong and hypocritical.

I imagine they thought they had the same sort of thing in "Dead Poets Society". But they're wrong. The comfort for the boys in "Dead Poets Society" is not the comfort Hollywood has usually given - i.e. that one day they'll be grown up themselves and able to inflict similar misery on their own kids -but rather the comfort that courage and principle and self-knowledge The film has more in common with rarities like "Norma Rae" , the film in which textile worker Sally Field learns to fight the bosses. The final scene of Dead Poets Society" echoes the scene in "Norma Rae" where worker after worker stops work.

There are flaws. Weir's tone wobbles when he has to draw female characters. The women are either goddesses like Chris, Knox's lady love, beautiful, golden and unattainable, or commoner clay, like the two girls who attend a society meeting and fail to recognise the words of Byron.

The presentation of Keating as opaque and mysteriously (because we don't know why he does what he does) perfect, and the rather romantic, melodramatic and overwrought scripting detract from the film, without destroying its appeal.

The film's message is "Know thyself". It makes a nice change from "American the Beautiful". strong, collective union tion to help them take up like sexual harassment.

Again, however, this central issue which, after all, was the trigger for the whole film, got a bit lost. The picket was supposedly part of a union campaign against sexual harassment but the placards seemed a bit tokenistic; it seemed more of an excuse to make a lot of noise and hammer bosses in general.

This was probably a result of the film trying to tackle so many issues. It sometimes seemed as though the filmmaker was too anxious to provide something — including romantic interest - for everyone. As the opportunity to make and market a film like this can't come along very often, again perhaps it was understandable.

Well, it moved along apace and was never dull, but colourful and uplifting. And it was, after all, a rare sight, a film about the working class fighting bosses and winning. There should be more of them.

----- pull-quotes -----

are good in themselves and bring rewards from within.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 418

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →