LABOUR PA rights voted
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-10-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Class, and build up a mass memberhip around such policies. Or the eft will be purged and the Labour Party transformed from its present ramshackle self into a tight and inolerant party modelled on the West German, Swedish and other Social Democracies".
We are now living through The worse of those alternatives. The eft has not been completely pur put the regime has been gr cly ightened up.
The National Executive's report o conference listed 71 cases heard py the National Constitutional Committee, the vast majority eading to expulsions. Numerous electoral moods agitate and organise agair the Tories"
onstituency Labour -een suspended.
The Labour leadership is not wayed by the need for unity. It is onsciously, aggressively trying to model the Labour Party as a safe arty of capitalist government -nd trying to construct guarantees › keep it safe.
When the conference voted for rms spending cuts, the Labour radership did not do what they light traditionally have done -aguely promise to "take on bard" the decision, and then white down the policy over time. Thev at down a marker by slapping the inference in the face, immediately eclaring that they would ignore its ecision.
The last major vote of the conrence was to review the whole ructure of Party decision-making. he leadership's plans are to timinate conference altogether, exept perhaps as a media event like n American party convention, and • replace it by unelected policy ommissions on the model of the olicy Review groups.
The left has not been thoroughly urged, nor is Kinnock likely to be ble to purge it thoroughly before le next election. But the right wing early has the upper hand, for now. The decisive turning point which gave it the upper hand came long ago, and Brighton was only drawing out the implications.
That turning point was in the early '80s. It resulted not from the strengths of Kinnock and his friends, or of the hard Labour Right, but from a turn made by Labour's Left.
When Thatcher came to power; the labour movement had two options: fight back then and there, mobilising on every issue that arose, trying to drive the Tories from office; or ride the punches and wait for better days A fight back was possible. Thatcher was very unpopular for the first two or three years after 1979. Industrial combativity was still relatively high. The anti-union shackles were only being riveted on; they were not reliably in place. The miners had not been defeated.
And in 1980-1 sections of the Lett had positions from which they could lead a fight back, in local government. It was a god-sent opportunity. Tory cuts could have been resisted. Local government positions could have been used to mobilise against the government, linking up local communities with industrial and other struggle.
But the dominant section of the local government left — people like Ken Livingstone, Ted Knight, and David Blunkett - decided differently. They decided to avoid confrontation, to duck out of the struggle, to haver and try to find a way out.
So they ran local government, raising rates to compensate for Tory cuts. At best they failed to do anything to mobilise their local working-class communities against the Tories, at worst they alienated and disgusted them.
Militant on Liverpool City Council got further down the road towards a fight with the government, but backed off in the end -so it was the same result, with a few added grotesqueries.
Instead of local government under the left being a school of class struggle, or of anti-Tory struggle at least, the Livingstones made it a school of class collaboration, an academy for 'lesser evil' politics, a crash course in what Ken Livingstone himself called 'the politics of the cynical soft sell' The left didn't get another chance. And everything else since has flowed from those decisions to do local government business as usual with left trappings.
Because we failed to fight — and nobody in their right minds would have relied on the Labour leaderHypocrisy as the platform sings "The Red ship to lead a serious fight the Tories went from strength to. strength, and the labour movement from retreat and defeat to defeat and retreat.
The right and soft left were both strengthened in the Labour Party and trade unions, and made to seem the best thing going as alternative to the Tories. Today, those like Ken Livingstone who bear most responsibility for what happened to the labour movement in the early "80s still parade as verbal leftists, free with the 'cynical soft sell' and left verbiage, but the reality of the defeats shapes events more than the left verbiage.
What should the left do? Tenacity, tenacity, always tenacity, must be our motto. There were sizeable left minorities at Brighton on many issues. New recruits can be brought. into the Labour Party from poll tax campaigns and industrial struggles and won to the left.
The "Constituency Labour Parties Conference" set up last year held a lively fringe meeting at Brighton, and will be campaigning: • for a charter of CLPs' rights; • to defend Conference sovereignty: • for Clause Four, unilateralism, and trade union rights.
Its newsletter, and its conferences (the next one of which is due next spring), will provide a solidly-based framework for active CLPs to coordinate campaigns and exchange ideas.
More than that, we need to organise a serious Marxist left, not only in the Labour Party but in the trade unions too. That is what Socialist Organiser is trying to do.
It must be a left which dares to face the lessons of the past so that we do not have a future as similar to the past as Neil Kinnock's future in office is likely to be similar to Labour's last period in office.
The Labour left will revive, and so will the left in the unions. Despite himself, if Kinnock wins the election it will give a great boost to the left and the working class in The Sunday Correspondent's Donald MacIntyre recorded a conversation in a bar at Brighton which puts it nicely. Ex-MP John Golding, the long-time right-wing roughneck, was astonished at the peace and calm. He said to a friend: "When's the Labour Party conference then? Because this certainly isn't it"
His friend replied: "T'll tell you exactly when it is - October 1992'. When Labour has won the election — or lost it again.
Trade union rights were a central issue at the Brighton Conference.
Liz Williams from Wallasey Constituency Labour Party moved a composite committing Labour to repeal all anti-union laws and to introduce "a legally recognised right to strike, to picket effectively and in whatever number is chosen, and to take other forms of industrial action"
The composite also claimed *the right for unions to determine their own constitutions and rule books in accordance with their own democratic procedure free from any intarfarance by the Moving it, Liz said: "This composite is about restoring basic rights to trade unionists, not giv ing privileges. Privileges do exist in this society. They are the privileges of the rich, the privileges of Thatcher and her friends".
Seconding, Tim Peacock from Broxtowe CLP said: "The Policy Review offers us 'A Charter for Employees' - sounds like it was written by someone from Personnel! We need a Workers" Charter giving workers the legal rights we need to defend ourselves collectively against the bosses"
And Arthur Scargill spoke in support. "It's all very well for the platform to praise Solidarity in Poland. What they should in Brighton Strong for contracey ocialist Organiser supbriefing for conference delegates in Brighton.
We also organised for several fringe meetings, including especially the Chinese Solidarity Campaign and the Constituency remember is that Solidarity has often called strikes without a ballot"
The composite won two and a quarter million votes. The TGWU voted for it, and so did a number of other unions. The issue caused a public row within the UCATT delagation on the floor of conference.
The composite adopted by conference on trade union rights was moved by John Edmonds of the GMB. It did not spell out the Labour front bench's intention to keep Tory laws requiring ballots, banning 'secondary' action, and limiting pickets to six, but only talked of "the repeal of anti-union legislation and its replacement by a fair and positive framework of industrial relations legislation"
Edmonds even spoke of the need to repeal all the Tory anti-union laws. Other speakers on his side of the debate, however, were more forthright.
Bill Jordan of the AEU declared: "The mass pickets have been demobilised, and the Labour Government must not call them back" . Eric Hammond of the EETPU congratulated himself on the fact that his industrial policy is rapidly becoming Labour Party policy.
The two and a quarter million votes for full trade union rights are, however, a good base on which to build a campaign against the approach of Hammond, Jordan and Edmonds. Labour Parties Eric Heffer, Tony Benn, Joan Maynard and Peter Heathfield all signed the Chinese Solidarity Campaign petition to free political prisoners in China. Gerald Kaufman, Arthur Scargill. and Maeve Sherlock refused.
Scan page 8
8 LABOUR PART he week at Brig LABOUR PARITY Sunday Conference rejected the proposal that resolutions carried contradiction to the Policy Review should be 'treated as amendments' to it, by 3.704 million votes to 2.245 million.
The constitutional amendment that CLP votes for Leader and Deputy must be decided by onemember-one-vote was carried by 5.207 million to 0.508 million. Monday The left resolutions on the a cut in arms spending was carried by 4.201 million to 1.922 million.
or the PiLO ali an nependent.
Palestinian state alongside Israel was carried by 4.645 million to 1.394 million, against the National Executive's recommendation. Tuesday The National Executive working party 'compromise' proposal for a Black Socialist Society was lost by 2.715 million to 3.363 million. The National Executive's policy — for a Black Socialist Society, with white members — was defeated by 2.893 million to 1.428 million.
A proposal for quotas of women among Labour candidates, the Shadow Cabinet and the National Executive was carried on a show of hands. A resolution laying down for unions to democracy f interference was million to 3.823 Thursday A resolution calling for non-payment and non-cooperation with the poll tax was lost on a show of hands.
A resolution calling for Labour to consider electoral reform was lost by 4.592 million to 1.443 million. One calling for a Bill of Rights was lost by 4.481 million to 1.297 million. The platform was defeated on full equality for gays and lesbians by 3.702 million to 2.317 million. A call for troops out of Ireland was defeated by 5.308 million to 0.600 million.
Friday regulate own ree fri tate as lost by 1239 million. depends where you are in the labour movement. If you are hi up, then you have done pretty! and it might get you into government - but for what purpose. It's not been good Dennis Skinner In 1931 they must have been disillusioned. I know my dad was. But it didn't stop him fighting. H didn't throw the towel in.
It took 14 years and a war, but things changed. They change all the time.
I think we have to understand that we socialists are optimistic. It's a contradiction to be a pessimist.
I can see a dozen issues upo which we have got to fight. Of of the things we have to do is make sure we put sectarianism onto the back boiler.
Dave Hatt (NUR delegate)
I think the Conference was very flat. It was stage-managed even before we got here. There seem to be cartels in the unions. The one thing that has not come through from this conference is any debate or consultation. If they think this is going to convince the electorate then they are in cloud-cuckoo land.
----- pull-quotes -----
'Instead of speculating on
and hoping for the best, Labour should go out