Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The road to Brighton Pier

Socialist Organiser no. 418, 12 October 1989 · scan p. 6 · about 1,573 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Order reigns in the Labour • Party! For now. This year's conference established one thing most clearly of all: that the big majority of the party wants to give Neil Kinnock and his team a clear ride against Thatcher for the 1991 or 1992 General Election.

Kinnock had most things his way. Not everything: against the will and voice of the seemingly all-powerful leadership, Conference passed Bruce Kent's motion to cut arms spending: The lett, and left-wing moods, impulses and aspirations, are not dead. But this conference showed them more dormant than at any time in the last ten years.

That is not surprising. There is a traditional and very powerful strand in British labour movement politics which scorns 'pie-in-thesky' ideas and prizes the approach which sets practical, limited, immediately realisable goals and goes for them.

It is the old narrow reformist approach, with its mixture of foreshortened vision, blinkered thinking, and its own version of "pie-in-the-sky' ideas - "socialism' to come sometime in the future, when the immediate short-term business is not so pressing.

This traditional thinking combined with the effects of ten years of defeats for the labour movement to provide the conditions, for Kinnock's triumph.

Right now the aching need is to bring down Thatcher. Everybody (except perhaps the foolish people who run the SWP) knows that only the Labour Party can do that, and that the normal way to do it is to use the next election.

The limited revival of industrial militancy this year shows us what the future will bring, but it has still not reversed the broad eight-year trend of industrial peace - the peace of Thatcher's industrial graveyard. The electoral struggle is the only weapon now available to the labour movement for a comprehensive response to the Tories -and people know it.

The pressure is enormous not to rock the boat, not to be too concerned for the future beyond the defeat of Thatcher, not to worry about what a Labour government would do. First get the Tories out!

Kinnockism in the Labour Party is a direct — and, in the minds of Labour's leaders, a conscious — byproduct of ten years of rampant Tory rule.

Many people who are now Kinnockites enthusiastically joined in the left's fight ten years ago, when it seemed that the Labour Party could be reconstructed and politically regenerated into a socialist movement accountable to the working class. They now settle for a lot less, in the spirit of settling for the best "realistic' option available. And so Kinnock and his friends could "write their own ticket" at this year's Labour Conference.

A shameful sight it was, to see a Labour Party which did not even dare commit itself to unshackling the unions from Thatcher's policestate trade-union legislation, the most vicious this side of Europe, for fear of a vote-losing campaign in the Tory tabloids.

Even poor old timid, tepid Michael Meacher is - so the Observer says — due to be sacked from his Shadow Cabinet job by Kinnock because he appears too "pro-union' to blend comfortably into the image Kinnock and his friends think best for the Labour Party now. —On one level the thinking in the labour movement that allowed Kinnock and his friends to do what they did at conference makes sense. Of course it is of the greatest importance that Labour wins the next election. It is true that short of a tremendous surge of industrial militancy of such scope and power that it could bring down the Tory government - and right now that is nowhere in sight, and anyway would be unpredictable - the next election is the best chance we have to kick out Thatcher.

A Labour government would at least loosen the legal disabilities which now cripple unions, and the recent experience of the dockworkers, for example, shows how lethal a barrage of weapons the Tories now have in their legal arsenal. It may even be that a Labour government will be necessary - both to loosen the Tory shackles and to break the atmosphere of primitive-Tory reaction which now reigns - before there can be a large-scale revival of industrial militancy.

In any case no-one but a sectarian fool can deny the sense and logic of those of the early-'80s left who now say that beating the Tories is the first goal, We part company with those comrades not on that, but on the miserable Kinnockite way of trying to dislodge the Tories, and on Kinnock's alternative to Thatcher. We refuse even to pretend — as many erstwhile leftists do pretend, in the first place to themselves - to believe that Kinnock's policy represents a real alternative.

Kinnock and his friends hope -and that is all it is, passive hope -that if they can appear as champions of normalcy then the Tories will defeat themselves. So they make themselves into 'wet Thatcherites', , as bland as bland can be, supporters of market economics, and even of Thatcher's anti-union legislation - and hope that the winds and tides of opinion tavour them in 1991 or '92, They hope that Thatcher's and Lawson's ability to manipulate the economy into a pre-election boom will vanish this time round (and it may do so); they hope, if all else fails, that the electorats will at least want a change next tim e round and opt for Kinnock's with a human face' The Labour leaders' new 'line' is that they represent mainstream capitalist policy, as maverick Tories.

"Mrs Thatcher is out of step" they say - out of step with the policy of the West German Christian Democrats or the rulers of Japan or George Bush in the US. And Labour is in step — with those capitalist governments.

Peter Mandelson, Labour's Director of Communications and eminence grise of the new regime, puts it strikingly in an interview in the current Marxism Today:

"Europe is bound to have become important for the Labour Party because it's a way of getting socialism in through the back door. The Tories were absolutely right in warning the British people during the European elections that Labour saw the European Community as a way of bringing more socialism into Britain"

Ten years ago almost the whole Labour Left, and much of the Labour Right too, saw the capitalist EEC as an obstacle to their hopes of bringing Britain to 'socialism in one country' ahead of the rest of Europe. Now the same BEC appears as a means of getting "socialism' (mainstream welfare capitalism) through the back door of Tory Britain — and Labour proclaims its goal as bringing Britain into line with other countries.

This approach has been accepted, or at least condoned, by the labour movement, not just because of the pressure for unity, and not just because of the demoralisation caused by ten years of defeats. The ideological weakness of the left is also a major factor.

When the left was stronger, the economic programme of the broad left was never developed beyond a vague scheme for a siege economy with import controls, price controls That "siege economy' programme has lost credibility. Kinnock's team has pushed through the ideological breach with a forthright acceptance of market economics, national and international. Most of the left has no answer. The two left resolutions on the economy got tiny votes in Brighton. Yet everyone knows that the acceptance of market economics is the keystone of the Policy Reviews. The left could challenge the Policy Review seriously only on less central issues.

Yet Kinnock's is a cowardly, passive, and ultimately an irresponsible approach. Because it has led Labour's leaders to divest themselves of any real alternative to Thatcherism, it is an approach that will finally explode in their face, when they have to try to clean up Thatcher's mess. Those in labour movement who now support Kinnock will come face to face with Kinnock's "Thatcherism with a human face' in power, and find it neither human nor friendly. It will still be capitalism, and most of the Thatcherite mask, too, will still be in place.

The alternative to Kinnock's approach is a drive to fight the Tories, on the sort of policies Socialist Organiser has advocated for the last ten years. Instead of speculating on electoral moods and hoping for the best, Labour should go out and agitate and organise against the Tories.

But Kinnock and his friends have not even dared to do that over the Poll Tax, a vastly unpopular measure on which a campaign could have mobilised millions of people around Labour. A campaign like that would not have made Kinnock a socialist, but it would have been serious anti-Toryism.

It is Kinnock's very failure to fight on this and other issues that pushes people who would be enthusiastic activists and militants in a fighting anti-Tory campaign behind Kinnock now. The lack of a lead from Labour's top ranks blocks off an avenue of action and leaves them little alternative!

It was an important conference; it registers serious changes, and gives the green light for more.

Back at the start of this whole cycle in Labour politics, I wrote: "If the proposals [for Labour Party democracy] get through, it will be the beginning of a major left/right struggle...

*Either the left will go on... to consolidate the Labour Party as a genuinely socialist party seeking to overthrow capitalism on the basis of the class struggle of the working

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 418

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →