Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unpleasant deposits

Socialist Organiser no. 417, 28 September 1989 · scan p. 9 · about 1,011 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

They disliked both his theories and the fact that he was Jewish.

In his youth he studied medicine, qualifying as a doctor and specialising in the study of the nervous system. He became more interested in the treatment of nervous disorders by hypnosis. Working closely with Dr Josef Breuer, he developed a treatment for hysteria which involved free association the discovery of underlying emotional traumas by means of relaxing and saying whatever came into a patient's head.

Freud's association with Breuer came to an abrupt end when Freud noted that neuroses were often associated with feelings of guilt. He developed the theory that different types of neuroses were the result of the patient participating, actively or passively, in sexual activity with an adult while they were still children From this time on, Freud developed theories about unconscious motivation, repression and human sexuality Freud was always prepared to refine or change old theories if they seemed to unsubstantiated by LES HEARN'S SICHENICE Now can we dispose of the The waste will be put into concrete containers, surrounded by bentonite, a clay mineral that will resist water penetration, and buried in granite tunnels several hundred metres deep.

Favoured sites for repositories will be coastal with hard basement rocks, such as granite, overlain with sedimentary rocks (eg. in Scotland) or offshore sites with sedimentary rocks (eg. East coast). NIREX were surveying several sites, most of which were vetoed by the government just before the last election as they were in Tory seats. NIREX's Multi-Attribute Decision Analysis for Site Selection (MADASS!) was then focused on Dounreay and Sellafield. Planning permission for exploratory boreholes at Dounreay was refused so that left only Sellafield.

NIREX's risk assessment is concentrating on:

• looking at the permeability or rocks to groundwater to see if substantial amounts of radioactivity will be able to get into the environment;

• looking at the possibility of future intrusions (eg. drilling) into the repositories. Future generations may not know of the repositories and if there is an attractive mineral near the site they might inadvertently dig up the waste;

• assessing the pace of corrosion and the likelihood of gas generation, leading to high pressure (fountains of waste?);

• assessing the likelihood of earth movements disrupting the stores. For intance, would another ice age (due any time in the next few thousands years) result in erosion of the rocks covering the repositories by glaciers?

If the risk assessment comes up with the right answers, testing will start at Sellafield in 2005J So how long will the waste be kept away from the environment if all goes well? The concrete containers should last 300 years. As they deteriorate, they should make the surrounding clay more alkaline and hence less permeable to water. This chemical containment should work for 5000 years. The geological characteristics of the rocks should then keep the waste in for perhaps 50,000 yars. By this time the more soluble radioactive elements (ie. those most easily leached out by water) should have decayed to very low levels.

The goal, as defined by the Department of the Environment, is that escaping radiation should cause no more than one extra cancer death per year per million population.

But sooner or later ground water will penetrate the repository. Do we have any guidance as to how fast it will wash out the still highly radioactive waste?

Well, there are some naturally occurring repositories of radioactive material. One, Morro do Ferro ('hill of iron") in Brazil, is perhaps the most radioactive spot on the Earth. 30,000 tonnes of the radioactive metal thorium lie buried a few feet below the surface and a stream runs through the deposit. Plants growing there have picked up so much radioactivity that when laid on wrapped photographic film they X-ray themselves!

However, and this is very encouraging: there is very little radioactivity in the stream so the material is not very mobile in the environment. Thorium behaves like plutonium, so it is most reassuring that emissions from Morro do Ferro are only 1/20th of US limits for plutonium.

At other sites, such as uranium mines at Koongarra, Australia, and at Oklo, Gabon (a natural fission reaction nearly 2 billion years old), very little radioactivity escapes.

At Cigar Lake, northern Canada, a 1300 million year old uranium deposit at 450 metres reveals no trace of its existence at the surface, despite being saturated with groundwater for a billion years. Closer to home, sediments in Loch Lomond include a layer of radioactive clay containing uranium, radium and iodine. The sediment has remained undisturbed for over 5000 years and the radioactivity seems quite firmly locked up.

The evidence from these natural deposits "provides considerable reassurance to those modelling a waste repository", concluded Dr Chapman at the BAAS meetingHowever, in his OU talk, he raised the question of human interference. Given that no human society to date has had a continuous history of much more than 2000 pessibility that some future society we have to consider the with no knowledge of us and our wastes will reinvent the science of geology.

They will then discover, say, in the region of what used to be Sellafield, an unexpected magnetic field. If they know about nuclear power, they may suspect a radioactive deposit but otherwise they may dig down to see what's there and find our still highly dangerous wastes.

The above deals only with high level waste. There are also intermediate and low level wastes, less radioactive but in larger quantities. These also require safe burial but their more varied composition (lots of paper and plastic makes it more difficult to predict what will happen to them over time. Quantities of intermediate level wastes will increase markedly as nuclear power stations start to be dismantled.

Dr Chapman argued though that people hastery to sore sorts of SOME SOLL realistic context. He thought people should be just as concerned about the disposal of toxic chemicals. much now in unlabelled sites. He also somewhat mischievously pointed out that more people die from using contraception than i nuclear power!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 417

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →