Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Neil Stonelake surveys the life and ideas of…]

Socialist Organiser no. 417, 28 September 1989 · scan p. 9 · about 708 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Neil Stonelake surveys the life and ideas of Sigmund Freud, who died 50 years ago this month n the late 19th century there were great leaps in human knowledge, with scientific methods being brought in to solve the problems people face.

Marx revealed the scientific basis of the exploitation of the newly-formed working class. Darwin's Theory of Evolution exposed the roots of the human race itself and cut through the superstitious mumbo-jumbo peddled by religion.

Last but not least, Sigmund Freud took the first steps towards unravelling the mysteries of the human mind. Like Marx and Darwin before him, Freud met with great hostility from his contemporaries. His theories provoked ridicule at first, ridicule based on fear of what he had to say and its implications.

For, in his investigations of the roots of human behaviour, and particularly of human sexuality, Freud seemed to be striking at a relationship which lay at the heart of capitalist society the family.

Freud was born in 1856 in a town which is now in Czechoslovakia, but from the age of four to one year before his death in 1939 he made his home in Vienna. In 1939, when he was in his eighties, and dying of cancer, he was forced to seek asylum in London from the Nazis.

An aspect of this theory which has also caused great controversy is that of 'penis envy'. Freud held that at the same age as a boy becomes interested in his penis, a girl develops a corresponding interest in her clitoris. But since, Freud said, the clitoris was a poor substitute for the penis, the girl became intensely jealous and only develops an attachment to her father - the Electra complex when she has accepted her sexual state.

Freud argued that neuroses occurred when the patient had failed to successfully pass one or another stage of development. Therefore a frustrating experience at one stage would lead to a regression to an earlier, more successful stage. So, a hysteric is said to have regressed to the phallic stage and an obsessional to the anal.

These theories led to the most savage attacks on Freud and his followers. Freud himself was the target of a scurrilous campaign of abuse and in England his follower Ernest Jones had his clinic closed Freud's concentration on the sexual origin of neuroses led to splits within his own movement. The Swiss psychologist C J Jung split from the psychoanalystical school, as did Alfred Adler, who saw Freud's theories as too exclusively concerned with sex to the exclusion of power.

Adler argued that social circumstances led to feelings of inferiority - the inferiority complex - for which the individual struggles to compensate. So people develop a public 'persona" whose aim is to beat feelings of inferiority and gain superiority. Thus far such strivings are natural but when they become exaggerated, maladjustment takes place and leads to personality disorders. Therefore a neurotic develops symptoms because they cannot attain the goal of superiority by normal means.

Freud's theories were a huge scientific breakthrough. For the first time it became possible to see such sexual phenomena as homosexuality as a product of the social environment (instead of as a sin or a crime). Freud's emphasis on the social was particularly progressive in a society which placed strict taboos on discussion of sex, which was seen as 'dirty' There are few orthodox Freudians about nowadays. Freud himself did not generally see his theories as fixed or static. He was generally open minded and scientifically objective.

Freud was not a revolutionary in a political way, despite the nature of his theories. His politics throughout his life were left-liberal rather than socialist.

It seems that the greatest weakness of Freud was his insistence on the individual rather than on society. For instance, while his views on homosexuality were very progressive for the time, he still saw it as primarily a dysfunction rather than a separate form of sexuality. His theory of infantile development now seems very rigid and mechanistic — unable the total environment of dividual into account.

But Freud stands as on great scier whos • vi flexi mora listic tific geniuses of the age, ws were more complex ble than those of his detractors.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 417

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →