Tragedy or farce?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
ference'. New Imperial Hotel, Birmingham. Details from Barry Lovejoy, 25 Philip Victor Rd, Birmingham B2] Sunday 8 October Socialist Platform Memorial Meeting for Harry Wicks. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, London WC1, 3.00 Sunday 8 October Canterbury SO day school: "Workers' Liberty 1989'. Keynes College, University of Kent, room JCRIII, 9.30am Monday 9 October Sheffield SO: 'Stalin's heirs face the workers', SCCAU, 73 West St, 7.30 Wednesday 11 October Cardiff SO: 'After Labour Party Conference'. The Comet, Moira St, near Cardiff Royal Infirmary, 7.30 Wednesday 11 October Manchester SO: 'Stalin's heirs face the workers"
workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own anti-socialist bureaucracies.
We stand:
For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class-based women's movement.
Against racism, and against deportations and all immigration controis.
For equality for lesbians and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clarity in debate and diecussion For a labour mozamont • accassible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitaliam.
We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board. LEFT PRESS W but extremely pretentious yorkers' Power is a small kitsch-Trotskyist grouping, keystone of a small but even more pretentious "International". - It was a mid-'70s splinter from the Socialist Workers' Party, formed partly under the political influence of the old Workers' Fight group. It fused with Workers' Fight in 1975; nine months later the majority of Workers' Power fied to the safety of their own ghetto, leaving an important part of their original group behind.
They remained adherents of the SWP view that the Stalinist states are a form of state capitalism, though, as they used to say, "not Cliff's theory" . They never told anyone what their own theory was, subsisting for four or five years on the name tag "state capitalism' Then they made a startling political leap and decided that the Eastern Bloc countries were after all some sort of workers' states. They made this decision in response to guess what event? The USSR's invasion of Afghanistan!
It was an irrational and hysterical leap, an emotional act of denial, made against the testimony of events in Afghanistan. Workers' Power seemed to be moving under the pressure of the Spartacist tendency, who enthusiastically supported the Russian invasion; WP = adopted the lower-key approsch, shared by most kitschTrotskyist groups, of refusing to call for USSR troops out but not explicitly approving the invasion.
Just as a human embryo, in the course of its short development period, recapitulates the whole of evolution, so Workers' Power quickly recapitulated most of the errors and foolishnesses of post-Trotsky Trotskyism - beginning with this grotesque piece of nonsense about 'supporting the revolution' in Afghanistan when in fact they were endorsing Russian imperialist expansion.
The post-Trotsky Trotskyists in the 40s were at least doing their best, groping for answers in unforeseen circumstances. The Workers' Power epigones of those epigones clowned around three and a half decades later when there could be no excuse for it. First time tragedy, as Marx said, second time farce - pretentious pous burlesque!
WP's other theoretical innovation since they split from WF is the notion of "imperialised' countries - one they coined in 1982 to explain why socialists should support 'imperialised' Argentina against imperialist Britain in the Falklands War.
iran, too, is 'imperialised', and so WP backed Iran in the Iran-Irag war. Now their solidarity with the "imperialised' has taken them a stage further.
A former WP supporter who had decided that Socialist Organiser makes more sense than WP was phoned by his local WP organiser, demanding the return of some political discussion documents circulated among WP supporters. To add urgency to his demand, the WP organiser threatened the comrade — an Iranian exile — with the prospect that he would be "exposed' to other Iranian activists in Britain as supporting a "Zionist" tendency, and WP would then "let anti-imperialism take its course".
So we contacted the WP office and asked them how they justified threatening to finger an Iranian Marxists to the Khomeinyites.
We never said any such thing', they protested. 'We said we'd expose the comrade to the Iranian left'.
Knowing that, for & group which ranks General Galtieri and Ayatollah Khomeiny among anti-imperialists, "left' can be a broad term, we asked Socialism and Revolution, maybe". Bat S&R would not be very shocked by a comrade agreeing with I SO Israel/Palestine, would they? "Oh, well...
Of course the threats were silly and inconsequential, as so much of W'S politics are. It was just an additional litte farce, growing out of the big farce of the 'anti-imperialism of idiots' so common on the left and the desire to be revolutionary "tough guys"
It was farcical - but symptomatic. Here you have a local organiser of an avowedly Trotskyist tendency who can threaten to inform on an Iranian excomrade to the iranian 'anti-imperialist' state which has slaughtered so many thousands of Iranian socialists.
And what does the nationa! *fice of Workers' Power do about it? Repudiate their organiser? Reprimand him? Set about re-educating him? No, they weasel and wriggle. Farcically. of course.
Catch comrades! yourselves