Flintknappers and thatchers?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Chris Croome looks at the arguments sparked off by Prince Charles's new book on architecture Over since Prince Charles' 'montrous carbuncle' spmeech in 1984 about a proposed extension to the National Gallery he has become increasingly vocal about the built environment.
Last year he presented a TV documentary and this summer he has published a book, the contents of which also form an exhibition at the Victoria and Albert Museum in Prince Charles' outrage at the form of the built environment is a reaction to the constant геmoulding of the environment by capitalism, and it is for that reason that he has 'struck a chord' with so many people.
He condemns the London Dockland where ...indifferent commerce snubs the deprived boroughs all around" and despairs ...the sheer, unadulterated ugliness and mediocrity of public and commercial buildings.
He deplores the wholesale reconstruction and redevelopment of city and green field sites which is taking place at an ever increasing pace. However, not surprisingly, he lacks an understanding of why such change is occuring] For example he makes no mention of how the intervention of vast amounts of foreign capital have turned the London Docklands into Europe's biggest building site. He fails to understand that the constant dynamic transformation of the built environment is a result of constant changes in the mode of production and social relationships.
An understanding of changes in the production process of buildings is crucial, as they have a dramanc effect on the building produced. One of the main tendencies within the capitalist mode of production has been a relentless reduction in the quantity of skilled labour employed on site, as new technology and components enable more production to be undertaken in factories and the division of labour between intellectual design work and physical construction work virtually eliminates the possibility of creative input from building workers.
These are just two consequences of management's attempts to exert greater control over workers' conditions and practices in order to wring greater profits from their labours.
Prince Charles is horrifed by the results of the capitalist production process, which he fails to understand. "A factory-made world is not enough". He declares that "Beauty is made by the unique partnership of hand, brain and eye.
Prince Charles mistakenly believes that architects are to blame through " ...obeying the dictates of fashion" , and his vitriol is aimed almost exclusively at them. lowever, in singling out this elite group Ol people he is massively overestimating the power they have over the form of the built environment, a delusion he shares with the majority of the profession.
The ideology behind this view sees buildings as sculptures created by artistically inspired individuals, and ignores the social and economic background to their creation.
Discussion centres on debates over the style of finished buildings and in so doing totally overlooks the generative nature of the production process.
Within this framework the debate over style - Price Charles's preference for classical buildings puts him to the far right relative to some of the more progressive modernists and it is that which provokes the condemnation of the architectural establishment. His views on architectural style lead him directly to one of his most reactionary proposals - that architectural education should be more traditional.
He believes that through the study of the styles of the past, architecture could once again continue the classical tradition.
Prince Charles, in his search for a way forward, looks romantically at the past, and points to Victorian Glasgow to show that ...an economic boom can inspire handsome buildings" as a contrast to this century's monuments to capital in the city of London which he derides as "slovenly towers of commerce... He believes that for various complicated reasons "sometime during this century something went wrong" . He's not quite sure what, but he knows that it was better in the past.
The idealised English village and its Extraordinarily rich tradition of regional building styles and materials" inspires him with a vision of the way forward, "we must encourage our traditional craftsmen - our flintlenappers, our thatchers and our blacksmiths and involve them in the building of our future"
This is possibly his most absurd statement, and is especially bizarre when elsewhere in his book he acknowledges that in reality "concrete, plastic cladding, aluminium, machine-made bricks and reconstituted stone are shipped to every corner of Britain from centralised production lines". Quinlan Terry's 'Richmond Riverside Prince Charles's favourites. Can a re answer?
It is impossible to turn the clock back. The specific social and economic conditions which for example generated superb medieval cathedrals, and beggars, starvation, hovels and filth all around them, fortunately cannot be repeated.
The unsatisfactory nature of the current built environment can only be explained through true understanding of history and the office complex, one of treat into the past be the social and economic realities of the present, crucial to this being the undemocratic distribution of land ownership and economic power.
Prince Charles has no answers for any problems based in reality; substantial improvement in the quality of buildings produced can only come about through massive change in the process of their production and only when workers have control can cess be realised.
This in turn can only occur as a result of revolutionary change in society; only then can everyone have the freedom to care about and creatively contribute to the form of the communites and houses that all must live in. Only then will society have an architecture that is truly free.