The bosses still don't control Russia
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
aurens Otter (SO 413)
raised three points against Trotsky's analysis of the The first point was that Trotsky argued that his theory was temporary, and that if the war did not lead to world revolution he would have been wrong.
Pardon me, but when did Trotsky say that! Certainly Trotsky did think that the war could lead to revolution,. but he stressed that revolution is conditional on the strength of the workers and the socialists.
Now predicting wrong is no crime. But if a wrong prediction means you nave to junk one or Trotsky's theories, why not junk the rest? Laurens distorts what Trotsky says in an attempt to refute this — and it is not convincing.
The second point is that all transitional societies are state capitalist'. • Laurens uses a quote from Lenin where he describes the USSR as state capitalist to prove this.
Again this is dishonest. For socialists today state capitalism means a capitalist society where the boss class owns the state and the economy and controls it through the state. Now that wasn't what Lenin was describing. -Lenin meant it to describe how the USSR - under the control of the workers - could use some "capitalist' methods. So long as they were under the control of the state it would not mean a return to capitalist power.
Lenin was talking about the NEP — a special package of economic reforms which specifically allowed peasants and farmers to sell their goods on the market.
So USSR Methods bu argued that the USSR was capitalist or that any transitional society could be capitalist. In fact Lenin argued the opposite - as Laurens well knows.
The third point is the argument - Lassalle's, so Laurens says -that a revolution will inevitably disappear if the revolutionaries aren't vigilent enough.
Well, I've never read anything by Lassalle - so I can't really say. There is a point that needs to be made though - nothing happens inevitably. For capitalism to be restored in a working class run state the bosses have to make a revolution to get back control of the economy. And that hasn't happened in Russia.
For all Laurens' fancy French quotations — he can't conquer facts so (like a Stalinist) he has to distort them. I think if Laurens was right he could win using honest methods. But he can't.
Finally, Laurens calls me an *orthodox Trotskyist'. I don't know why he insists on using the inverted commas because I've never called myself orthodox. That's a word for the religious, not the revolutionary.
Duncan Chapel, Nottingham Sinn Fein in catnones in the ivorin. unis fact alone makes discussion with them important. Secondly, Gerry Adams has said that the needs and fears of the Protestant community should be recognised by all Republicans — obviously a step away from simple "Catholic domination"
Chris also says that we should be interested in talking to real workers, not their self-appointed leaders. Unfortunately, the 'real' workers in Ireland are divided on communal Lines, and look to their communal leaders to represent them. Socialists can't just ignore this.
He also seems to have forgotten the media ban on Sinn Fein and should be fighting for the right for them to be heard, not putting extra barriers in their way.
To finish, a serious discussion on the solution to Ireland must include the representatives of the Protestant community too, in order to try to nde d take into account