The issues at Labour Party conference ary
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
EDIITIORIIAL Labour's leaders and their allies in the top brass of the trade unions want to transform Labour's decisionThe Policy Review is their model: a package carefully designed by small committees under their control, without any untidy Conference mandates Or awkward commitments.
A resolution from the General, Municipal and Boilermakers' Union (GMB) in the agenda section on Reform of Conference and Policy Making maps out the plans of the Kinnock faction. The motion is full of fine words about "greater involvement by Party members" "more representative of all sections of the membership" "expanding the role of Conference", and so on. Its real drift is just the opposite.
The GMB wants to change the make-up of the National Executive so that it would include representatives of Labour councillors and of Euro-MPs. This would mean electing the National Executive piecemeal, from the Euro-MPs' caucus, the conference of Labour councillors, Labour regional conferences, and so on. All direct control by Party conference over the National Executive would removed.
Then most of the Conference would be given over to considering reports from "policy commissions"
Also in this section are proposals to increase the constituencies' share of the vote at Conference from about 10 per cent to 40 per cent. Last year's Conference instructed the National Executive to prepare a constitutional amendment to that effect. The Executive has broken that mandate, but three constituencies have submitted draft amendments, and a motion from Nottingham North asks for those amendments to be debated.
The right wing will try to use the enlargement of the CLP vote as sugar on the pill of removing power from Conference. We should insist the issues are kept separate.
Other constitutional proposals to be voted on in Brighton require CLPs to decide who they back for the constituency section of the National Executive by one-memberone-vote, exempt MPs from reselection if they have fought a by-election, and restructure Labour women's conference to let the unions dominate it. All these should be opposed.
The Brighton conference will vote on each Policy Review document as a whole, warts and all. The big trade unions will vote for the documents even where they have criticisms, so it is certain that they will be accepted.
Then what happens if conference votes for unilateral nuclear disarmament, for renationalisation of industries sold off by the Tories, or for the reversal of all Tory anti-union laws? The Policy Review scraps all these commitments.
Neil Kinnock would like the Policy Review to overrule specific conference decisions. Dozens constituencies have submitted motions saying that specific conference decisions must considered as *The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race!
Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01 639 7965. reports: first post amending the Policy Review.
Will a future Labour government keep some of the Tory shackles on the unions? Or will it legislate a positive right to strike?
This will be one of the key debates at Conference, under the title Rights at Work. It looks as if the bulk of the motions under this heading should sort themselves out into three composites.
The General, Municipal and Boilermakers' Union (GMB) has a motion endorsing the Policy Review. The GMB wants judges to continue to have the right to rule strikes illegal because pre-strike ballots have not been carried out in the form decreed by the Tories. Solidarity strikes would also, proremain illegal, and bosses would have the right to sue unions for damages.
The Transport and General Workers (TGWU) have an amendment to the GMB's motion demanding immunity in tort for trade unions" . Translated out of lawyers. language, this means that bosses should not have the right to sue unions to recover the losses they suffer through strike action.
A large number of motions demand a "Workers' Charter"including the right to strike, the right to picket, and the right for unions to determine their own democratic processes free from control by the courts. The most detailed are from Wallasey, Broxtowe and Sheffield Central CLPs.
They call for Labour to go on the offensive on this issue, proclaiming and championing the right of working class resistance to the tyranny of capital.
The biggest section of the Conference agenda is on the environment.
The green-socialist magazine New Ground comments the Policy Review on the environment: "[The] criteria by which...to judge Labour's environment policy.all essentially boil down to one tism: do they really mean it?, quesAnd on that one question the verdict is "mixed" The Policy Review's commitment to free-market economics will make it difficult for any green good intentions to become effective. And the Policy Review favours retaining nuclear The Policy Review does say *we shall not invest in new nuclear power stations" — but as long as the Tories build enough nuclear power stations during their periods in office, on the basis of this policy Labour governments could be using nuclear power for ever!
The Labour leadership, however, wants to keep the environment debate relatively uncontroversial, so has hived off the motions calling for an end to nuclear power (from the National Union of Mineworkers and some CLPs) into a separate agenda section, Energy.
The centrepiece of the Policy Review is its unambiguous commitment to managing the capitalist market economy instead of replacing it by socialism.
There are three main responses from the left. Militant supporters in Coventry South-East and Liverpool Garston CLPs have submitted their usual motion calling on the next For by phone PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser. Labour government to *nationalise, under workers' democratic control and management, the 200 or so monopolie! which control 85% of the UK economy"
CLPs influenced by the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy have submitted motions which call for renationalisation of the enterprises sold off by the Tories and *taking into public ownership least one top company in each of the major sectors of manufacturing industry and extending public ownership in other key sectors".
Unrepresented in the resolution book, but expounded in a new book (Livingstone's Labour) is the recipe championed by Ken Livingstone and Socialist Action. This proposes a cut in military spending to the average European level, forc ed repatriation of British capital invested abroad and repeal of Tory tax cuts for the rich, in order to give new Labour government resources to invest.
The proposal for forced "everything must go" sale of all British capitalist property abroad is weird. Should all other national labour movements propose the same? Should socialists really be arguing for "capitalism in one country" and redivision of the world into national siege economies?
And if we're talking about a programme for a workers' government in Britain, would it not hand over British capitalists' property abroad to the workers there, rather than selling it off to the highest bidder?
The left motions on the agenda, however, should be supported. Their shortcoming is their lack of international perspective and their view of "economic policy" as solely blueprints for the next Labour government rather than a programme of struggle for workers now.
The left has still not rallied round an adequate response to the rapid internationalisation of capital. One index of this is that too few CLPs have submitted motions or amendments on the European Economic Community to get it onto the agenda.
The agenda is weak on interT national issues generally.
Five CLPs have submitted amendments on the Middle East, making it likely that this issue will get to conference floor.
The major motions in that section call for recognition of the PLO as representatives of the Palestinian people and 'the right of all states in the region, including an independent Palestinian state and the state of Israel, to existence". They should be supported.
However, there is only one motion on China, and none on Eastern Europe. Think what the response would have been if the Tiananmen Square massacre had happened in South Africa or Chile!
Not many people on the left would be willing to side boldly with the ruling bureaucrats in China any longer. But vaguer hesitations and half-thoughts still prevail about the state-monopoly systems somehow being some, admittedly unsatisfactory, form of socialism.
Fringe meetings organised by the Chinese Solidarity Campaign and Labour Focus on Eastern Europe will allow socialist oppositionists from China and Poland to put their views.
There are only five motions and one amendment on Ireland, so it is unlikely that Ireland will reach the conference floor.
Unilateralism will be the second-biggest debate after environment, if you count by number of motions submitted. This debate will be a sharp, clear confrontation between the Policy Review T which abandons unilateralism, and CLPs reattirming unilateralism.
The supposed good reason for abandoning unilateralism is the progress in superpower negotiations. But the conclusion does not follow at all!
The negotiations have still left 90 per cent of nuclear weapons intact. They have not removed the threat of civilisation being wiped out; they have just eased the strain on the budgets of the US and the USSR of maintaining that threat.
Unilateral nuclear disarmament by Britain would be the best possible boost to further progress in the negotiations. And in any case, socialists cannot want to "defend" Britain with the threat to wipe out hundreds of millions of working class people in Eastern Europe and Nuclear weapons are no defence. They should be scrapped. The warmongers should be disarmed.
Unfortunately the pattern of union conferences this year makes it almost certain that Kinnock will get his way in Brighton. But the fight won't stop there.
Proportional representation big debate at conference.
Some 37 CLPs, not all right wing by any means, submitted motions favouring a changed voting system. There will probably be a composite calling for Labour to examine alternatives to "first past the post"
It should be supported. "First past the post" is an arbitrary and undemocratic system, making many individuals' votes valueless.
But we should be wary of the fight-wingers and followers of Marxism Today who want to use proportional representation as a stepping stone to a coalition or alliance with the Democrats. They are quiet now, as well they might be with the Democrats in deep doldrums; but they • Poll tax: motions and amendments from Glasgow Govan, Bow and Poplar, and Norwood CLPs call for a mass campaign on the theme 'Don't pay, don't collect'. Several other motions call for mass non-paymant but omit the call for Labour councils and trade unions to refuse cooperation with the poll tax.
• Women's rap:333ntation: motions backed by the Labour Women's Action Committee call for a 40% women quota on the National Executive and among elected Labour representatives. An amendment from the GMB seeks to take the teeth out of these motions by reducing them to vague good intentions.
• Health: the health union CoHSE has a resolution, amende by NUPE, and there are 24 other motions. But will the Labour leaders give clear support to the ambulance workers?
• Education: a motion from Derby South calls not only for ac tion by the next Labour government, but a Labour Party campaign now.
• Transport: this section of the agenda has a motion from the TGWU which includes the call for the next Labour governmant to restore the National Dock Labour Scheme. week in order to enable our staff to active around the Labour Party
----- pull-quotes -----
P - or constitutional reform in general - will be another
Next week Socialist Organiser will miss a
conference in Brighton. No.418 appear on 11 Oct