Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Policy Review offers little for women

Socialist Organiser no. 416, 21 September 1989 · scan pp. 15–16 · about 621 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

Even right-wingers and sell-out merchants feel the need for a radical fig-leaf to hide behind from time to time.

Neil Kinnock and his pals on the Policy Review team are no exception. Having ditched unilateralism, nationalisation, and virtually every other half-way decent policy in the name of modernising the party, they've cast around for a 'modern' issue to use as a radical sop - and, surprise, surprise, it's women who again are going to be used in an attempt to bring a rosy glow to the insipid pages of the Policy Review.

Actually reading the thing, though, shows precious little in terms of real commitments to women. In fact, there are two concrete commitments - to full-time rights for part-time workers, and to abolishing tax on workplace nurseries.

The rest of the document is given over to vague meanderings on the effects of the much-publicised *skills shortage' on women's employment opportunities.

Employers, so the argument goes, will increasingly need women workers to make up for the shortage of school-leavers. Thus employers will have to adapt to and court women workers - by providing childcare, decent maternity rights, and skills training. Women will enter into previously male-dominated jobs and, hey presto, all will be much improved for women.

Such faith in the rationality and benevolence of employers is touching, if rather misguided in the face of existing facts. Economists working for big business have known about the looming skills shortage for some time, and whilst employers have acknowledged that they will need women workers all surveys show that beyond one or two cosmetic measures they have done absolutely nothing to adapt.

If women are to be trained in new skills it is more than likely that the bosses will want the state to do it for them, rather than to splash out themselves. And a rudimentary knowledge of the history of women's employment would show that the overwhelming tendency is for jobs which become open to women to become reduced in status and earnings.

Good intentions and a semimystical reliance on the beneficial effect of demographic change are just not good enough. A decent programme for women would compromise: expanded training opportunities (at trade union pay with positive discrimination); expanded parental leave; universal public provision of childcare; real legal and financial independence.

But then these are no soft option — a Labour leadership would have to be committed to fight for these, and to legislate for them - and that's the last thing on Kinnock's mind.

• Feminism — or the right wingers" version of it at any rate — is also being used as a smokescreen to hide attempts to further stamp out democracy in the The GMB have submitted a proposal which calls for a "reformed and expanded NEC" which would be, so they say, more representative of women and ethnic minorities. Sounds good, doesn't it? Only this proposal also means less of a role for CLPs and more for the NEC, and an American-style showpiece conference which won't determine Party policy as at present.

It's the same with the much-vaunted "quotas" idea, whereby Party leaders applaud the idea that 40% of party posts should be held by women. The hollowness of their words is shown by the fact that they refuse to allow women to elect their own representatives on the NEC in the way that all other sections of the party do. Any extra seats on the "reformed" NEC reserved for women will go to those who Kinnock and co. deem "acceptable" — the witch-hunters and those who think that the Policy Reviews are wonderful.

So it is in our interests to fight such attempts at destroying party democracy, and expose this abuse of "feminism".

Scan page 16

NO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 416

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →