Frank Field's Inquisition for single mothers
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
apts to define a strict moral and maintains a view of le sexuality as being soft, intic and clean. omen writers have begun to expent with sexuality in their Is. Women in their books are eated but the reader (female) is id on. The point these novels ; is double-edged; on the one fantasy exists separate from y — we don't want to be abusbut can experience pleasure igh the fantasy of pain. On the hand, these books leave a g of emptiness and exploitaand the author has made her not involve penaeries sexuality non-alienated sexuality vould not draw solid conclufrom any of this. Angela r claims that the only reason graphers are the enemies of en is that we cannot perceive ge. Surely a pornography of an and non-alienated sexuality feminists ibivards theism enta CASES d be welcomed. repeat that pornography is y offensive and obsessed with r. However, images reflect en's position in society and do create it. Pornography is not al to women's oppression and paigns aimed at legislation are ly misguided; they risk too i in order to achieve too little. me feminists believe poraphy's obsession with power is netimes designed to reassure and allay fears of impotence. re it is violent it displays fear loathing, not only of women Iso of male passivity...much of sexuality is joyless and comve, plagued by the perforce principle, shadowed by -seated fears of impotence, inuacy and failure. elieve this is a much more ade• response to pornography the response of mainstream nism, which positions women ctims, always at the mercy of lust; passive recipients in life hat men consume in fantasy. ideas do not fit into our view omen as part of the working being fighters for a free, list and liberated society Witch-hunter extraordinaire and arch right-winger Frank Field MP has come up with his own distinctive solution to the discussion about single mothers and state benefits.
Single mothers, he argues, should be forced to disclose the names of their children's fathers to the DSS. The DSS would then chase up these errant dads and force them to pay up maintenance for the fruit of their loins.
Mothers refusing to name names would lose benefit. Even fathers themselves claiming benefit would have an amount stopped at source.
Field's rationale is that the family is breaking down, and that men should be forced to *behave reactively dis anaged rom sin be parenthood.
Apart from the introduction of punitive DSS rules, Field also suggests that single mothers who have learnt the errors of their ways should be sent to schools to warn other girls off following in their footsteps by dint of their own pitiful example.
Field's brainwave is in essence pretty similar to ideas the Tories have been mooting for some months — except they go further in proposing to cut off benefit from women who refuse to comply.
Field reckons his proposals will help reduce poverty. Really? Has it not occurred to him that poverty amongst single parents may be better alleviated by increasing child benefit, and by the provision of nursery places for all under-5s, so that single mothers can go to work?
Of course, this would require a commitment to spend money — not an appealing prospect for Field.
Many of us who are single parents have positively chosen not to involve the donors of the necessary sperm in our lives, or the lives of our children. Many of us do not want to be in the humiliating position of being financially beholden to men with whom we no longer have relationships. Mr Field presumably considers this wilful and irresponsible - women consider it dignified and independent.
However, we do not choose to be dependent on inadequate state benefits — we want to be able to work. At the moment government policies make this well nigh impossible. Frank Field offers us no better.
Field is what is euphemistically termed a political "maverick' — to you or I a rent-a-quote unashamed right-winger. His comments could be written off as the idiosyncratic ravings of a demented dinosaur. Except Field is the Chair of the Commons Social Services Committee. We should be able to expect better from Labour's representatives on such committees.!
Even worse, so far the Labour Party has issued no statement distancing itself from Field's wellpublicised proposals. What are they playing at? I and tens of thousands of other single mothers would like to know.
This is the most recent in a long line of right-wing and anti-working class pronouncements from the Labour member for Birkenhead. It is to be hoped that Labour Party members will now say 'enough is enough and deselect the reactionary old bastard before he does any more damage.