The feminist case against censoring pornography Strangers
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Would banning pornography be a powerful blow agai the roots of sexism and male violence against women? Or would it play into the hands of bigots, censors and puritansi Ruth Cockroft argues that a ban on pornography would risk too much to achieve too little Feminists are once again discussing the issue of pornography. On 25 November the Campaign Against Pornography (CAP) is holding a 'Women on Porn' conference. This event promises to be lively, if not positively acrimonious.
There has also been the recent launch of a new anti-pornography group called Campaign Against Pornography and Censorship, which has the backing of the National Council for Civil Liberties. Clare Short MP has pioneered the campaign for an end to Page 3, accompanied at every stop of the way by the acclaim and support of many thousands of women.
Surely all this must be a step forward - at least an attempt to deal with the more insidious side of sexist society? I think not.
Pornography has become a pivotal issue around which many feminists have campaigned - the reason being that contemporary feminism is not moulded and guided by socialist women but, on the contrary, by cultural feminists, most notably Andrea Dworkin. We aim to build a mass campaign of action against the major attacks being mounted on women's rights, such as the right to control our own fertility. the right to health and childcare facilities, the right to work, the right to live in this country with the partner of our choice, the right to maternity leave and job security for mothers, SUBSCRIBE Get Women's Fighttack delivered to door by post. Rates: £2.50 for 12 issues, €1.50 for six.
Name.
Address.
ease send me 6/12 m subscripion. I enclose E.
to Women's hightet London SE15 4NA Dworkin made her name as a brilliant, controversial figure after writing "Pornography - men possessing women'. In a speech in 1978 she starkly summarised her whole case against pornography when she stated:
i..sex and murder are fused in the male consciousness so that the one without the imminent possibility of the other is unthinkable and impossible," and said: "This propaganda [pornography] does not only sanction violence against women, it incites it. This propaganda does not only threaten assault, it promises it."
Clearly, if one holds such views it is easy to justify censorship. It is easy to reduce the complexities of human desire to the predatory nature of men. It also serves the argument that pornography is a tool of ideological oppression of women, it theorises and justifies rape, it teaches rape, it is at the root of all women's social inequality.
Not all feminists care for such extreme and intransigent arguments. Most socialist feminists criticise Dworkin for suggesting male sexuality is biologically determined and that men are inherent rapists. However, most of us who have been involved within fragments of the women's movement have been influenced by what cultural feminists have to say about pornography. In many situations we have not had the courage to speak up for a more liberal attitude to pornography, and a more sophisticated understanding of what it represents.
Let me state quite categorically that I believe most hetrosexual pornography is a gross and distorted representation of sexuality. Most of it represents pure misogyny and all of society's barbarity spewed up in a single image - not only is pornography sexist, it is also racist and obsessed with power.
So why not accept the need to ban porn, as so many other women do? Why have only a few lone voices been left to defend the inthe right to wages, benefits and legal status indapandant of a man, the right to organise as trade unionists and as These rights and many others. many not yet won or consolidated, must be defended and extended in the face of the onslaught against women by this government.
Such a mass campaign has to be part of a labour movemant response to the Tory attacks. We aim to provide a focus for united action by women already organisad in the labour movamant and in campaigns and groups of the women's moveInside:
women's movement MUS searching for lose in a world hound for doom!
- 2.50 Poe aric defensible and argue against censorship and for a liberal attitude in the sphere of sexual images?
Firstly, we're not in favour of the state defining sexuality and imposing limits on sexual 'norms' (with the exception of paedophilia and incest). We're not in favour of the state using anti-pornography legislation to prosecute lesbians and gay men and censor what they read. I would also add that it is not in the interests of women to see sex sentimentalised or 'cleaned up' and made less 'dirty', The natural allies of feminists who have attempted to make laws ment, and to involve women who not relate to these movements.
We aim to strangthan the position of women in the labour movement, and fight for it to take our needs as a priority. We will encourage and aid the organisation and consciousness of women as women in the labour movement, and fight for the aims and demands of the women's movement in the unions and labour organisations.
We fight to change the sexist atmosphere in the labour movement. and for positive discrimination and changes in arrangements and practices to enable women to play a full part at all levels.
We fight against the labour movement's reflecting in any wy the oppressive ideas about a woman's role, which can undermine women's ability to fight back, and dangerously divide the movement. We ally with all those fighting for rank and file controi, democracy and accountabiity. against those who hold back and sell out our fight. Never again a 'Labour" government that ighores party decisions, serves the bosses and bankers, and beats down workers' living standards and struggles.
We aim to co-ordinate and assist those women in the Labour Party, and the trade unions, who are fighting for these aims.
We are for direct action, solidarity as women and as workers, and for -flies for all actions gainst the capitalist system that exarts and us.
Mills & Boon against, pornography_ (such as Dworkin and McKinnon In America) have been the right-wing and religious fundamentalists. Any socialist woman intent on a campaign against pornography must accept the fact that the issue attracts our enemies — the very same people whom the American feminists are in a vicious fight with in order to save abortion rights. Hopefully this point illustrates the problem of developing a socialist response to pornography.
The Campaign Against Pornography and Censorship has attempted to avoid the issue of censorship by campaigning for a law equivalent to the Race Relations Act, which makes it illegal to incite racial hatred. This particular campaign obviously would give a lot of power to the courts to define what is suitable erotica on the basis of very flimsy evidence, ie. that there is a causal relationship between pornography and rape inconclusive evidence shows an relationship between pornography and rape and in my mind is too causal and simplistic. It's like saying smoking dope gets you hooked on crack.
Even more worrying about the CAPC is that it sees racial oppres sion and sexual oppression as the same. We are for free speech except in the most extreme of circumstances. These circumstances are when oppressed minorities are at risk from a direct, politicallymotivated act of hatred, whether a speech or organised violence. Even then we should recognise, along with militant sections of the black community, that the law is feeble in preventing such attacks, and only the mobilisation of whole communities, of the labour movement, is an adequate defence.
Placed in this context, we can really begin to see how socialist feminists have become ensnared by Dworkin's fundamental argument: is pornography as malicious as fascist propaganda? Do men who look at pornography deserve the same treatment as organised racists? Is the porn empire built by men whose political motivation is the same as a conscious racist's? Is pornography an issue around which we would mobilise the whole labour Romance SHADOW DANCE Margaret Way The shift 1 from sentim to a less roi manticised women is p trocressive movement to fight to its last breath as if a matter of life and death were at stake as we would in a fight against fascism? Clearly not.
Pornography is different to racist literature in another important respect. The reason why, I think, is obvious but uncomfortable for feminists to face. Pornography does not only appeal to men, it also appeals to those it denigrates and abuses.
where women are taught to be subservient and even to fear their own bodies, a desire for erotic domination, a turn on by images of passivity, of subordination should not be surprising to us. Of course, we could be pious and simply proclaim it is not in the interests of women to be turned on, which is the same as pretending the problem doesn't exist.
More controversial still is the hard fact that the pornography industry has changed. A few American women run vast porn industries, while the business itself has diversified and an expanding market has developed with a specifically female clientele.
This market not only includes women who buy videos and magazines for husbands and boyfriends, but women who buy pornography for themselves. Ann Summers parties are booming, and women-only visits to male stripshows are extremely popular.
This marks a shift away from the soft-focus porn of Mills and Boon which has dominated the female inarket. Althougn a cultural feminist response would just label these women consumers as collaborators and outsiders to the feminist project, we have to look at the contradictions of what's going on.
The shift from sentimental porn to a less romanticised porn for women is, in my opinion, progressive. In addition, many lesbians have begun experimenting with ideas of erotic submission and domination, with sado-masochism and with lesbian pornography. There is an objection that this kind of pornography reproduces heterosexist sexuality in| lesbian relationships and that lesbians
Scan page 15
NN Tof Poet I porn for Id know better. I find chis ment particularly offensive; it TV Belinda Weaver wri about the TV series "thirtysomething"
If 'Dynasty' brought glitz and glamour back into fashion, and taught an insecure nouveau riche American middle class how to dress and entertain (if you've got it, flaunt it), 'thirtysomething' is no less a primer for the baby boomer generation (if you've got it, agonise over Mike and Hope, Elliott and Nancy, Gary, Ellen and Melissa all spend a lot of time worrying -about success, about their friends, about careers, relationships, and about their kids. They probably worry about their kids more than anything else.
It's not that the kids are bad. No, the kids are great. But are the parents great? Are they playing their role properly? Are they holding the fine line between fulfilling themselves and doing the right thing by their kids? Week in, week out, this is what the thirtysomethings agonise over.
When they're not worrying about their kids, other anxieties spring up. Friendships, careers, dreams and desires are all grist to the breastbeating mill.
I like the show. I'm addicted. I'm thirtysomething myself, so that may explain a lot. However, it does have its good points.
1. It's not glamorous. People do housework and mostly slop around in old sweatshirts and tracksuit pants. You don't have to feel embarrassed about your own appearance when you watch it!
2. The people aren't shamingly successful. They go bankrupt, and skip their regular jog, and yell at their kids (yes, the kids again) and often act so badly that all their friends have to get together and agonise over it all.
3. The women characters are generally stronger than the men. Nancy is developing her skills as an illustrator, and is coping pretty well with single motherhood, Hope is an earth mother and dispenser of wisdom to all, Melissa is carving out a successful career as a photographer (though she agonises a lot over whether success is OK).
The guys on the other hand are a bit wimpish - Mike tells Hope at least once an episode, "You're my life", , Elliott is a big baby, and Gary is a bit of a moral coward, though cute in a sixties throwback kind of way.
4. The men are expected to be real fathers - not absentee ones, not just breadwinners, but equal partners in child rearing. If they don't measure up, they agonise over it, and peer group pressure generally ensures they keep up to the mark. No 'thirtysomething' father could buy gender-stereotypical toys and expect to get away with it.
All problems, whether bleeding ulcers, inadequate parenting, or writer's block, are resolved within the fifty-minute time slot. Mike and Hope - worrying together That's a big part of the appeal; there's no cliffhanger ending to torment you till the next dose.
6. The characters are trying their hardest. Rather than just copy their parents, or react blindly against them, they want to carve out new ways of relating to their partners, their friends and their children. They try to change, try to be better, try to contront themselves and their inadequacies. They're role models for a generation disoriented by the junking of Sixties idealism in Reagan's America.
But are they good role models? I think not. Ignoring the world, turning inward, is no answer to life's complexities. There's more to life than marriage, childrearing and friendship, however important these things may be. The world of work is ignored in thirtysomething'; work only intrudes when it affects the families, as Michael and Elliott's bankruptcy does. In its retreat from a too confusing world into the sanctum of home, the show gets a little claustrophobic.
Maybe we'd all be happy if we were too-good-to-be-true-Hope, living in a warm, supportive community, where even terrible things aren't terrible for more than fifty minutes.
But we don't.. The world, however much the thirtysomethings try to ignore it, is out there, and it can't be avoided. Sure, you call escape it now and again by watching shows like this. Just don't make the mistake of thinking they're real.
----- pull-quotes -----
Where stand
WOMEN'S FIGHTBACK A new kind of
WE WON'T PAY THE POLL TAX! ENO ON T COLLECT LAB
Images and fantasy are not the same as reality, and in a society