Just not funny
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
TV Gavin Millar, director, set C - out in last Friday night's 'Omnibus' screening programme called "Rape...That's Entertainment?' — to discover if it's possible to honestly represent the act of rape without exploiting it for general titillation.
Or, at least, to show it like it really is..as he explained, you can't hope to cut out the thrill for the mercifully few people who genuinely like to see realistic violence done to real people.
Apparently rape poses a moral dilemma for film-makers because, in one act, sex and violence are combined and both are highly saleable.
In some films, like "The Accused' for example, a rape is central to the plot and, I suppose, the director ought to include it in their film. So how do filmmakers avoid the commercial strains on their artistic integrity?
How can they resist the temptation of getting box office value for money by bathing every bit of naked flesh In orange lighting, and thus making sex through violence "sexy"?
'Rape...That's Entertainment?" explored several filming techniques which can make the difference to how a rape scene is perceived.
To do this effectively, researcher Jane Mills commissioned Gavin Millar make two versions of a rape scene, using the same script, setting and actors. The aim was to use various tricks of the trade to produce, on the one hand, as far as possible, cinema verité, on the other, a "French", or eroticised, portrayal of rape.
The programme also briefly reviewed a number of films having rape scenes. gramme was a brave and intelligent study of a subject TV companies usually leave alone, and about which debate rages.
Jane Mills, who made the programme as part of her wider investigation into rape in films, made it not to prove a fixed theory but to explore some halfthought-out ideas.
That on the whole film-makers portray rape dishonestly was certainly proved..and also that they could do it another way. The reasons why they don't were discussed in interviews with people working in the film industry or in research into some of its shadowier aspects.
It is not through pure ignorance that film-makers seem to subscribe to some or all of the rape myths which abound Michael Winner, "Winner, liho has made the. that ete mindless 'Deathwish' films containing rape scenes, comfortably admitted that he includes them because his backers think that they help to sell his films.
I said earlier that rape is sometimes central to a film's plot and is therefore bound to be shown. In the case of Michael Winner's films, rapes are pure. Yu incidental and just all to the tearaway The programme touched on the vexed question of whether watching films which glamorise rape can make some men commit the crime. No it doesn't, the programme seemed to say, but it included interviews with researchers into "desensitisation" which can follow from watching lots of sexually violent films. This would certainly help to explain men's general complacency about rape myths, whilst most wouldn't go out and themselves rape.
The programme described the hypocrisy which currently 'X' rates a ex film, and yet allows 15 year olds t see a woman "penetrated' not by a naked penis, whether forcibly or by her own consent, but by a knife or a chainsaw blade.
The programme left plenty of scope for further thought and study, and, as I've said, some of Jane Mills' ideas can only be guessed at. One conclusion you were bound to draw was that rape honestly depicted isn't entertainment, and that the sooner the playboy direc tors who dress it up for titillation are ousted by responsible film-makers the better.| It also left me thinking, although I don't know if Jane Mills would, that while the only sex you are likely to see in most films is some vigilante grappling a woman out of her skirt on the way to blow away his arch adversary, rape myths will remain difficult to explode.