Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[SCIENICE California, history is in the making. The…]

Socialist Organiser no. 416, 21 September 1989 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,221 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

SCIENICE California, history is in the making. The genetic engineering firm, Calgere, has 'constructed' a new strain of tomato and is now seeking permission from the US Food and Drug Administration to release it into the market. straight on sale. If the FDA decides it is an entirely new plant, release will be delayed until a whole set of regulations have been obeyed.

Is the engineered tomato a tomato? All Calgere have done is to inactivate a gene that causes tomatoes to go mushy as they ripen.

Doing this to the gene is of no benefit to the tomato plant. It has presumably evolved its sottening behaviour to help it spread its seeds, perhaps by making it more attractive to animals or birds. Alternatively, perhaps it allows the fruit to rot faster so that the seeds can germinate sooner.

Neither is the change of benefit to consumers. Such a tomato will no doubt have the same content of sugars, vitamins and minerals. But neither is it likely to cause them any harm.

It will benefit the growers since their products will have a longer shelf-life, holding their value for longer.

Some objectors see the genetic engineering of a plant, even in such a small way, as a dangerous step. In reality, the Calgere process mimics a natural one. Mutations to an organism's DNA occur all the time at random.

Some mutations inactivate entire genes. In a wild tomato, most mutations of this type would most likely make it less able to survive and pass on its genes. on its genes. plants as possess a character useful to them - fatter ears of wheat, sweeter apples, fancy-coloured flowers, etc. Many domesticated varieties of plant would find it very difficult to survive without human protection.

Calgere's innovation has been to cause a desired mutation, rather than just waiting hopefully for it to occur by chance. If we find that objectionable, we ought also to reject the methods of agriculture itself and • return to the gathering and hunting lifestyle of our forebears.

Chemicals company Monsanto have taken genetic engineering a step further with their (insect-) killer tomato. There is a bacterium, Bacillus thuringiensis (B.t), which produced a toxin that kills insects. Indeed, a spray of B.t. is available as an insecticide.

Monsanto have taken the gene that codes for the toxin in the bacterium and inserted it into the DNA of a tomato plant. That plant's offspring should all have the ability to kill insects that attack them.

Objectors are even more hostile to this step, mixing genes not just from different species, but from completely different types of organism (thus offending doubly against the 'natural order').

But if the toxin is harmless to humans and other animals, such as birds, that might eat the tomatoes, what is the objection? If it works, it will only affect insects which attack the plants. Other possibly beneficial insects will be unaffected, not the case with ordinary insecticide sprays.

The idea of a killer tomato is not so outlandish as all that. Many plants produce insect-killing chemicals and the nightshades (deadly and woody), relatives of the tomato, produce chemicals which poison humans. True, putting a bacterial gene into a tomato is probably not a naturally-occurring phenomenon but certain plant viruses do something similar.

The whipping-up of tears about genetic engineering has led to the repeated destruction in California of beds of that dangerous plant, the strawberry. The plants had been treated with an altered version of a bacterium naturally found on the surface of strawberries. The natural bacterium damages the plants by encouraging the formation of ice crystals during cold snaps. The altered, 'ice-minus' bacterium doesn't, with the hoped-for effect of preventing frost damage. It is difficult to see what threat the release of this bacterium could pose.

It is possible to imagine genetic engineering experiments that might produce harmful results. But campaigns for a blanket prohibition seem based more on fear, ignorance or an inaccurate idea of what is "natural'. It is surely more sensible to look at each case on its merits.

Scan page 11

By Sleeper ahis year's TUC conference was a subdued affair: no big left vs right showdowns, expulsions, everyone on their best behaviour.

The union bureaucrats of both "left" and "right" bent over backwards to avoid controversy, play down differences and - most important of all -present an image of "responsible" and "forward looking" minor statesperSOnS.

The explanation for this is not hard to fathom: for the first time in a long while the TUC top brass feel things are beginning to go their way; the Tories are trailing in the opinion polls, Neil Kinnock has finally achieved some degree of tage of the total workforce). When this is taken into consideration, things look far less desperate than the absolute figures would suggest: density (including the umemployed) in 1979 was 58%; in 1985 it was 51%. According to the goverment's Employment Gazette density amongst part-timers actually increased from 27 to 29% between 1983/4 and 1985/6. And remember, official figures presently available only take us up to the end of 1987 — exactly the point at which the present revival in union strength began.

In other words, the overwhelming explanation for the decline in union membership has been, quite simply, unemployment. That's not to say that there aren't serious problems facing the movement and it is certainly no excuse for complacency. In fact many of the ideas contained in Organising for the 1990s' are quite sensible, especially the emphasis on organising part-timers, women and youth, and the argument for raising the "collective profile" of trade unionism instead of wasting energy on inter-union recruitment battles.| The section of the document dealing with the reasons why many non-union workers stay outside of the movement, is particularly interesting: "Often, especially in workplaces with no union recognition, workers are unconvinced unions can achieve anything; in other places, workers are reluctant to join for fear of the reaction of their employer and in some cases they may not even have been asked to join."* In the exhibition space outside the TUC Congress at Blackpool, a company called Tips which sells computer software to the NUM, CPSA and AEU had a stall. Tips is non-union. According to the Independent, its sales manager, one Phil Dye, issued this challenge: "We don't have any union members on the payroll, and they've never been approached. Perhaps we ought to be identified as a possible target."

Civil servants across Britain are fighting back over staffing levels and pay.

Strikes in the Department of Employ ment (DE) - Unemployment Benefit Offices (UBOs) and Jobcentres - have been organised by workers in the Civil and Public Services Association The disputes have bubbled up during the summer. Three offices are on all-out indefinite strike — in Glasgow, Coventry and Wolverhampton.

60 offices in Scotland came out for the day on 31 August, and a number struck for two days over the following weeks. 40 London offices came out for a day in August and Shepherd's Bush Jobcentre came out for a week. 40 offices across the Midlands have taken solidarity action. Aston UBO has written to their Section Executive demanding support for all-out action. The strikes are mainly about staffing. DE bosses have delayed increases in

----- pull-quotes -----

ndays service s on jok fight

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 416

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →