A moving story of struggle
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Ray Ferris reviews "My Left Foot' was going call it...
reminiscences a mental defective."
"Christy, that's that's a terrible thing."
"It was my blue period."
"My Left Foot' tells the remarkable story of Christy Brown. He was born severely handicapped by cerebral palsy, and his mother was told he would be little more than a vegetable — if he survived at all. Yet Christy was to become a celebrated painter, writer, and poet. "My Left Foot' was his autobiography Christy was born into a poor working class Catholic family in Dublin. "There were nine children before me and twelve after me. Of this total of twenty two, thirteen lived."
The privations of this childhood are idealised in the film as everyone mucking in together. And there is something artificial about the readiness of local children to accept Christy without a struggle. Children can be cruel and ruthless about poking fun.
In the film, the contempt directed at Christy comes mainly from adults, including his father, who call him moron, cripple, dunce...and it is Christy himself who is revolted when confronted with his condition at a local hospital.
Christy's mind was trapped inside a body he would not control -apart from his left foot. This was to become the conduit through which the would express himself to the outside world and his early efforts to do so are indeed moving.
He alerts a neighbour after his mother collapses and falls down the stairs. He desperately scratches the outline 'Mother' on the floor in chalk. Soon he would start paintingDaniel Day Lewis as Christy Brown There are three main women in the film — and in Christy's life. He loved all three of them.
His mother loved him too, from birth. Dr Eileen Cole specialised in cerebral palsy and arranged therapy for Christy. She introduced him to Shakespeare, arranged the first exhibition of his paintings and helped him to talk.
His love for Eileen threatened to consume him in a nihilistic rage when she told him she was getting Calgere wants the FDA to agree that the 'super-tomato' is actually a tomato, in which case it can go married. But the intellectually adult Christy struggled with the emotions of an adolescent, and overcame them.
He married Mary Carr at the age of 28. Mary is with him both at the start and finish of the film. She read the first volume of 'My Left Foot" while Christy waits to perform a "benefit' for a local lord who sponsored Eileen's clinic.
The film is cut with scenes of them talking as she breaks her Agriculture and horticulture have often progressed through the selection and protection of such mutated reading and attends to him. It is a powerful device, giving the impression that, by the end of the film, she already knows the "real" Christy Brown. It makes it less contrived when he asks her out and she accepts.
Though the film does intrude on sentimentalism, it is peppered with laughs that relieve the tension.
And the acting by Daniel Day Lewis and Hugh O'Conor (the young Christy) is excellent.