How the free works in the U
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
America's airways were "deregulated" in 1978. All government controls on fares and routi were removed.
Fares did fall. They have risen by about 20% less than general inflation since 1978.
But chaos has boomed. Many scheduled flights cannot possibi take off on time, because sharpl competing airlines schedule mor planes for peak times than airports can possibly handle.
The infrastructure of the airways has been increasingly strained. Airports are heavily over-used. Profit-hungry airlines are using older and older planes. In 1981 America's entire staff of air traffic controllers were sacked when they struck, and replaced by scabs. Safety standards are risk.
Airlines have attacked unions. The fastest-growing airline in the US is Continental, part of Frank Lorenzo's Texas Air empire. Wher Lorenzo took over Continental, he smashed the unions and halved wages.
As for free competition, that is vanishing fast. After a wave of takeovers and mergers, the eight biggest airlines control over 90% of the business, and their control over take-off "slots" at airports will block new competitors.
Airline profits, after a dip in the mid-'80s, are booming. Meanwhile, mass public transport in the US - subways and buses -is in acute decay, the rail network has almost disappeared, and the roads get jammed solid as fast as they can be built.
Scan page 8
Refugees in West Germany telephone friends and relatives back in East Germany 4,000 East Germans have 1 crossed from Hungary to the West in the few weeks that the border with Austria has been open to them.
This has been the first chance East Germans have had to leave en masse since the building of the Berlin Wall in 1961.
Most of these emigrants are not leaving because of political persecution or absolute economic need. Political opponents or absolute economic need. Political opponents of the regime in the "German Democratic Republic' (GDR) are usually the least willing to leave and often the Stalinist regime is only too willing to give them a one-way ticket to the West.
Nor do the emigrants come from the worst-off sections of society. According to an analysis of those arriving at one camp in West Germany, 90% are skilled workers who have served apprenticeships and a further 7% are graduates. They are overwhelmingly young and would probably have had reasonably comfortable lives had they stayed.
As far as one can tell from interviews in the press, their motives include a desire for more access to consumer goods and better job opportunities, and an almost universal rejection of the stifling, ever-present, paternalistic party/state machine in the GDR.
Whatever their motives, the exodus represents a massive rejection of the East German Stalinist regime. If many more people with skills leave, it will begin to have an impact on the GDR economy, which only has a working population of 9 million.
The GDR is both one of the most politically and ideologically rigid states in the Stalinist bloc, and the most prosperous economically. The two go together: while the economies of the Soviet Union, Hungary and Poland had collapsed to such an extent that change was unavoidable, the GDR. has had more economic room for manoeuvre.
A journalist on the SED (East German Communist Party paper Berliner Zeitung makes this clear: *Only thanks to the economic help of the Federal Republic can the GDR leadership stand and say we don't need perestroika because we are so strong economically." (The GDR gains a lot from gifts from the West to its citizens, and transters such as payment for the use of roads to Berlin.)
Shops in the GDR (at least in the big cities — in the countryside there are more shortages) don't have Thursday 21 Scpteat..
Newcastle SO: 'The Alternative he Policy Review'. Moorside chool, 1.30 Saturday 23 Ss8Campaign Group of Labour MPs: ol day seminar - 'Planning for Victory'. Red Rose Club, 129 Seven Sisters Road, N7, 11.30. Conference fee E2, to Jeremy Corbyn, 129 Seven Sisters Road, N7 Sunday 24 5rph-1North London SO: 'Solidarity with China's workers and students'.
Angel & Crown, Upper St, 7.30 Wednesday 27 S-17-t South London SO public meeting:
"Bankers and bureaucrats trap Solidarnosc*. The Two Eagles, Austral St, nr Elephant and Castle, empty shelves or lack very basic necessities, as in Poland. However, what there is is often drab, and people seeking high quality consumer goods have to buy them with foreign currency in special shops.
The GDR does have the industrial base to produce fridges, washing machines, furniture and so on - they flow across the border to the West at little above cost price, ending up in MFI or the West German equivalent.
A comparison of the GDR's standard of living with that of the Federal Republic depends on what indicators one chooses. If you measure incomes against the cheap rents, free services (health and education) and cheap basic foodstuffs in the East, then standards are roughly similar East and West; if you take account of the fact that expensive consumer goods can usually only be obtained in the East as gifts or for foreign currency, a ratio of 3:1 in favour of the Federal Republic is more realistic.
The East's standard of living has stagnated in the 1980s, despite a growth rate last year of around 3%.
The GDR is one of the most ideologically rigid and traditional Stalinist regimes in the Eastern bloc - to the extent that it openly rejects Gorbachev's limited reforms and is now looking towards stronger ties with Rumania and China. The old leadership around Honecker is the last generation to have been handpicked by Stalin, while Hitler was in power.
Many of the Stalinist bureaucracies in Eastern Europe can shift to a more market-oriented and less openly repressive regime while still retaining their privileges and control of the state, but it is not so easy for the East Germans. If it were not for the existence of two different social systems in the parts of Germany occupied Western powers and the Soviet Union after 1945, Germany would not have been divided and the GDR would never have been created. (Stalin originally wanted a united, but neutral capitalist Germany on the lines of Finland or Austria today. But the Cold War aims of the Western allies wrecked that prospect by 1948, since when the GDR has served as a "frontline state' for the Soviet Union.)
Even today the GDR depends on this difference for its raison d'être. A leading SED ideologue recently summed this up: "What reason would a capitalist GDR have for existing alongside a capitalist Federal Republic? None, naturally."
The GDR, unlike the other Eastern Bloc countries, has no history as a national unit, though in recent years the GDR has made increasingly bizarre attempts to link 7.30* Thursday 28S fr Nottingham SO: 'What is socialism?' - International Communit Centre, Mansfield Road, 7.30 Friday 29 Scr Leeds Socialist Organiser and Socialist Outlook debate: "Where is the USSR going?" Leeds Poly Student Union, 7.30 Sunday 1 October North London SO: "Social Democracy goes Thatcherite". & Crown, Upper St, 7.30 Sunday 1 October Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign: "Sandinista Sprint', sponsored run and dance for Nicaragua. Brockwell Park, Brixton, SW9, 11.00. Details from NSC, 23 Bevenden St, London N1 6BH (253 0246)
Sunday 1 October Labour Left Liaison conference fringe meeting: "The Policy Review and the Left' - Speakers include Tony Benn. Corn Exchange, Brighton, 8.00 Sunday 1 October Campaign for Labour Party Democracy pre-conference rally. Speakers include Tony Benn. Co the "Marxist-Leninist' regime to the heritage of German nationalism. First Martin Luther ceased to be a reactionary advocating a bloodbath of the peasants and became a national hero. Then the SED claimed to be the true heir of the Prussian state and the 18th century absolute monarch, Frederick the Great. (There may be some truth in this one...Erich Honecker is not known for his sense of irony!)
The ideologising of everyday life goes all the way through to being assured that waiters in every restaurant are serving you in the spirit of "socialist emulation". . The SED would itself, no doubt, win the "socialist emulation" prize for hollow rhetoric in Eastern Europe.
Despite endless exhortation and being able to deliver at least some of the goods, the regime has still been unable to create a solid base of support outside the ranks of the party itsell. Une complaint or many or those leaving, and oppositionists remaining, is the absence of any opportunity for a real public debate on any issue. The party and state take the best decisions on everyone's behalf, in true paternalistic style, and smother any attempt at participation in decision-making or even discussion. Another is the easy comparison of Germans in the West, available through access to Western TV and radio.
But what really awaits the emigrants in the Federal Republic?
Exchange, Dome complex, Church St/New Rd, Brighton, 10.00 Sunday 1 October CND "Rally for a nuclear-free future! at Labour Party conference. "The Level', Lewes Rd, Brighton, 12.00 Monday 2 October Labour Women's Action Committee conference fringe meeting. The Old Ship Hotel, Brighton, 1.00 Tuesday 3 October Labour Party Black Sections conference fringe meeting. Royal Albion Hotel, Old Steine, Brighton, 12.30 Tuesday 3 October Chinese Solidarity Campaign fringe meeting at Labour Party conference. Speaker: Cheung Siu Ming. Curzon Hotel, Brighton, 6.00 Tuesday 3 October Labour CND conference fringe meeting. Norfolk Resort Hotel, Tuesday 3 October Canterbury SO: 'Socialists and Labour Party'. KJCR III Wedneedey 4 October CLPs Conference fringe meeting at Labour Party conference. Curzon Hotel, 1.00 Wednesday 4 October London Socialist Forum: The Chinese Revolution 40 years Despite the apparent warm welcome, the government has already initiated legislation to exclude East German emigrants from receiving full unemployment benefits. There have also already been stories of employers offering jobs at low wage levels to exploit the emigrants' ignorance of West German law.
A positive sign is that in one camp local trade unionists have been holding meetings and distributing leaflets advising them of their rights.
On the whole the emigrants have skills that are in some demand, though there is already high unemployment among teachers in West Germany and technically trained workers have difficulty matching exactly the skills required for sımilar work.
The massive wave of German refugees from Eastern Europe immealately aner 1943 formcu a major right-wing bloc in West German politics, arguing tor a refusal to recognise the GDR or the borders of Germany after 1945. This is unlikely to be the case now.
Sociologists who have followed the fate of a group of 32,000 refugees from the GDR in 1984 report more ambiguous feelings. After five years only 18% were totally positive about their move and 22% were totally negative, the rest were undecided.
Many found problems with the Speakers: John O'Mahony, Lam Siu Wai and others. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, London WC1, 7.30 Saturday 7 October Socialist Lecturers' Alliance: 'NATFHE 1989 Pay Claim Action Conference'. New Imperial Hotel, Birmingham. Details from Barry Lovejoy. 25 Philip Victor Rd, Birmingham B24 Sunday 8 October Socialist Platform Memorial Meeting for Harry Wicks. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, London WC1, 3.00 Sunday 8 October Canterbury SO day school: 'Workers' Liberty 1989'. Keynes College, University of Kent, room JCRIII, 9.30am Monday 9 October Sheffield SO: 'Stalin's heirs face workers' . SCCAU, 73 West St, 7.30 Wednesday 11 October Cardiff SO: After Labour Party Conference'. The Comet, Moira St, near Cardiff Royal Infirmary, 7.30 Thursday 12 October North London Women for Socialism: 'The future of socialist feminism' Speakers: Martha Osamor, Nadine Finch and others. Red Rose, Seven Sisters Rd, N7, 7.30 individualism, lack of human warmth and having to provide for themselves many things they were used to the state providing. 38% couldn't find jobs relevant to their skills, But the first 14,000, at least, of this wave of refugees will probably find jobs and housing and become integrated fairly quickly into West German society. But if there are a lot more people leaving the GDR, they won't be so lucky. Ethnic Germans from the Soviet Union, many of whom cannot speak German already face severe problems - and 'Os even more so, do the Gastarbeiter from Turkey and Southern Europe.
That so many people take the first opportunity to leave the CDR for good shows that the Stalinist state has nothing to offer, politically or economically, as a socialist alternative to West Germany. Yet in :11 AA 1:64la 4A une long run cavers war au muc to change that society, leaving those remaining more resigned and the political opposition more isolated.
The real result may be to reinforce the systems that exist on both sides of the border, states which have been at the heart of the status quo in Eastern Europe since 1945.
Only a fight for a democratic, working class socialism can provide an alternative to the unemployment and exploitation in the West and the bureaucratic police state nightmare of the East German state.
Saturday 14 October Socialist Movement supporters in the Labour Party meeting. Key Books, 136 Digbeth, Birmingham, 11.30. Contact Davy Jones 01-607 9579 Friday 3 November History Workshop Conference 1989. Salford University. Contact Helen Bowyer, 51 Crescent, Salford M5 4UX (061-736 3601)
Saturday 4 November Fight for the Right to Study! Defend NUS!' Conference organised by Kent Area NUS. PCL, Marylebone Rd, London W1, 11.30. Details: Mark Sandell, Kent Area NUS, 0227 766725Saturday 11 November Socialist Conference 'Building the Left in the Unions' - Sheffield Poly Student Union, Pond St, 10.30. Credentials E6 waged, E4 unwag from Socialist Conference, 9 Pola St, London W1 Friday 17 November Labour Youth conference (three days), Bournemouth Friday 17 November CND annual conference (three da) City University, London EC1. Con tact CND, 22-24 Underwood St, London N1 7JG
----- pull-quotes -----
sOS Notrulmet