Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why transport is a series of disasters

Socialist Organiser no. 416, 21 September 1989 · scan pp. 6–7 · Duncan Chapel · about 1,489 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

6 Nov 2026: headline and by-line checked against the scan of page 6; the standfirst reads 'Duncan Chapel looks at the decaying transport services of Tory Britain'. The text below is still the machine reading.

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

at the decaying transport services Tory Britain ten years as Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher hasn't used public transport.

As she swans around in her Daimler or her Jaguar, people travel to work in conditions that would be illegal for the transport of cattle.

Over the past years, crowded, expensive and dangerous transport has become the rule for working class people. While investment goes into transport for the rich like Intercity or the Channel Tunnel, most people get nothing. Traffic on the roads in London moves slower than it did at the start of the century, and it's getting slower still.

The 'Marchioness' disaster on the Thames is one of many watertransport disasters. And there will be more. Seventeen out of 72 ferries, nearly one in four, failed a standard Department of Transport test for stability earlier this year, but Tories will let them sail until 1992.

On the rail we saw three serious crashes in as many months this year. In the air, there were over 1,200 deaths in civil aviation accidents worldwide in 1988. And it's still the safest way to travel!

But transport which cuts corners on safety is more profitable than safe transport. Crowded transport is more profitable than uncrowded transport. Expensive transport is more profitable than cheap transport. Skimpy public services which drive more people to use private cars make for more profits all round than ample public services which make people less willing to buy cars and petrol.

Fewer workers, with heavier workloads and lower pay, mean more loot for the bosses.

What's good for people is bad for profits. And we live in a society geared to profits.

Not all capitalist states are as blinkered and single-minded about profit-seeking as Tory Britain. The Tories are not only aiming to turn over transport to private profit, they are also dedicated to breaking the power of workers in the transport industries. For them, that the way to rebuild British capitalism.

The waste and the failure of the transport system in Britain today is a direct result of the profit system. One of the biggest trends in transport since the war has been the shift from rail onto the road.

Private cars and private road haulage have been encouraged. The building of the motorways and the over 700% growth in European car production (from under 1.6 million to nearly 11.4 million cars a year) during the '50s and '60s were central to the post-war boom.

But road transport has huge social costs. If people travel by private car rather than public transport, it means extra road congestion, delays, stress for travellers, accidents and pollution.

The individual choosing to go by car doesn't have to weigh up those costs, only the speed and comfort of the car against the cost of petrol. For the Tories' big business backers, more car travel is good news more profits, sumption, more growth.

Today, the Tories make sure the road still rules. They have sold off the national bus and freight businesss, and they plan to get shot of the rest - producing smaller and more 'profitable' (more expensive!) operations.

For most people, that's no good. 39% of households don't have a car. In Scotland, where the Tories are keenest on rail closures, the figure is 49%. We have to sit and suffer while they count the profits in their chauffeur-driven cars or their luxury jets.

Most capitalist governments try to put some elements of order into the chaos of capitalism. The Tory government in Britain has done very little, and it is doing less privatisations, reduced subsidies and the deregulation of local buses.

How are things different elsewhere? Take the cost of public transport in big cities. In Milan, a ticket costs 29% of its true cost. In Paris, 35% - and it is common practice there for employers to pay half or all their workers' transport costs. But in London, a passenger pays 84.5% of the full cost themselves.

French and Italian bosses care about profits just as much as Thatcher. Cheap public transport works for them because it keeps their cities working well.

That would be just as useful in Britain, where congested roads cost us £15 billion a vear. But the Tories don't care. They have taken a firm line against Labour Councils trying to improve transport.

Ken Livingstone's Greater London Council crumbled when the courts ruled against its 'fares fair" policy. Now peaktime rail arrivals in London break records - over 468,000 a day - and the system is giving way under the strain. But the government insists that BR can only invest where it can get an 8% return.

Outside London, many Labour Councils are turning to light rail systems like the Tyneside Metro to ease the load. Construction work on Manchester's system is expected to start next month. The system was planned to cost only £85 million, compared to £156 million for a conventional rail system. Light rail 'trams' can move 260 passengers cleanly and safely, producing no diesel fumes.

There are many other ways that transport could be improved, and with it the cities we live in: cheaper or free public transport; more investment in public transport; building car-free areas into the hearts of our towns and cities (as in some West German cities); ending the subsidies on company cars; developing dial-a-ride services, and so on. Of course the Tories and the Labour leadership will say that the money is not there, They are short-sighted Transport is now responsible for 13% of the gases which cause the greenhouse effect'! Public transport uses less energy, it takes up less land, it gives different groups of transport users better access.

In Britain, plans to improve transport are stifled by lack of government support. In the rest of Europe taxes are raised to pay for transport. In France it is raised by a 'payroll tax' on employers in the area. In Germany, money comes from taxing petrol heavily. We ought to think about those alternatives. For the Tories, however, investing in public transport is a waste.

The Tories are wasting not only time and resources, but also lives.

In March the Transport Minister, Michael Portillo, authorised 17 unsafe ferries to go on sailing.

When the London Underground was extended to Heathrow Airport, the Department of Transport's railway inspectorate tried to stop London fire officers enforcing safety measures on platforms and subways - despite warnings that escape facilities were inadequate. Their reason? That the warnings came "at a time of very considerable financial restrictions"' The Tories refuse to put up the cash to make transport safe.

The lack of safety is even clearer with private transport — not just in badly maintained equipment, but also overstretched workers. In the air, for instance, while ageing planes creak and delays increase, more and more pilots are frequently Platom Time Ca too tired to carry out their job safely.

Cumulative pilot fatigue, building up after a series of night flights, is the greatest single risk in air travel today. Pilots are made to work all the hours that can be squeezed out. Day and night work are mixed with no regular shift pattern. That can lead to acute fatigue.

What the air companies can't pound out of the crew, they pound out of the planes. Older planes are kept in the air for longer. Frequent inspections don't show up the hairline cracks that often lead to planes failing or falling apart in mid-air.

On average, planes in the Pan Am fleet are 64% older than in the recently privatised British Airways fleet. TWA planes are 52% older. That leads to more risks and more mistakes merely because profit comes first.!

Socialists should demand adequate cleaning, maintenance and checking of all transport. We need decent independent safety inspec tors - who don't spend their time covering up mistakes as we've seen the Department of Transpor bureaucrats do.

We have to raise the arguments for the workers to control and in. spect what goes on, to make sure it is safe and that corners aren't being cut.

To stop the job cuts and the massive overtime, we should fight for a sliding scale of hours. That means instead of overtime, the bosses take on new workers with permanent jobs. If the bosses have some problem and they want to cut down the work they should pay, not us. They should cut the working week with no loss of pay or jobs.

A socialist transport policy would change the way things worked. We would aim to develop rail and buses, community transport services, and improve things for pedestrians and cyclists. But more than that, we'd put the ability to choose where they go and how they go into hands of ordinary people, not the bosses and bankers.

Scan page 7

IRELAND 7

----- pull-quotes -----

930) In Stie Platfona Time te ILED Calmerin ALk

Calling at Rayan Patter Caling al Photo: Stefano Cagnoni, Report

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 416

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →