Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Profit is a jealous god

Socialist Organiser no. 416, 21 September 1989 · scan p. 3 · about 527 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

tion and Socialist Outlook hailed them as great revolutionary communists, unfortunately a bit bureaucratic and 'empirical in their methods. More critical voices on the left (like Workers' Fight, published by some of those today involved in Socialist Organiser) warned that the Khmer Rouge would establish a Stalinist regime, hostile to those fighting for But the criticism was only a footnote to support for the Khmer Rouge against the US-backed regime. None of our criticism went anywhere serious towards anticipating the horrors to come.

The same day that the Khmer Rouge took control of Phnom Penh, they started driving all three million of its inhabitants on forced marches into the countryside. The sick and weak died on the way.

intellectual government officials, of any sort, were singled out to be killed.

The rest were herded into labour camps, organised into a sort of The Labour Party leaders have got themselves into a mess again.

Neil Kinnock has been anxiously reassuring shareholders in British Telecom and other privatised companies that they will continue to get dividends under a Labour government.

He was scurrying to give the reassurance because the media had interpreted an earlier statement by Bryan Gould as meaning that dividends would not be paid. Gould had said that public utilities should be managed according to the public interest, not profit-making.

Gould is certainly right, but then Kinnock is wrong in his attempt to propose a compromise between profit-making and the public interest.

If a Labour government leaves the bulk of shares in British Telecom, gas, electricity, water and so lon in private hands, then it will face a brutal choice. Either those businesses are run so as to yield maximum profit, or dividends and share prices will tumble.

Profit isn't an optional extra for a company trying to keep its share prices high. It is a cruel and jealous god, tolerating no rivals.

The Tories understand that. They have sacrificed all considerations of public service in order to get the utilities ripe for selling off. They have even promised to indemnify the future private electricity supply companies against the extra costs of nuclear power.

Labour should understand that too. The enterprises denationalised by the Tories should be taken back into full public ownership, with compensation only on the basis of ensuring that small shareholders get back the money they originally put in.

Neil Kinnock would have done better to pay attention to the scientists debating at the British Association conference last week, rather than the baying Tory press. Professor lan Fells told the conference that market forces were "less than useless" in making sure that energy industries were developed in a sustainable and ecologically sound way.

"Reliance on market forces," he said, "to give the correct signals to the newly privatised power generation companies and entrepreneurial investors seems the most unreasonable optimism"

He spoke not from socialist principle, but from scientific calculation. "It may be that we are privatising our energy industries, however laudable the principle, at just the wrong time."

Labour's leaders say they represent socialist principle. In fact they are so scared of triumphant Toryism that they will not even listen to scientific calculations.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 416

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →