Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How the scandal broke

Socialist Organiser no. 416, 21 September 1989 · scan pp. 1–2 · about 1,197 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 1 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 1

24 August. . "Ulster Freedom Fighters" (alias for the Association) claim responsibility for the murder of Laughlin Maginn. Maginn had been harassed repeatedly by member of the UDR and RUC. One one occasion they had put a gun to his head and told him "We're going to get you" 30 August. UFF, claiming that Maginn was an IRA man, show a BBC reporter official files to back up this claim. 2 September. Unionist MP Peter Robinson says that he routinely receives copies of official riles on IRA suspects through the post. 4 September. It is revealed that Cameron Hastie, a corporal in the Royal Scots Regiment who had been convicted, together with an UDR soldier, of passing information unlawfully to another Protestant-bigot murder group, the UVF, is still serving with his regiment (in England). Hastie had received only a suspended sentence. 10 September. Two UDR soldiers are charged with the murder of Laughlin Maginn. One of them is also charged with the murder of Liam McKee on 24 June - another killing claimed by the UFF. 10 September. British Army admits that a secret document with details of nine IRA suspects is missing from a UDR base in Ballykinlar, Co. Down. 12 September.4 Margaret Thatcher visits Ireland to praise the UDR.

Turn back

Scan page 2

Key issue will be Labour conference's right to decide Pete Willsman from the Campaign for Democracy briefed 1 Constituency Labou Parties Conference last Saturday, 16 September, on the rulebook issues coming up at Labour Party conference on 1-6 October.

Debates at conference over trade union rights, over public ownership, over nuclear disarmament, he explained, will be empty unless the conference also gair the right to overrule the Policy Review in which Neil Kinnock has spelled out his intention to keep many Tory anti-union laws, to manage the capitalist market economy, and to Britain's nuclear weapons until they negotiated away internationally.

f you think back to the victories we had on reselection and the electoral college, we were constantly being told at that time that party constitutional issues were diversionary.

We shouldn't be talking about internal issues; we should be concentrating on broader campaigning among the public and winning elections.

have put in resolutions and amendments in that section. It is the key battle at this year's conference.

Last year, when the leadership forced through the Policy Review, a lot of people said we should be allowed to amend it. The National Executive said they would see what they could do about it. Of course, they never had any intention of allowing amendments. If you present the Policy Review on an all-ornothing basis, you can get through anything you like, because the trade unions will vote for it rather than defeat it en bloc.

In February at the National Executive, Dennis Skinner put a resolution that amendments should be allowed to the Policy Review, and that was defeated by 23 votes to In June a comrade from the CLPD wrote to Neil Kinnock's office to ask why he wasn't allowing amendments to the Policy Review. Neil Kinnock's office wrote back and said that no declaration had been made that there could be no amendments to the Policy Review.

The CLPD sent out a model resolution which said that resolutions carried at conference should take precedence over the Policy Review. We used the word "precedence" because we were worried that if we used the word "amendment" it would be ruled out of order; but it wasn't, and we've asked constituencies to put in amendments saying "be treated as amendments to" rather than "take precedence over"

Many unions are not willing to vote for the formula "take precedence over» , but will vote for "be treated as amendments to"

That will be the big battle at conference - on Sunday evening, before the television cameras start. Of course, our proposal is not by any means foolproof, because even if resolutions are *treated as amendments" Kinnock can still ignore them, but it is going some way down the road.

We are also trying for a stronger proposal as a second composite. This will say that when a resolution is carried at conference which contradicts the Policy Review, we should then have a second vote between the Policy Review and the resolution. Then the Policy Review would be defeated on that issue.

There are also two resolutions in Last year's Labour Party conference so that we'll have an MPs' section, a constituencies' section, a coun cillors' section, a regional section, and so on. They also want to have the conference once every two years, not every year.

These proposals are being put forward as something new and progressive for the 1990s. However, almost identical proposals were in a pamphlet put out by the Campaign for Labour Victory - Shirley Williams, Bill Rodgers and David Owen - in the late 1970s. For 20 or 50 years the right-wing have been trying to destroy conference; it's nothing new.

As well as the GMB motion, there is a National Executive consultation paper which will go out to constituencies - it's important that every constituency sends a critique back.

Three constituencies have submitted a proposal to give more votes at party conference to the constituencies. The leadership want to muddle this up with the general plan to restructure conference, but we've got to keep the issues separate.

More votes for constituencies is an issue which we've been pushing for ten years. Year after year conference has agreed to give constituencies more votes, and there have been three working parties on the issue. Last year a motion was carried saying that the National Executive should bring a constitutional amendment to give constituencies more votes to this conference. They have ratted on that and produced no such amendment; they've just produced another consultation paper, trying to use more votes for constituencies as a carrot to help get through their other ideas.

Our view is that we should hold the National Executive to the decision of last year. The constitution should be amended this year to give constituencies more votes.

The GMB have also poked their nose in on the women's organisation. There are a number of resolutions from constituencies demanding a 40 per cent minimum quota of women in the National Executive and among Labour candidates and representatives. The GMB have got an amendment which gives lip service to the principle but omits any definite timetable.

On black sections, the issues are still not entirely sorted out. They have been remitted to the next National Executive. It's a question of whether the National Executive will agree to a Black Socialist Society affiliated to the Labour Party like the Fabian Society, and whether it's a Black Society based on selfdefinition as black.

Koy Hattersley is trying to stop it, and there's a huge argument over whether the National Executive agrees to this Black Society. If it does, then black members will have a place on the National Executive through it. Black Sections are very worried that the National Executive will renege on it, so they have a fallback position of their own.

Those are the key issues of party democracy at this year's conference.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 416

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →