Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How the capitalists remember their revolution

Socialist Organiser no. 415, 14 September 1989 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 4,238 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

From page In its place, the proletariat could not and would not have acted otherwise. That the spokesman of the "mob", , the Montagnards, no less than the Girondists, held on high the principle of liberty and law is proved by the constitution they formulated, the freest ever written in France. The constitution introduced direct legislation by representatives of the people and limited the powers of the executive to a minimum. However, because of the entire external and internal conditions of France, it became impossible for the Montagnards to apply the constitution.

Generally speaking, it may be regarded as a rule permitting no exceptions, that a given social class or layer of the population, having come to power, will the more readily resort to measure of terror if its chances to retain power are small. In the 19th century, it had to become clear to the bourgeoisie that its rule over the proletariat was becoming more shaky every day and, in consequence, it now strives more and more for terroristic subjection of the same. Against the June insurgents it proceded more ferociously than in 1831 against the weavers of Lyon; and in the suppression of the Communards of 1871 it acted far more atrociously than in June 1848.

The terror practiced by the bourgeoisie against the proletariat overshadows by far the atrocities of the Jacobins which, by the way, have been greatly exaggerated by the reactionaries. Robespierre, when compared with Thiers, looks like a veritable angel, and Marat, put side by side with the bourgeois press cossacks of the bloody May week, appears like a mild, benevolent being. He who looks deeper into the French history of our century must fully agree with the Russian writer, Herzen, when, after the June days, he said that there was no more ferocious government, and there could not be a more ferocious one, than that of the shopkeeper running amuck.

It was just this shopkeeper ferocity which made impossible a permanent consolidation of political freedom in France. The bourgeoisie must be held solely responsible for the reactionary lapses that typify the history of France in the 19th century. Even during the time of the Restoration the victory of the reactionaries was made much easier because the bourgeoisie, mortally afraid of the workers, for a long time prevented their entrance upon the struggle.

And now, for the sake of tranquilizing the bourgeois writers, who shudder at the mere thought of the Jacobin rule of terror, we shall present a truth which to us seems irrefutable. The victory of the workclass, now impending in all civilised countries, is certain not to be marred by cruelty, because the victory of the cause of labour is made secure the course of history to such an extent that no terror will be needed. Of course, the bourgeois reactionaries will be well advised if they abstain from trying to trip up a victorious proletariat, and are judicious enough not to imitate the royalist conspirators of the great revolution. "A la guerre comme a la guerre" (in war act as in war, ie. as war makes necessary) is a true saying, and in the heat of the fight it might go hard with the plotters. But, we repeat, the entire course of historic evolution guarantees the success of the proletariat.

On the occasion of the celebration of the centennial anniversary of the great revolution, the French bourgeoisie has almost purposely proceeded to demonstrate to the proletariat ad oculos (to the eyes) the economic possibility and necessity of a social transformation. The world exhibition gave it an excellent demonstration of the unprecedented development of the means of production in all civilised countries, which has outwinged the boldest fantasies of the utopians of the preceding century. In keeping therewith, the emancipation of the proletariat, instead of the noble dream it was at the time of Babeut, has become an historic necessity.

The exhibition has shown, furthermore, that the modern development of the means of production, under the anarchic conditions. governing production, must logically and necessarily lead to industrial crises ever more destructive to world economy. In order to escape the dangerous consequences of these crises, nothing is left for the European proletariat but to lay the foundation stone for the planful organisation of social production which, for the sansculottes of the past century, was a thing impossible. Not only do the modern production forces make possible such an organisation, but they tend in that direction. Without such an organisation the full utilisation of these forces is not to be thought of.

In the modern mechanical workshop production has already taken on a social character; all that is now needed is to bring into harmony the different productive functions in these workshops and, in keeping therewith, transform the ownership of the product, ie. change it from private to social ownership. To attain this aim will be the task of the European proletariat. The International Socialist Congress, meeting in July 1989, did not fail to remind the proletariat of this great task.

And now back to OUT philosopher, Paul Janet, of whom we have lost sight for a while. Just now he presents himself with the assertion that one "must remain true to the spirit of the revolution, but must reject the revolutionary spirit. In other words, manking must be satisfied with the results of the great revolution attained by the bourgeoisie, but must not take another step forward.

But we hold the very opposite is true. The aims of the bourgeoisie cannot possibly by those of the working class, and the results attained by the former cannot satisfy the latter. And, therefore, the workers go one step further when they reject the bourgeois spirit of the great revolution, but remain true to the revolutionary spirit. To remain true to that means to struggle ceaselessly and fearlessly for a better future, to struggle implacably against all that is old and obsolete.

The bourgeoisie would fain instill into the workers' minds the idea that modern society knows no class divisions, because the foundation of the modern state is the equality of all before the law. But this formal equality can console the workers as little as, under the old regime, the proclaimed equality of all before God satisfied bourgeoisie; not content with this fantastic equality, the bourgeoisie did not rest until it had come into possession of all possible mundane goods. Small wonder then that the proletariat will not be content with juristic fictions, knowing full well that economic inequality must in real life render illusory all other equality.

In much the same manner the bourgeoisie would make the workers believe that, today, there is nothing more to be done in the realm of the economy and that, therefore, one must only indulge in the game of "pure" politics. But "pure politics means for the workers nothing but kite-tail politics in the service of the bourgeois parties, 'and the bourgeoisie is fully aware of the significance of this brand of "pure politics", at least such was the case Robespierre, July 1794 when it was engaged in the struggle, with the nobility and clergy.

In the brochure "Qu'est-ce que le Tiers Etat" ["What is the Third Estate"] once before mentioned which must be regarded as the programme of the bourgeoisie of 1789, the sophistries of the "pure politicians" , then to be found in the two upper estates, were refuted with much talent. Abbé Sieyès insisted that the nation, as a matter of fact, was divided into two camps, in the one, the privileged; in the other, the oppressed; and that this actual division must be reflected in politics. It was natural and understandable that the privileged should seek to preserve their interests by means of political measures; but the oppressed also must not neglect the safeguarding of their interests, and should appear as a unified party in the newly opened political arena.

To this very day this lesson has not suffered in either sense or importance. Conditions have changed only insofar as the bourgeoisie today occupies a privileged position. And what else is now left for the workers but to close their ranks in a separate party of the oppressed, standing opposition to the privileged bourgeoisie?

At the end of the 18th century, at the time of "the great rebellion" of the French "mob" , the class antagonism between bourgeoisie and proletariat was present only in embryo. For that reason the class consciousness of the proletarians had to be rather unclear. When, in the course of this treatise, we tried to explain the argumentation of Paul Janet relative to the Jacobin conceptions of "the people" ascribed to them an attitude antagonistic to all classes living on the labour of others. That was really the only possible meaning of the argument of the author.

However, this is correct only insofar as the Montagnards, in reality and instinctively, always strove to defend the interests of the poorest class of the population. This was so because in their conception there was present a feature which, in the course of further evolution, would have taken on thoroughly bourgeois character. This teature shows up plainly in the speeches of Robespierre. And through it is to be explained the struggle of the Jacobins against the Hebertists, and in general their struggle against the so-called agrarian legislation.

But these "agrarian laws" , as their adherents pictured them to themselves, contained nothing that was of a communist character. Private property, and the petty bourgeois purposes closely connected therewith, forced themselves into the programmes of even the most extreme revolutionists of the time. Babeuf alone took a different stand; he appeared in the last act of the great tragedy, when the strength of the proleriat had already been wholly exhausted in the preceding struggles. The party of the Mountain failed just because of that innermost contradiction between its petty bourgeois conceptions and its endeavour to be a representative of proletarian interests.

To the present-day representatives of the working class these contradictions are foreign, because modern, scientific socialism nothing but the theoretic expression of the unbridgeable antagonism of interests between bourgeoisie and proletariat. The impending victory of the working class under the banner of socialism is going to be far more glorious than all the "glorious" revolutions of the bourgeoisie put together.

Force, naked force, based upon bayonets and cannon, becomes more and more the only support of bourgeois rule. And candid "theoreticians" make their appearance, who admit without further ado that the prevailing bourgeois order cannot be justified theoretically, and does not require such justification - because the bourgeoisie controls the public powers. Thus, for instance, speaks an Austrian professor, Gumplowicz, in his book "The Political State and Socialism'.

When the representatives of the nobility and clergy, in one of the first sessions of the estates, fell back upon the foundation of their privileges - the historic right of conquest - the theoretician of the bourgeoisie, Abbé Sieyes, proudly replied: "Rien que cela, messieurs? Nous serons conquerants a notre tour!" - which means, Nothing but that, gentlemen? Well, we too shall be conquerors in our turn!"

And the working class must say fust that to the advocates of bourgeois force.

Dates 5 May 1789: King Louis XVI convenes the Estates General. 17 June 1789: The 'Third Estat (everyone except the nobles and clergy) declare themselves the National Assembly. 14 July 1789: Storming of the Bastille, the royal prison in Paris. 4 August 1789: National Assembly decrees abolition of feudal privileges. 5 October 1789: Women march from Paris to the royal palace at Versailles, force the king to come to Paris and to ratify the decisions of the National Assembly. 20 June 1791: King attempts toescape from Paris to join counter-revolutionaries abroad; is intercepted and brought back. 20 April 1792: France declares war on Austria, whose monarchy has family links with France's. 10 August 1792: People of Paris storm the Tuileries (the royal palace in Paris); bring the Girondin faction to power. 21 January 1793: King Louis XVI guillotined.

March 1793: Mass counterrevolutionary peasant rising in the Vendee district of western France. 4 May 1793: First 'Law of the Maximum', fixing maximum prices for bread. 29-30 May 1793: Lyon, France's second city, taken over by moderates and counter-revolutionaries. 31 May-2 June 1793: New rising in Paris results in the expulsion of the Girondin leaders from the Convention (parliament) and the rise to power of the Jacobin or Montagnard faction. 5 September 1793: Rising in Paris pushes Jacobin government towards the policies of the Terror: sweeping rice and wage controls, "revolutionary armies"' to requisition grain from the countryside, the guillotine for counter-revolutionaries. 27 July 1794: (Thermidor" by the revolutionary calendar): the Jacobin leader Robespierre is ousted and guillotined, and soon power shifts from the Jacobins to the moderates.

Names The Girondin faction were the most moderate republicans, so called because many of their leaders came from the Gironde area, round the great port of Bordeaux.

The Mountain, Montagnard, or Jacobin faction were the most radical wing of the bourgeosie. Their leaders were Robespierre, Danton, Marat, and Saint-Just. "Sans-culottes": according to all modern research, the decisive force in all the sans-culotte institutions were not those who had no property at all - labourers, servants, beg-l gars, and so on - but urban working people who were also small property-owners, shopkeepers, craft workers with small workshops, cafe owners, and so on. There was no cohesive industrial working class in the modern sense. "Agrarian laws': proposals to up the land equally and give everyone a smallholding.

Scan page 9

Riot police are the South African state's answer to the black working class. Negotiations are reserved for right-wing black Both the South African government and the opposition groups around the African National Congress are talking about negotiations in South Africa, though the conditions set for talks by the two side: are still miles apart. This article from the Cape Action League, socialist group in South Africa, reviews the prospects.

It one end of the spectrum A ot possibilities, the presumed framework within which such a negotiated settlement would be hammered out is some confederal-federal constitution based on ethnic/racial groups. At present, only the compradore black middle class is willing to go that way. Very recently in Munich, West Germany, even the wily Chief Buthelezi has indicated that he and his party are willing to consider that road provided certain other conditions such as the release of all political prisoners were effected. Quite logically, therefore, the National Party government is at present "negotiating" with precisely these compradore elements.

At the other end of the spectrum, the presumed framework within which a settlement would be negotiated is the unitary, non-racial, non-ethnic South African state. This is the direction within which the vast majority of the people of South Africa are moving. This is indeed the mass line of the liberation movement at present. This is what has given to the Charterist movement, taken globally, the popularity it has experienced in recent years. For - let it be stated clearly the armed propaganda of the African National Congress, together with the momentous insurrectionary wave of the period 1984-86, kindled in the hearts of the masses South Africa the hope —*a realistic one as many of them believed that sooner rather than later the South African regime would move towards the negotiation table. For the moment, that particular option has led into a cul-de-sac.

By way of completing this discussion on the different possibilities of a negotiated settlement, let us state that most liberals in South Africa believe that some blending of colours, some centre-left point on the spectrum can be found where the two extremes can meet and avert a cataclysmic, Palestine or Lebanonlike conflict.

In this, they have recently been encouraged not only by most Western governments and liberal or social-democratic opposition groups but even more importantly by historic shifts in the Southern African strategy of the Soviet Union. If reports emanating from that country and papers by Soviet Africanists delivered and discussed at numerous seminars and conferences are anything to go by, it would seem that the Soviet leadership has become convinced that an armed conquest of power by the national liberation movement South Africa is beyond the capacity of that movement however defined) and that, consequently, it would be more effective to work towards a negotiated settlement of the conflict in the rather distant future (at least ten years). As for socialism, Dr Victor Goncharov, who is said to be "a leading Soviet analyst on Africa", reckoned "op. timistically" that perhaps in another 100 years South Africa would attain to this desirable state.

Be that as it may: we are entitled in terms of our analytical thrust, to raise the question under which conditions OT circumstances negotiated settlement between the South African ruling class and the black working class would be possi Posed in this form, it immediately becomes evident that as in every other civil war in which the major classes in a social formation are struggling for dominance — these conditions are extremely unlikely to occur.

Civil wars involving exploiting and exploited classes are seldom resolved by compromise; where strata of exploiting classes find themselves in conflicting camps, compromise and negotiation are certainly possible (compare, for example, the Philippines recently), but this is not the case in South Africa. One of the ineluctable consequences of the system of racial capitalism is that the black working class has to and will lead the the struggle for liberation.

The black middle class has to and does decide whether to align itself with the black working class or with the white bourgeoisie in whatever guise; it cannot act independently and its class location in the racial capitalist order is such that it cannot win over the white bourgeoisie and the white working class to accept its preferred solutions. The stark choice before it is either to sell out (as some have done to the racists or to go with the movement of the black working class. That movement, objectively, is not simply against racial discrimination but against class exploitation and hence against capitalism. It is a movement against apartheid understood as the present socio-economic and socio-political form of the racial capitalist system. We are not involved in a struggle against a feudal ruling class nor are we struggling directly against foreign imperialist overlord. Our struggle is against the local white capitalist class and its domestic and foreign allies.

At present, a large section even of the organised black working class is trapped mystifying OCLLY traurgeois belief that it is possiblety disentangle racial discrimination and capitalist exploitation in the peculiar historical conditions of South Africa. All manner of propagandists teach them that what academic boffins and party political called "the system of racial domination" in South Africa was superimposed on "the system of class domination" which is notionally no different from that which obtains in any other capitalist society. At the bottom of this particular mystification lies an idealtypical "capitalism" which has never existed anywhere except in the academic abstractions of freeenterprise economists starting with Adam Smith. Hence the deracialisation of the polluted capitalist system is seen as stage one of the struggle in South Africa. Consequently, a negotiated settlement which will leave the basic free enterprise system intact is postulated as a possibility that has to be made into a necessity.

It is our view that only the unlimited internationalisation of the conflict in South Africa could bring about conditions in which some such negotiated settlement would become possible. However, the military costs of such a course of action would be prohibitive and given the lack of any deep commitpoliticians like Buthelezi. ment to, or interest it important Southern capitalist nations and in the Soviet Union, it is unlikely that this path would prove to be popular. Even the first resort of the anti-apartheid movement, namely, the demand for comprehensive mandatory sanctions against the South African regime, cannot be implemented without a prohibitive mobilisation of resources by all the major industrial countries of the world.

Without this internationalisation, a negotiated settlement within the unitary framework referred to before is not going to come about. Botha, Heunis, Malan and Co., just like any other regime in any other African country will not hand over power to the leaders of the exploited classes just because they are appealed to on grounds of morality and so-called Western civilisation. Nothing could be further from reality than this scenario.

In the short to medium term, they will try to accommodate the augmentation of economic and political power by the black working class and black middle class by "Broadening democracy" in their sense of the term, ie, by trying to co-opt as large a layer of the middle class as possible by tying them into the racial capitalist order and neutralising those who refuse to defend neo-apartheid. Those who choose to go with the black working class in quest of political and economic freedom will continue to feel the jackboot of repression.

If a negotiated settlement of the conflict in South Africa is not on the agenda, in spite of all appearances to the contrary, what, then, is the alternative? In a nutshell, we have to steel ourselves for a war of position, a long march not through the institutions but for building up new institutions and organs of workers' power.

Until recently, the ideology of the black petty bourgeoisie was hegemonic in the national liberation movement. During the next decade the ideology of the black working class will become hegemonic in our movement. More and more, the youth and the conscious organised workers in South Africa are realising that in the present world democracy comes through socialism and not vice versa.

The fact that there are few if any models that can be used immediately is neither strange nor discouraging in the epoch of the transition from capitalism to socialism. In the coming decade, the values, the practices and the embryonic organisations appropriate to a socialist Azania will be established and consolidated in the process of building a national through our day-to-day resistance to oppression, exploitation and repression.

Whenever conditions permit, we shall mobilise our people on the largest possible scale in order to entrench the traditions of socialist struggle which flow out of the traditions of our decades-long struggle for national liberation. The hegemonic black working class will attempt through its organisations to occupy every empty space in the social formation, to capture new areas by forcing the ruling class to bring about fundamental empowering reforms such as the right to form trade unions, the abolition of pass laws, group areas, etc. This will be done through mass mobilisation, not by accepting the racist constitutional framework of the rulers. By means of such actions, the political ecology will be changed fundamentally, the parameters within which all the classes of the social formation can make decisions will be shifted in favour of the goals and strategies of the black working class.

We have time to mention only three kinds of factors that need to be considered. Firstly, the enhancement of economic and military strength of the neighbouring states constitutes a plus point for our struggle today. Hence, our strategy should embrace this goal at all times and we need to support all progressive regimes in the region that are not opposed to a socialist Azania.

Secondly, we have to look carefully at what is happening to the composition of the South African Defence Force. To what extent is its class and "racial" comIssue No.1 position changing? Is this a factor of significance in our strategy?

What tactics flow from our assessment?

Lastly, and certainly not least, we have to create a national liberation front of all the forces that are opposed to the racial capitalist order.

We have to build a People's Parliament in exile on the model of the PLO, in which tendencies with different programmes are represented and tolerated. This implies that all notions of sole authentic representative status by any of the present liberation organisations operating internationally should be jettisoned as being divisive, destructive and not reflective of the situation on the ground in Azania.

Despite the undoubted popularity of the Charterist current in South Africa at present, there are significant other tendencies and organisations, all of which have the potential under conditions favourable to their particular visions of the future, to mobilise the oppressed millions of our compatriots. It would be strange if in a relatively advanced capitalist country it would be otherwise.

All of us hope, of course, that in spite of different analyses, approaches and assessments, there is enough common ground among us to make possible the converging of our oganisations. From within such an overarching structure as suggested here, we will be able to give overall direction to the movement of the toiling masses of Azania against the racist regime and its capitalist backers. In such a structure, too, it can be decided from time to time whether or not to enter into tactical alliances with elements that are merely opposed to the superficial or phenomenal aspects of the system.

Frontline Worker incorporating Azania Frontline Azania Worker No. 13 August 1989 Subscription rates to FRONTLINE United Kingdom and Eire Individuals £9.00 Institutions £14.00 rates on application for the unemployed ani South African students or freedom fighters Frontline Worker BM Box 4863 London WC1N 3XX

Scan page 10

of facing reality

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 415

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →